Preface
In April 2015 the Yale National Initiative to strengthen teaching in public schools® accepted public school
teachers from twenty school districts in eight states and the District of Columbia to participate in six
national seminars held at Yale University. The Initiative is a long-term endeavor to influence public policy on
teacher professional development, in part by establishing exemplary Teachers Institutes for high-need schools in
states around the country.
Teachers Institutes are educational partnerships between universities and school districts designed to strengthen
teaching and learning in a community’s high-need public schools. Evaluations have shown that the Institute
approach exemplifies the characteristics of high-quality teacher professional development, enhances teacher
quality in the ways known to improve student achievement, and encourages participants to remain in teaching in
their schools.
Seven of the Yale National Fellows came from school districts that are participating for the first time this
year: District of Columbia Public Schools; Franklin‐McKinley School District in San José, CA; and
Cape Henlopen School District, Indian River School District, and Polytech School District in Delaware. Forty-two
of the Yale National Fellows are from school districts that already are planning or exploring the establishment
of a new Teachers Institute for the Bay Area, CA; Chicago, IL; the Diné Nation, AZ and NM; Pittsburgh,
PA; Richmond, VA; San José, CA; and Tulsa, OK. Other National Fellows came from school districts with
existing Teachers Institutes located in New Castle County, DE; New Haven, CT; and Philadelphia, PA. Overall,
nearly two thirds of the National Fellows were participating for the first time.
The National Fellows attended an Organizational Session of the seminars held in New Haven on May 8-9. The
seminars reconvened during a ten-day Intensive Session from July 6-17 and concluded in mid-August when the
Fellows submitted their completed curriculum units. The six seminars were:
- “Literature and Information,” led by Jessica Brantley, Associate Professor of English;
- “Explaining Character in Shakespeare,” led by Paul H. Fry, Professor of English;
- “Problem Solving and the Common Core,” led by Roger E. Howe, Professor of Mathematics;
- “History in our Everyday Lives: Collective Memory, Historical Writing, and Public History,” led
by Mary T. Y. Lui, Professor of History and of American Studies;
- “Using Film in the Classroom,” led by Brigitte Peucker, Professor of Film Studies and of German;
and
- “Physiological Determinants of Global Health,” led by W. Mark Saltzman, Professor of Chemical
and Biomedical Engineering.
The purposes of the program are to provide public school teachers deeper knowledge of the subjects they teach and
first-hand experience with the Teachers Institute approach. This increases their leadership in an existing
Teachers Institute or prepares them to lead the development of a new Teachers Institute. Each teacher writes a
curriculum unit to teach his or her students about the seminar subject and to share with other teachers in their
school district and, over the Internet, with teachers anywhere. The curriculum units contain five elements:
content objectives, teaching strategies, examples of classroom activities, lists of resources for teachers and
students, and an appendix on the district academic standards the unit implements. In these ways the curriculum
units assist teachers in engaging and educating the students in their school courses.
The curriculum units National Fellows wrote are their own; they are presented in six volumes, one for each
seminar.
The Yale-New Haven Teachers Institute® is a permanently endowed unit of Yale University, which undertook the
National Initiative in 2004.
James R. Vivian
New Haven
August 2015
Introduction by
Jessica C. Brantley, Associate Professor of English
Literature and Information: admittedly, it’s not a narrow topic. One of my high school teachers
had a poster on her desk that read, “What in the world isn’t chemistry?” But one
might better ask: what in the world isn’t either literature or information? In order to make sense of this
broad topic for those who were not a part of this Yale National Initiative seminar, this introduction will
address how and why the concept of the seminar developed, as well as what is at stake for us in thinking today
about the relation of literature to information in the classroom, or (for this is what we really mean when we
use those words) the relation of fiction to nonfiction.
The first thing at stake is a conversation about educational policy nationwide. The Common Core, now adopted by
nearly all of the 50 states, mandates changes in the distribution of fiction and nonfiction across the K-12
curriculum: literature on the one hand, and “reading for information” on the other. The scariest
number, for teachers of English literature, is the expected 70/30 split for high school students between
nonfiction and fiction. The proposal is that 70 percent of what students read should be
nonfiction—ostensibly to prepare them better for the kinds of reading that they will need to do in life,
and particularly for the kinds of reading that they will need to do on the job. This preference for nonfiction
is worth questioning for many reasons, not least of which is the instrumentalizing of education for the purposes
of the workplace. But even if we accept the premise that students are primarily in training to be good workers,
there are strong arguments supporting the value of reading imaginative writing, with its complexity of language
and richness of ambiguity, to train students’ critical and analytical faculties. It is not clear to me, at
least, that reading poems or novels is worse preparation for the kinds of thinking one needs to do as a
productive citizen than reading Op-Eds.
Moreover (and this has been a main concern of articlespublished in the popular press recently)1 the
necessity to squeeze literature into ever smaller parts of the school year has led also to the frequent
excerpting of fiction, such that students never have the opportunity, or the challenge, of reading a whole
novel, or engaging in a sustained way with a writer’s craft over an extended period of time. Instead,
students read excerpts of novels in order to connect their themes with contemporary concerns, further
impoverishing the experience of reading. Should we be teaching Tom Sawyer in order to think about youth
unemployment? Or teaching King Lear to get to debates about end-of-life issues? As important as those
topics are in contemporary society, works of literature such as these—as some rightly point out in letters
to the editor—have much more to offer than that. The commerce between the present and the past should go
in both directions, and works of literature are ends in themselves, not only means to relevancy.
But even as there are some horror stories coming out of this new emphasis on nonfiction, there are some
opportunities, too, for lovers of language—or at least I hope there are. First of all, it seems that the
new guidelines run the risk of some crucial misunderstandings: the balance of nonfiction to fiction advocated by
the Common Core is not to be 70/30 in English alone, but across the whole curriculum. Indeed, a student’s
English class might account for the 30 percent of fiction, filled with all of the novels, short stories, poetry,
and drama that classes in English literature have always offered. Part of the idea, I think, is to suggest that
students should be reading more quality nonfiction in their other classes—in history, science, even
mathematics. And here there is an opportunity: if students could be reading not only nonfiction, but
good nonfiction (“quality”), across the curriculum, then they could be growing constantly
as readers, writers, and thinkers. In this optimistic vision of things, students are not to be reading
instruction manuals or train schedules (this was the nightmare scenario some had feared), and they are not even
to be reading an American history textbook. Instead, they should be grappling with some of the most amazing
writing that both underlies and communicates that history: Jefferson’s “Declaration of
Independence,” Lincoln’s “Gettysburg Address,” Douglass’s “What to the Slave
is the Fourth of July?”
The primary way to combat the problems of the Common Core, and at the same time to take advantage of the
opportunities the new curriculum represents, is to make sure that the nonfiction we’re asking our students
to read is “quality” (an elusive measure of value, of course). But there are also other strategies.
One of these is to take advantage of the suggestions here for rich interdisciplinary study across many modes of
discourse: fiction and nonfiction, but also the performing and visual arts: theater, music, dance, painting,
sculpture, photography. Crossing among these modes forces us to think critically about how we understand them:
what do we do when we read fiction? Or nonfiction? Are our methods of interpretation that different?
Because the goal of all good seminars should be confusing the categories we thought we had understood, the first
thing we read in the organizational session of “Literature and Information” was an essay by
historian Hayden White, “The Historical Text as Literary Artifact.”2 The argument of this
provocative essay is made by its title: the historical text, far from being a transparent accounting of events,
should be thought of as a narrative, shaped like any narrative by the rhetorical needs of its author and its
audience. White suggests that we should think of any historical narrative as a story being told from a
perspective and for a reason. Just as we glean information from literature, so we can treat
“informational” texts (nonfiction of the right kind) as “literature.” When White calls
the historical text a “literary artifact,” he signals both something about the status of the
text—what it is—and also something about how it is used—how we read it, and
in what spirit we approach it. If the historical text is a literary artifact, that means we can apply to it the
techniques of reading that prove most helpful when we read fiction. We can ask about its structure and its form,
as well as its content. We can ask about its audience and its context; we can analyze the rhetorical devices
that make it persuasive, or not.
White’s basic proposition—that historical writing is itself a kind of fiction—provided a
theoretical provocation for our more practical thinking about the relation of literature to information in the
remainder of the YNI seminar. We began to think about these two rich modes of writing in conversation with each
other by reading Anne Fadiman’s The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down, a compelling and
beautiful example of creative nonfiction that shows how a young Hmong girl’s epilepsy reveals the
differences between her family’s culture and the cultures of American medicine.3 Like
White’s essay, Fadiman’s book argues that histories and stories, fact and fiction, cannot be
definitively separated from each other. In the intensive session, we continued to read some of the best examples
of both imaginative fiction and imaginative nonfiction that we could find, in order to explore how the YNI
Fellows might weave the two together, productively separating and also combining them, in the curriculum units
they were writing.
Our seminar Fellows included teachers who teach across the K-12 spectrum—from kindergarteners to high
school seniors—and the subjects of the units accordingly vary quite a lot. But precisely because we all
face different pedagogical situations, both the seminar discussion and the curriculum units proved to be
especially rich. Moreover, given our diversity, it was surprising how consistent the units in some ways proved
to be: like White and Fadiman, all of the unitsultimately imply that we construct ourselves through the
stories—fictional or nonfictional—that we tell.
Several of the units took up the topic of culture through the lens of fiction and nonfiction. Joseph Parrett
(“Defining Culture through the Lens of Literature and Text in Kindergarten”) and Nadra Ruff
(“Different Cultures in Chicago’s Neighborhoods: Chinese and Mexican Communities”) both wrote
units that introduce young students to the Mexican and Chinese cultures through story, song, image, and history.
Taking advantage of the ways in which multimedia can inspire imaginations, both Fellows seek to present
differences among cultures that might vary substantially, as well as similarities among human societies that
share many features in common. LeTanya James (“Farming, Food, and a Balanced Navajo Lifestyle”) has
constructed a unit that draws on her own cultural knowledge close to home: Navajo foodways and food histories
form the basis of a unit that seeks to inform children in the Diné Nation about healthy eating, a unit
that will teach young students new concepts by connecting them to their own cultural history with food and
farming.
Several of the units designed for older students used fiction and nonfiction to explore the ways in which
storiescan be used to construct societies for good or ill. Teresa Rush (“Dystopian Societies in Adolescent
Literature: Can Compliance and Freedom Coexist Peacefully in a Dark, Dystopian World?”) wrote a unit about
dystopian fictions, a very popular genre currently for adolescents in both novel and film. She hopes to use
nonfiction to challenge her students to think about why fictions of this sort are so compelling. What
connections can be made to history? To our own experience of communal life? Luke Holm (“Helping Students
‘See Beyond the Pale’”) also hopes to open his students’ eyes to more than they usually
see about the society they live in. Inspired by his students’ potential, he hopes to provide them with
critical tools to better understand their world and to make good choices about their contributions to life on
earth. Keisha Wheat (“Words of Patriotism: The Pledge of Allegiance”) will use her unit to inspire
much younger students to make similarly good choices as citizens, as they open their eyes to the implications of
extremely familiar words: the pledge of allegiance. Her students will be inspired by each phrase of the pledge
to think hard about what citizenship means for them, and how they can productively be a part of this nation.
Julie So (“Biographies and Autobiographies: Portraits of Peacebuilders”) also hopes to inspire her
young students with words, biographies of great figures who can model peace building behaviors for her own
students’ developing stories—their autobiographies.
The history of this nation provides many compelling stories taken up by a final group of units. Joyce Arnosky
(“Wandering Through The Bad Times: Children Making Their Way Through the Great Depression”) has
written a unit based on award-winning fiction, as well as on letters, newspaper accounts, photos, and songs from
the period of the Great Depression, harnessing the power of interdisciplinary experience to provide her students
with a sense of the era from the perspective of its children. Valerie Schwarz’s unit (“Jim Crow,
Civil Rights, and the Integration of Schools”) takes in both local Richmond and national histories of
school integration, using prize-winning fiction as well as historical documents to create an account of the
events and emotions of the struggle. Krista Waldron (“Race and Riot: Exploring Tulsa’s Conflicts in
Fiction, Nonfiction, and Image”) also has based her unit on a locally specific event—the 1921 race
riots in Tulsa, OK. But she shows how that event can be understood in light of very recent developments around
race and law enforcement in the summer of 2015, as well. Her unit is both timely and timeless, both
geographically specific and inescapably relevant to any community in the US.
Jessica Brantley
Notes
- See, e.g., Kate Taylor, “English Class in the Common Core Era: ‘Tom Sawyer’ and Court
Opinions,” New YorkTimes, 19 June 2015.
- Hayden White, “The Historical Text as Literary Artifact,” from Tropics of Discourse: Essays
in Cultural Criticism (Baltimore and London: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1978), pp. 81-100.
- Anne Fadiman, The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down: A Hmong Child, Her American Doctors,
and the Collision of Two Cultures(New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux, 1997).
Synopsis of the Curriculum Units
15.01.01 - Wandering Through the Bad Times: Children Making Their Way Through the Great Depression
by Joyce Arnosky
This is a four-week interdisciplinary unit for fifth graders, but could be modified for middle school. The work
centers on literacy and social studies and aligns with the CCSS Reading Literature and Reading Informational Text
Standards. The goal of this unit is to help students strengthen and enhance their literacy skills as they do the
work of historians – examining the lives of children during the Depression. Understanding the past requires a
multi-faceted, critical approach and so is very much like what we want our students to do in terms of their reading
and writing work. Historians can’t simply rely on one account. They must consider and evaluate many sources in
their search for clues and evidence of the past. In this unit students will do close readings and analysis of
primary and secondary sources, literary nonfiction, memoir, and photographs. They will combine these sources of
informational text with reading historical novels in book club format, poetry, and songs from the period. Students
will also write across a variety of genres and for different purposes: journals, constructed responses, literary
analysis, poetry, expository essays, and fiction.
(Developed for Literacy and Social Studies, grade 5; recommended for Literacy and Social Studies, grades 6-8)
15.01.02 - Helping Students
by Luke Holm
In a world wrought by deceptive media, oil-made living, and constant consumerism, students are bombarded by
influential information every single day. The unit “Helping Students ‘See Beyond the
Pale’” is designed to develop critical thinking skills and awaken students’ minds to the truth of
the world around them. Using Paul Fleischman’s Eyes Wide Open, as well as various articles, videos,
and fictional short stories, students will explore the theme of environmentalism and how the world got to its
current state. Throughout the unit, students will explore subtopics such as advertising, lobbyism, world population,
consumerism, peak oil, and green energy.
This unit can be used for a wide range of academic grade levels. It is meant to introduce controversial topics to
students in a nonbiased and open atmosphere. Furthermore, the unit is designed to promote great autonomy in choosing
the various areas of focus. Students will engage in collegial discussions to enhance their understanding of
environmental topics and develop educated opinions about the world around them. By the end of this unit, students
will be inspired to think more deeply about their world and, in doing so, become active members of their community.
(Developed for Social Justice, grade 7; recommended for Elective, grades 7-12)
15.01.03 - Farming, Food and a Balanced Navajo Lifestyle
by LeTanya Krista James-Austin
This unit will assist Kindergarten and First Grade educators in teaching students about the importance of farming,
food and a balanced Navajo lifestyle. This unit will be taught in a three part timeline: a) Navajos and Farming b)
Fruits, Vegetables and Our Body and c) Navajos, Diabetes and Exercise. The unit will incorporate a variety of
fiction and non-fiction literature in the introduction and activities. The nonfiction book, “Farms Feed the
World” by Lee Henry Sullivan will serve as a basis and reference for the entire unit. The students will begin
by learning about the importance of farming and how food, specifically fruits and vegetables are farmed. After this,
they will gain a wealth of information about specific fruits and vegetables and how each of those foods will have an
effect on our body. We will be reading Finally, to end the unit the students will realize that in order to stay
healthy, they need to eat healthy foods and exercise on a daily basis. In the early years of academics, equally
integrating and exposing the power of fiction and non-fiction literature into every unit will enhance the learning
of our young scholars.
(Developed for English Language Arts and Science, grade K; recommended for English Language Arts and Science, grade
1)
15.01.04 - Defining Culture through the Lens of Literature and Text in Kindergarten
by Joseph Earl Parrett
This is a kindergarten unit that addresses Common Core State Standards in language arts. It also addresses the area
of social studies. The purpose of this unit is to help students define the concept of culture through the use of
children’s literature and expository text. Students will be exploring the Chinese and Mexican cultures. A part
of this activity is comparing and contrasting the Chinese, Mexican, and even American cultures. The class will read
paired texts seeking the “ingredients” that make up the “recipe” of culture.
“Ingredients” such as food, clothing, customs, and holidays are included. Students will be using
kindergarten reading skills that relate to actively participating, asking and answering questions, and writing.
Additionally, the class will be learning to make connections between different communities and the activities that
occur in those communities. Throughout the unit students will be sharpening their listening skills, their ability to
sort ideas and objects into categories, and their ability to write informatively or tell a story. This process can
be modified to other elementary grades.
(Developed for Language Art and Social Studies, grade K; recommended for Language Arts and Social Studies, grade 1)
15.01.05 - Different Cultures in Chicago's Neighborhoods: Chinese and Mexican Communities
by Nadra Ruff
This unit is designed for 3rd grade, but could be adapted for grades 4th-8th. The
school where the unit will be implemented is located in the Englewood Gresham area, one of Chicago Public Schools
hardest communities. The unit emphasizes the Common Core standards of literature and informational text and
addresses the social studies and language arts content areas. The main focus of the unit is to teach students about
immigration, geographical location, and cultural diversity. These concepts are achieved within this unit by teaching
the history, traditions, and commonalities and differences between the Chinese and Mexican American cultures in
relation to their geographical settlement in Chicago’s neighborhoods that surround the students’
communities. The unit will use literature and informational text at different reading and comprehension levels,
styles of print, and text features. The scope of this unit however, is not just to analyze the Chinese and Mexican
cultures but to enhance student’s cultural awareness by building their background knowledge with pieces about
the two cultures of study. By examining a historical sequence of events that took place for Chinese and Mexican
immigrants, this unit will offer students an understanding of how members of a culture meld into communities while
trying to maintain cultural identity and honor their ancestors.
(Developed for Language Arts and Social Studies, grade 3; recommended for Language Arts and Social Studies, grades
4-8)
15.01.06 - Dystopian Societies in Adolescent Literature: Can Compliance and Freedom Coexist Peacefully In A Dark, Dystopian World?
by Teresa Rush
In 1516, Sir Thomas More wrote the first ‘Utopia’, which began a long and rich tradition of imagining
both utopian (or ideal) societies and imperfect dystopian ones. Recently, there has been a spike in the popularity
of dystopian literature and movies. This type of literature is characterized by a bleak, dysfunctional future in
which anti-utopian events oppress the weaker class of a society. The ruling class uses various controlling agents to
obtain absolute power and establish their own personal utopias. These forms of control include corporate control,
bureaucratic control, technological control, and philosophical/religious control.
In this ninth grade English unit, students will explore the common and contrasting themes of the following
dystopian novels: The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins, The Maze Runner by James Dashner,
Divergent by Veronica Roth, The Giver by Lois Lowry, and Matched by Ally Condie. In these
novels, characters are faced with a lack of power and choice that force them and others who share their beliefs to
rise up against their oppressive governments. While reading, students will engage in literature circle activities,
close reading of dystopian and utopian articles, writing, and powerful discussions all centered on the Common Core
State Standards. As they engage in reading and writing activities, they will develop a deeper understanding of
whether or not compliance and freedom can coexist in a dark, dystopian world.
(Developed for English I, grade 9; recommended for English and English Language Arts, grades 7-10)
15.01.07 - Jim Crow, Civil Rights, and the Integration of Schools
by Valerie J. Schwarz
Jim Crow, Civil Rights, and the Struggle to Integrate Schools is a literature based curriculum unit that
combines history and language arts. The curriculum unit uses Jacqueline Woodson’s free verse memoir, Brown
Girl Dreaming as an anchor text, and provides a framework for making historical connections to the Jim Crow
and Civil Rights Eras. The stories of the Little Rock Nine and Davis v. Prince Edward County are told as a way to
view the aftermath of the Brown v. Board of Education decision. Throughout the unit, different genres of non-fiction
and fiction are brought together to help students make text-to-text, text-to-self, and text-to-world connections.
The unit also includes an interactive hands-on scavenger hunt to teach children about the Jim Crow Era through the
use of technology including: iPads and QR codes. A list of related resources, activities, informational texts, and
the actual verses with their ties to historical events are included. This unit is sure to engage students from the
intermediate grades through high school and can easily be adapted to reach high school English and history classes.
It also could be adapted to meet Common Core Standards.
(Developed for Language Arts and Social Studies, grade 4; recommended for English/Language Arts and History, grades
5-9)
15.01.08 - Biographies and Autobiographies: Portraits of Peace Builders
by Julie So Lizarraga
This unit helps K-2 teachers build upon foundational concepts of being peace builders in communities through study
of high quality literature and information. Topics include gender bias, multicultural role models, qualities of
heroes and peace builders. Influential peace builders mentioned include Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., Cesar Chavez,
Mahatma Gandhi, Florence Nightingale, Malala Yousafzai, and Wangari Maathai. Discovering through our readings the
formidable qualities of influential people compels young scholars to identify with these great leaders. With the
help of literature and information, students will examine these inner qualities and values developed in influential
peace builders and in themselves. I hope to spark their own expressive dreams of building peace in our community as
they create their own autobiographies: portraits of peace builders. Our children need to know that they truly are an
important part of the community and, even at their young age, they can make a world of difference. The unit meets
Common Core Reading Literature, Reading Information, and Writing standards. Background information of literature
genres related to young children, teaching strategies, and activity examples to bring out the best in our young
future heroes are provided.
(Developed for English Language Arts and History/Social Science, grade 1; recommended for English Language Arts and
History/Social Science, grades K-2)
15.01.09 - Revisiting Race and Riot: Exploring Tulsa’s Conflicts in Fiction, Nonfiction, and Image
by Krista Baxter Waldron
This unit comes from a seminar about fiction and nonfiction texts and effective pairing of the two. It addresses
Common Core standards and Oklahoma state standards. The first two thirds covers the 1921 race riot in Tulsa,
Oklahoma. We’ll look at context, causes, social themes, recovery, and the literary nature of all texts,
whether fictional or informational, primary or secondary. The last third connects the riot to more recent events
that include race and authority, including those we know the most: Trayvon Martin, Michael Brown, and Freddie Gray,
all of whom received international attention because their deaths seemed to be related to race and were not
necessary. Included texts and sources are fiction, nonfiction, poetry, and image. The anchor fiction is Rilla
Askew’s Fire in Beulah. The texts include news journalism—old and new, well-known essays,
online collections of images, Harlem Renaissance and new poems. This unit was written for middle and high school
classrooms. My students are middle and high school mixed into multi-grade classes. I teach at-risk and adjudicated
youth who for whom social justice issues are especially relevant and for whom academics have not been a priority.
Some strategies were selected with this in mind.
(Developed for English I, grade 9, English II, grade 10, and English III/IV, grades 11-12; recommended for
English/Language Arts and History/Social Studies, grades 8-12)
15.01.10 - Words of Patriotism: The Pledge of Allegiance
by Keisha Wheat
How do we know what makes us patriotic? What are our rights and responsibilities as citizens? The answers to these
questions and more can be found in this unit. "Words of Patriotism: The Pledge of Allegiance," is a cross curricular
unit addressing learning standards in both Language Arts and Social Studies. Even though this unit was written for
first grade students, the content can be modified for kindergarten through second grade. The Pledge of Allegiance
encompasses the ideals of our founding fathers: the ideas of liberty, justice, and citizenship. Students will make
connections to these concepts through the exploration of each phrase in the pledge. U.S. symbols such as the
American flag, the liberty bell, and the bald eagle are taught throughout the unit to give students access to visual
representations. Through the paired use of literary and informational text, students will explore the patriotic
roots of America. Each concept is introduced with a fictional text and the concept is further studied through the
use of non-fiction. Students will compare and contrast information found in both genres of text. In addition to
learning the Pledge of Allegiance and the Preamble to the Constitution of the United States, students will also
write a classroom pledge, classroom rules, and their own version of the preamble.
(Developed for Language Arts/Social Studies, grade 1; recommended for Language Arts/Social Studies, grades K-2)
Introduction by
Paul H. Fry, William Lampson Professor Emeritus of English
This was the third National Initiative seminar I have had the pleasure of leading on topics related to
Shakespeare. Our focus was “character,” and it was in part my hope to show that Shakespeare
transforms the role of character as Aristotle had prescribed it, with the continued approval of Renaissance
criticism and practice until Shakespeare. For Aristotle, character is subordinate to plot; it exists solely to
provide motivations for the events in a plot, and in order not to seem anomalous it must be plausible and
consistent within a given role. All teachers need to recognize that this is still the way we are taught to
understand dramatic characterization: a “tragic hero,” for example, is a noble person who has a
“tragic flaw” (pride, ambition, jealousy, devotion to private rather than public loyalties, etc.)
that brings about some reversal of fortune in the plot. Who doesn’t recognize that formula, and who has
managed to get through school without hearing it? Well, it works, more or less, for drama from the Greeks right
on through to Shakespeare’s great contemporary Ben Jonson.
I hoped to show in our seminar, though, that Shakespeare has a different conception of character. Sure, character
provides motivations, but there’s a great deal more in his characters, as there is in our own, that makes
them “human”—“round,” as E. M. Forster put it in an influential discussion of the
novel, a modern form of literature that would have puzzled Aristotle but not Shakespeare. Characters in
Shakespeare may be the puppets of destiny, as they often complain that they are, but they stand before us as
beings whose thoughts, like our own, very often wander away from their predicaments. Or, to see this matter in
another way, if even their thoughts that seem to wander most freely are still obscurely connected with their
predicaments at all times, we need the help of modern thinkers about the determinants of
consciousness—Marx, Darwin, Nietzsche, Freud, cognitive scientists, some theologians—to understand
why this is so. We can’t just identify a tragic flaw or comic obsession, then tie a ribbon around it, and
call it the truth about a character.
Although our discussions ranged over these matters in the seminar, however, our curriculum units reflected the
sober fact that teaching is a practical affair, and there’s only so much you can do. To begin then with
the units of two teachers of second and fourth graders, respectively: Joyce Jacobson uses Shakespearean insults,
chosen from passages in three plays, to illustrate her school’s newly mandated guidelines to discourage
bullying. She leaves open the question whether certain characters (say Tybalt in Romeo and Juliet) just
are bullies; that isn’t her point, and can’t be. Her point is to show her students what bullying
is. Irene Jones teaches fourth grade children of the Diné Nation who have no “first”
language (they have had no opportunity to master either Navajo or English), and a large part of her mission is
therefore to improve their verbal skills. She has an interest too, though, in the relation of character to plot,
and she gets her students to see the motivational nature of this relation by comparing a traditional oral
narrative with which the children are familiar to moments of choice in graphic novels of Romeo and
Juliet and The Taming of the Shrew.
The aim of many teachers is to get their students to see themselves, or aspects of themselves, in
Shakespeare’s characters. Christina Cancelli in her military academy takes up the complexities of
stereotyping—a crucial issue for today’s students that goes right to the heart of question, what is
character?—in The Merchant of Venice, leading to in-depth discussion not just of Shylock but of
Portia and Antonio, and beyond that to what might be called religious as well as cultural ideology:
Shakespeare’s dispassionate and even-handed study of the clash between Old and New Testament values and
their mutual misunderstandings. Chenise Gregory wants all of her African American students to discover the
Hamlet in themselves. For Chenise, whose enthusiasm for Hamlet as a guide through personal perplexities
drives her teaching, the goal is to make students see the relevance of Shakespeare by recognizing in themselves
his characters’ motives, family circumstances, and social outlook. Sarah Weidmann, having noted a high
incidence of family tragedy among her students, teaches Hamlet almost therapeutically as a story of
“family and loss.” Her most continuous study of character in this regard concerns Gertrude, whose
responses to family and loss Sarah considers for the most part admirable, defending Gertrude against
performances suggesting her degradation. And Michelle Hilbeck, teaching sixth grade, wants students to see
themselves in choices made by characters in Romeo and Juliet and Macbeth. It is her challenge
to make Shakespeare palatable to the young, and to this end she works chiefly—like Irene Jones—with
graphic novels of these plots that perforce make character primarily motivational, posing for students the
question: what is it in our own characters that dictates our choices?
For many teachers the relevance of Shakespeare is ethical. And why not? Ethe is Greek for
“character.” Quinn Jacobs feels that her high school students struggle to distinguish—in
themselves and others—between “phony” and “authentic” presentations of self, and
to that end she has written a unit on masks and pretenses in The Taming of the Shrew, primarily but not
exclusively focused on the enigmatic final speech of the apparently “tamed” Kate. Jennifer
Vermillion’s ethical focus is the seductive yet also sometimes elevating power of persuasive rhetoric, and
she helps students analyze dialogues and speeches in Julius Caesar by using the ancient rhetorical
divisions logos, ethos, pathos. The center of her attention is the contrast between the funeral
speeches of Brutus and Marc Antony.
The focus of Teresa Madden Harrold is at once ethical, as she is interested in what constitutes a villain, and
intellectual, as she makes students consider what constitutes a historical fact: what is
“literature” and what, if anything, is “information”? The first part of her unit studies
the character of Shakespeare’s Richard III, while the second part considers the effort to reconstruct the
historical Richard in Josephine Tey’s novel, The Daughters of Time, in disagreement with the
Tudor-sponsored biography by St. Thomas More on which Shakespeare’s Richard is largely based. Studying
Julius Caesar, Jen Giarrusso too pursues an objective that is at once ethical and intellectual. She
begins with the dispute late in the play between Brutus and Cassius about friendship: is it blind loyalty or is
it subject to a dispassionate weighing of qualities? She goes to show how this question, and the ethical choices
it gives rise to (et tu, Brute?), permeate the entire fabric of the play, offering students a coherent
close reading with an ethical basis.
The remaining two units focus on themes within which character is central. Comparing and contrasting the theme of
love in A Midsummer Night’s Dream and Romeo and Juliet, Justin Brady ranges through
these companion plays not only to reflect on the elusive line of division between love and lust but also to
contrast love as a genuine feeling with love as a literary affectation, a pretext for sonneteering. One can
detect all three of these feelings struggling with each other in the character of Romeo, for example. Tara Ann
Carter’s study of four characters in Julius Caesar (developing the theme of character) in a way
illustrates the dispassionate analysis of qualities discussed by Jen Giarrusso. That there is more than one way
to view each character displaces the duty of choice from the characters themselves onto the reader’s or
spectator’s reactions to them.
I am certain that each of these units will not only stand up to the test of the classroom but also inspire
intellectual conversion experiences in many students, and that is surely what teaching is for.
Paul H. Fry
Synopsis of the Curriculum Units
15.02.01 - Sticks and Stones: The Bully and the Bullies in Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, The Merchant of Venice, and The Tempest
by Joyce Jacobson
This unit designed for a second grade classroom will use snippets from Romeo and Juliet, The Merchant of
Venice, and The Tempest as a vehicle for teaching about Anti Bullying. Included is a brief overview of
the health implications of bullying and the attitudes and research on bullying. Examples of types of bullying
behaviors associated with bullying and research on the causes therein will be provided. This will be followed by
examples of the Olweus Bullying Prevention Program and suggestions on how to implement this in your school
setting. Finally key excerpts of dialogue between characters in scenes from the three plays are given with a
focus on word choice and vocabulary of Shakespeare’s time. Discussion topics and questions that
highlight the roles played by characters that at as bullies, bullied, and or bystanders will accompany each segment.
Suggested activities such as role -play, masks, and script writing that are aligned with the Common Core State
Standards will culminate the unit.
(Developed for ELA/Reading, Writing, Listening, and Speaking, grade 2; recommended for ELA/Reading, Writing,
Listening, and Speaking, grades 2-5)
15.02.02 - Tragedies and Plots Shaped by Characters of Shakespeare and Navajo Oral Myths
by Irene Jones
In my unit for fourth grade English language Learners I will compare two characters in a Navajo oral myth of the
kind our students hear at home and at school, Changing Bear Maiden, with two characters from graphic novels
based on Shakespeare plays. My students sometimes lack the reading abilities for their grade level; however, I still
need to teach them using fourth grade standards. Fourth grade reading standards and standardized assessment
emphasize reading comprehension. Determining character traits and motivation, together with plot development, are
the main standards that students need to learn. The students will compare the actions of Tingly Woman in
Changing Bear Maiden with Kate from Taming of the Shrew, and Coyote will be compared with Iago
from Othello. The characters in the stories of oral myths create the course of the plots of the stories.
When oral myths are retold, they are told in a way that leaves little mystery in solving character traits, or
character motivation. The only mystery is the outcome, usually ending with a moral to be learned. This unit will
allow students to identify character traits and motivation, and to learn how motivation changes the course of the
plot.
(Developed for Reading and Writing, grade 4; recommended for Reading, and Writing, grade 5)
15.02.03 - Fate or Action: Character Agency & What the 21st Century Student Gains from The Merchant of Venice
by Christina Cancelli
This unit focuses on scaffolding instruction to eliminate any intimidation by Shakespeare and focuses on creating
real world connection and relevance to the lives of the modern eleventh or twelfth grader. Concentration is placed
on creating student centered, active learning that will encourage each child to be investigative and think
critically about the changing world he or she lives in through the lens of Shakespeare’s The Merchant of
Venice. The unit is organized in four major sections structured chronologically. Stage one addresses
censorship and controversial literature, with attention paid to the vocabulary and rationale needed when teaching a
controversial text. Stage two systematically familiarizes students with Shakespearean language, with tiered
activities to build their confidence. Stage three features the actual reading of The Merchant of Venice,
with student, teacher, and group reading activities. In stage four, students will be investigating, analyzing, and
connecting the text to today’s world. In this section, students will examine today’s justice system as
it relates to the defense of disenfranchised groups or individuals. Also, students will do a cross-curricular study
involving interest rates with credit cards and student loans, so they can begin to understand the nuisances of
predatory lending. Additionally, they will look at the destructive power of stereotypes and the platform of social
media in relation to cyber bullying.
(Developed for English 12/British Studies, grade 12; recommended for Economics, Debate, and Reading Enrichment,
grades 9-12)
15.02.04 - To Thine Own self Be True: the Uncovering the Hamlet in You
by Chenise Gregory
This unit should be prepared for Eleventh and Twelfth graders. It focuses on William Shakespeare’s
Hamlet and thus can be used to discuss Character and Plot within a play. In this particular Unit, students
will read the play and dissect various characters in hopes of finding traits, both negative and positive, that are
found also, within the personal lives of students. The goal of this unit is to show how Shakespeare is still
relevant to this time, and to engage students in the process by which Shakespeare uses these characters to develop
the plot of the play. Students will use social media as a way of following along, enhancing understanding, and
establishing a realistic connection between themselves and the characters. Facebook will be the primary site used as
a forum to discuss events that have taken place in the play. Students will also create a movie trailer that
advertises key concepts or events shown in the previous Act. A close reading of the text is very necessary for
overall understanding and effective questioning in order to continue that understanding. Assessments are given at
the will of the teacher utilizing this unit. This unit follows the Common Core State Standards.
(Developed for English IV and AP English Literature, grade 12; recommended for English III and IV, grades 11-12)
15.02.05 - Character in Hamlet: Family & Loss
by Sarah Alice Weidmann
This unit for upper middle school students is titled Character in Hamlet: Family & Loss. The focus is
how four characters (Hamlet, Gertrude, the Ghost of Old Hamlet, and Horatio) deal with family and loss. The content
follows an interpretation of these four characters’ emotional journeys throughout the play. Evidence for
changes in their emotions is shown with lines of text characters speak themselves as well as what other characters
say about them. Many school communities have dealt with a lot of loss from violence and family disruption. Our
middle school students have not experienced the reading and interpretation of Shakespearean text, a perfect example
of complex literature. Combining social-emotional learning with text interpretation will allow text access through
personal connection. Students are asked to consider how a person might perform emotions rather than truly feel them.
They are also asked to consider what family is, and then go farther by examining how family ties (blood-related or
chosen) might intensify our experiences of loss. Aided by a plot map, students will dissect the first lines of the
play, short phrases, and sections of scenes that feature our four characters. After reading the text students will
write scenes from current times based on scenes from Hamlet that show difficult choices being made.
(Developed for Reading, grade 7; recommended for Reading and Social Studies, grades 6-8, Drama, grades 6-9, and
Literature, grades 9-10)
15.02.06 - Examining Shakespeare’s Characters, Character’s Choices and the Consequences to Make Them Relevant to Middle School
by Michelle Wiedenmann
So why is it that William Shakespeare—a long dead author whose plays were written for playhouses very
different from today—should be celebrated as an author of enduring significance? He was a master of telling a
gripping story and he has this uncanny ability to render personality that makes his personages seem so
real. With this unit, I want to provide my sixth grade students an early exposure to Shakespeare and
determine how his characters are still relevant and similar to the students themselves when they need to make
choices. We will study the personalities and choices the characters make in Shakespeare’s two plays, Romeo
and Juliet and Macbeth, while first reading the graphic novel interpretations of the plays. This
will act as a springboard for my students to examine how the plot unfolds based on the decisions the characters make
or how they respond. Next, we will compare the graphic interpretations with segments of the original verse to dig
deeper into the thoughts and emotions of the characters.
(Developed for English/Language Arts, grade 6; recommended for English/Language Arts, grades 6-9)
15.02.07 - Removing the Mask: An Untamed Look at Shakespeare’s The Taming of the Shrew
by Quinn Jacobs
In this unit, students will become familiar with the William Shakespeare’s play The Taming of the
Shrew. This will be modeled by using a close read of the text and an analysis of the film. In small groups,
analyze Kate’s final speech and determine whether they believe she has or has not been tamed. Close reading is
an important skills students need to master. Then, they will synthesize the information from their small group
discussions and individually write a short essay on her taming, or lack of. This unit, although geared toward the
idea of always being yourself and could easily be adapted to fit the needs of many other groups/communities.
(Recommended for British Literature, Grade 12)
15.02.08 - Convincing the Masses: Rhetoric in Julius Caesar
by Jennifer Leigh Vermillion
Using Julius Caesar as a foundational text, high school students will be challenged to understand and
employ the art of rhetoric, or persuasion. An awareness of the prevalence of rhetoric in advertising, politics and
even daily life will be developed in hopes of developing critical thinking skills and an ability to self-advocate.
Close reading of text and learning to analyze passages for rhetorical strategies will engender readers who approach
text with a purpose, and recognize the ways in which authors develop their point of view. Critical thinking,
strategic reading, and analytic writing skills will be honed prior to approaching Julius Caesar, at which
time students will find themselves engaged in complex questions relating to the uses of rhetoric. Students will
learn to recognize and appreciate the complexity of the language instead of feeling intimidated by it. The play
lends itself to multiple interpretations of character owing to ambiguous language and therefore provides students
with ample opportunities to develop their own opinions based upon textual evidence. Through close reading of
specific soliloquies, monologues and passages, students will understand that rhetoric works to both
embellish the text and develop characterization.
(Developed for English II, grade 2; recommended for English I-IV, grades 9-12)
15.02.09 - Shaping a Multi-Dimensional Villain: Richard III
by Teresa Madden Harrold
In this unit, 10th grade students, in an accelerated English class, will explore Shakespeare’s
craft in creating the title villain in Richard III, afterwards will learn something about the historical
Richard III from a modern literary source. Students will be tasked first with answering, Who was the
literary Richard III? Through classroom read alouds, scene analysis, and theater games, students will collect
evidence to respond to this guiding question. In the individual lessons, we will carefully examine Richard’s
soliloquies, his manipulative performances before other characters, and various epideictic speeches. After studying
the play, students will compose an original soliloquy in which Richard justifies his actions as given in the play.
The class will then read Josephine Tey’s novel The Daughter of Time, which presents historical
evidence to complicate the villain created by Shakespeare. Students will document details from the novel that
contradict the presentation of Richard in the play in order to answer, Who was the historical Richard?
Students will craft their response in the form of a eulogy for the historic king. The main objective is for students
to analyze fiction and nonfiction depictions of Richard III and come to an understanding of how historic figures are
shaped in later times.
(Developed for English II CAS, grade 10; recommended for English/Literature, grades 9-12)
15.02.10 - How Our Moral Views Shape Our Judgment of Characters in Julius Caesar
by Jennifer L. Mazzocco
In [] Julius Caesar, there are no clear cut “bad” and “good” characters. The four
main characters – Caesar, Brutus, Cassius and Antony – participate in a series of decisions that make it
difficult to judge the character definitively as a whole. In fact, there may be no accurate judgment possible at
all. For one thing, when we read a piece of literature, we bring with us a wealth of beliefs and experience that
color our judgments and, ultimately, may alter the way we see text evidence – what evidence we assign value
and what evidence we may even choose to ignore. At times, we may choose evidence selectively to support an
interpretation that justifies our already existing ethical views.
This unit will ask ninth and tenth grade students to address the viewpoints they bring to the table and actively
assess how those beliefs influence their interpretation of text evidence and how they can actively look for the
evidence they may have overlooked in defense of their own belief. The unit promotes analysis by pursuing the
question “when does loyalty expire?” and uses that frame to examine how the four main characters can be
judged in different ways.
(Developed for English 1 PSP, grade 10; recommended for English, grades 9-12)
15.02.11 - The Question of Desire: A Comparison of Love in Shakespeare
by Justin Robert Brady
Shakespeare presents different views of desire and love in A Midsummer Night’s Dream and Romeo
and Juliet, respectively. These plays complement one another while also existing at opposite ends of a
spectrum for readers to analyze. Is love merely the lucky result of good timing or are we fated to fall for a
predetermined person? One play is a comedy and the other is a tragedy, but how did the decisions made by the
characters determine these genres? What was Shakespeare trying to tell his audience about love? Through examination
of these questions, the class will consider character motivation through action and words in both plays, acting out
scenes such as Romeo and Juliet’s first meeting as well as the play put on by uneducated actors in A
Midsummer Night’s Dream. Students will also work together to synthesize Shakespeare’s text
into a modern format while making a soundtrack suited to different characters, using both music originally inspired
by these plays and modern music. Finally, students will participate in a Socratic seminar where students will work
together to consider the decisions made by individuals within both plays, defending a point-of-view as they take on
the persona of one of these characters.
(Developed for English Language Arts, grade 7; recommended for English Language Arts and Drama, grades 7-12)
15.02.12 - Take a Stab at It: Exploring Character in Julius Caesar
by Tara Ann Carter
This unit for an advanced ninth grade classroom seeks to explicate strategies and activities that represent a
well-rounded deep investigation of character in William Shakespeare’s tragedy, Julius Caesar.
There is universality in William Shakespeare’s works that makes them relevant for all people in our
increasingly globalized society. In our current moment, the characters and concerns of the four primary characters
of Julius Caesar are as relevant and applicable to the ethical, political and psychological struggles of
today as they were during the author’s era.
The focus of this unit is how to enable students to understand the creativity and economy with which the Bard
approached the English language, and the frank and clear eye with which he was able to evaluate some of the most
base and inherent characteristics of the human condition. Students will come to understand Shakespeare as a master
craftsman of humanism and of the psychological development of characters. This unit [] could be easily adapted for
learners at all levels, in middle or high school.
(Developed for English, grade 9; recommended for English, grades 7-12)
Introduction by
Mary Ting Yi Lui, Professor of History and of American Studies
We are surrounded by the history though we rarely take notice. In moments of national crisis, however, we often
become painfully aware of our unresolved past. The volatile 2015 debates over the symbolism of the Confederate
flag—as an enduring symbol of slavery and white supremacy or simply Southern heritage—quickly remind
us of the importance of confronting the nation’s past in our everyday landscapes.
This seminar aimed to explore the field of public history as a set of broader engagements between historians and
the public about the documentation and interpretation of the past. By exploring a range of public history
projects—podcasts, public art, exhibitions, websites, documentary films, etc., seminar participants
discussed the ways in which teachers and students in k-12 grades might use their everyday surroundings and
readily available materials to reinvigorate the study of local, state or national histories in the classroom.
Critical to the understanding of the power of public history is the potential for the public to intervene in the
research and narration of its own history and not cede authority solely to academic historians. In the seminar
we considered the importance of searching for alternative sources of information beyond the textbook and how the
act of research and discovery empowers students to be historical researchers, thinkers, and writers.
Particularly for teachers working in low-income and predominantly non-white or recent immigrant neighborhoods
the methods of public history allow students to find ways to connect their own experiences to those they read in
textbooks. Opportunities to touch the past in the form of visits to archival collections housed in libraries or
historical societies or on walking tours of historic sites also allow students to come face to face with the
past. These engagements also allow students to question the practice of historic preservation and public memory.
Whose stories are saved and why? Why do others disappear from the historical record and our surrounding
landscape? How might we find other ways to restore forgotten histories and voices to the public record?
The seminar also considered the different types of public history projects and how they create literary, aural,
visual, and corporeal experiences that foster different forms of engagement with the past. While some public
history projects such as historic exhibitions and documentary films allow for greater historical information to
be presented to an audience, we noted the ways in which the historical fiction film or public art might create a
more powerful emotional connection to the past. And we debated the merits of these public history projects not
just for their historic accuracy—that is the ability to render every fact and detail accurately as we
might expect from a work of academic history—but also for their artistic or experiential worth.
The rich discussions over the value of public history and the possibilities and limitations of different types of
projects supported the growth and development of the ten curriculum units presented here. Collectively, they
range from explorations of the history of local parks situated in diverse urban communities, studies of school
desegregation, work and labor, public art and commemoration, and the history of aviation. The units also discuss
the ways that archival research, walking tours, museum visits, public art, and documentary filmmaking may offer
alternative ways to engage with and speak back to academic history. While each of the units focus heavily on the
local community history of the seminar participants’ home cities, they offer models for any teacher hoping
to enrich their teaching of local and national history through the tools of public history. The units
demonstrate the potential for teachers to explore their own communities and empower their students to contribute
to the writing of their own history.
Mary Lui
Synopsis of the Curriculum Units
15.03.01 - Richmond’s Divisive Monuments: A Look into One City’s Debate over Public Art, Memory, and History
by Jeanne Callahan
“This is an issue that touches the soul of a city.”
One hundred and fifty years later, the South’s connection to the Civil War still divides the nation.
Since the massacre at Episcopal AME which claimed the lives of nine black parishioners, Americans once again
heatedly debate the meaning imbued in the South’s myriad Confederate monuments and icons. In a publication
titled “Art, Scale, and the Memory of Tragedy: A Consideration of Public Art in Pleasant Hill,
Missouri,” historiographer Chris Post writes that “public art presents the views of a commissioner or
artist to a wide audience, presumably an entire community. By doing so, art becomes a forum for discourse over
essential cultural and political activities, their history, and their representation.” During this unit,
students will delve into this discourse through exploring the divisive debates surrounding Richmond’s most
historic boulevard which honors five Confederate leaders and, most recently, the renowned, black athlete and
humanitarian, Arthur Ashe. Through analyzing this real-world issue over Richmond’s cultural narrative,
students will develop an understanding of the many nuances surrounding one city’s quest to answer a question
that is anything but simple: Whose story do we tell?
(Developed for English 11, grades IB 10 and Standard Level 11; recommended for Language Arts, grades 8-12, and
Civics and History, grades 9-12)
15.03.02 - Silicon Valley’s Otro Lado, Youth Voices Speak About Their Community in Film
by William Cavada
Silicon Valley has become a popular subject, not only in cinema, but on television dramas. Indeed, a great many
stories at the moment concern the power and glory and development of the Valley. When we look at today’s
society we can see how film and television have effectively become the authoritative sources for many of
people’s knowledge of history. The objective of the unit is to illustrate to students that there is power in
moving images, and they conjure up powerful feelings and communicate ideas in ways that transcend the written word.
As product of understanding their own public history, students create self-documentaries that draw upon the rich
histories of their neighborhoods and speak back to the broader historical narratives within Silicon Valley using the
language, process and technique of filmmaking.
(Developed for Multimedia Arts, grades 9-12; recommended for Media Arts, U. S. History, and English, grades 9-12)
15.03.03 - My City Need' Something
by Sydney Hunt Coffin
Celebrating the current renovations of a city park in North Philadelphia, students in this unit will examine the
changes to the built environment through a public history lens, looking closely at decisions being made over time to
bring the park (and its people) into the present day. Applying a Project Based Learning methodology to the
assignments, students will hone in on an aspect of the park that intrigues them: its horticulture, recreational
facilities, safety, art and architecture, poetic aspects, maintenance, or its social politics, all the while meeting
with community organizers and city officials to ask how can we participate in making this a better park. What does
your city need?
(Developed for English III American Literature Class, grade 11; recommended for Social Studies, English, and Art,
grades 10-12)
15.03.04 - French History in Your City: San Jose, California - the Pellier Brothers
by Glenn Davis
“French History in Your City” is a unit on local, public history, which explores how the French
arrived, specifically, in San Jose and what they did to contribute to society. It includes struggles and victories
for the new immigrants. With a bit of research on immigrants in your area, it can easily be applied to other
neighborhoods, cities, counties, etc., in which the French, or other ethnic groups, settled.
The unit is student-centered, focusing on their research using the internet, learning first about the migration of
the French language from a small area in Western Europe, to all corners of the globe, including North America,
California, and finally, San Jose. Their research includes visiting local history libraries, where they can find
primary source materials, museums, and places of interest where the immigrant is memorialized, such as a small park
and a cemetery.
The unit will empower students to be historical researchers, thinkers and writers. From a few words on a tombstone,
students will dig deep in their research, taking them back to France, where they will make discoveries about the
origins of the immigrant. It will open up the area of genealogy, as they research the family.
(Developed for French III, grades 11-12, and AP French Language and Culture, grade 10; recommended for French
III-AP/World Languages, Spanish III-AP/World Language, Vietnamese II-III/World Languages, and German II-III/World
Language, grades 10-12)
15.03.05 - A Public History of Public Housing: Richmond, Virginia
by Libby Germer
In the Library of Virginia’s archives, mid-20th century black and white photographs chronicle the
construction of Richmond’s first housing projects. Looking at the photos requires the viewer to step back in
time, in many ways. One picture features a horse, a ramshackle outhouse, and pedestrians next to a construction
zone. A large painted sign says, “Gilpin Court Slum-Clearance Project” then advertises: “Model
Negro Apartment.”
This curriculum unit reflects on the history of US housing policy, then focuses on public housing in Richmond,
Virginia, and culminates with a student-led oral history project in Hillside Court. While many of my students call
Hillside “home,” they are likely not aware that when the apartments were completed in 1952, they housed
an all-white tenancy of working class families.
Today, there is no racial divide in Richmond’s public housing because nearly every resident for decades has
been black. What socio-economic and political forces allowed for segregated public housing in the 1950s and the
racial homogeneity of today’s housing projects? Why do future plans feature subsidized, mixed-income
townhouses? In Richmond, as in many other American cities, the bitter fruits of de facto segregation come from
historical housing policies and practices deeply rooted in injustice.
(Developed for Virginia and U. S. Government, grade 12; recommended for African American Studies and Urban History,
grades 9-12)
15.03.06 - Looking at Desegregation through Local Narratives: A Case Study at Tulsa Central High School
by Patricia Leann Delancey
I teach 11th grade US History in urban Tulsa. Last year as I showed my students the video clip Eyes
on the Prize: Little Rock Nine, my students asked me about our own school’s history; they
wanted to compare Little Rock’s Central and our Central High. It was then that I decided to look at
desegregation and indeed the whole Civil Rights Movement as it happened in our school. In 1917, Central was built.
The four story building showed the wealth and privilege of the oil boom years. By 1938, Central was the second
largest high school in the US, with 5000 students. Now, Central is one of the smallest high schools in Tulsa with
only 500 students. Central was 100% white, now it is 85% black. It was once nationally renowned; now it fights to
stay off the “failing schools” list. What happened to reverse the Central’s fortune? How did
desegregation, federal mandates, Supreme Court cases and the Civil Rights Movement affect the school, individuals,
communities, and the whole history of Tulsa?
(Developed for U. S. History, grade 11, AP U. S. History, grades 11-12, and African American History, grade 12;
recommended for U. S. History, AP U. S. History, and African American History, grades 10-12 and Oklahoma History,
grades 9-12)
15.03.07 - Telling Stories: Place, Space, and Memory in Chicago's Parks
by Elizabeth M. Miller
This is a unit that examines the history of public parks in urban areas using Portage Park in Chicago as the
primary example. By making use of historical documents and getting to know their neighborhood park facilities in new
ways, students will be able to contribute to the historical record of their communities. The end product of the unit
is a podcast-- a form of visceral aural storytelling-- and easy for students to produce in this technological era.
Teachers will achieve this goal by engaging students in close reading, visual thinking, and seminar-style
discussions.
(Developed for English/Art Interdisciplinary Course, grade 9; recommended for English, Social Studies, and Art,
grades 5-12)
15.03.08 - Ripple Effect: How Major Events Effect Everyone
by Raymond Ott
This teaching unit examines specific historical moments in Aviation History that were chosen for their potential to
relate to your own teaching community and understanding of aviation. It is designed for a High School class but
certainly can be taught in a middle school environment. Technological advancements are a core part of the lesson
however the intent is to weave how big historical events can have an impact on society and communities. Although
aviation history is the medium here, hopefully the chance to explore, examine and learn about the community your
specific classroom resides in will prevail. The lesson was designed at POLYTECH High School which resides in the
middle of Delaware just outside Dover Air Force Base. Therefore, many of the events chosen were selected for their
potential to relate to students of Delaware. However, much of the classroom activities are more global in
nature. For example, the contested history of the Enola Gay is explored and the ripple effects of 911
are examined. The unit also reveals how today’s awesome power of aviation must be respected and acknowledged.
Just as aviation has quickly changed warfare, it has had similar effects on society and community.
(Developed for History/Aviation, grade 12; recommended for History, grades 9-12)
15.03.09 - The History and Analysis of Public Art: Using Delaware’s Desegregation History as a Ground to Learn, Interpret, and Create
by Elizabeth Terlecki
Northern Delaware played a significant role in desegregation, a little known fact that is not highlighted by
Wilmington’s vast amount of public art—none of which is reflective of the civil rights movement.
However, not only does the absence of public art dedicated to the civil rights movement create an opportunity for
speculation and conversation, but it also provides some context for high school students in the Christina School
District who are still being bused out of the city of Wilmington and into the suburbs to attend high school as a
direct result of desegregation. Through the exploration of various examples of public art, including monuments,
memorials, murals, and interactive installations, students will not only develop a proposal for a much needed civil
rights-themed monument within their own city, but they will also collaboratively construct a piece of unique public
art to be displayed within their own school—one that represents their unique blend of both city and suburbs.
Students will investigate and analyze both local and national public art, gaining an appreciation for the statues
and monuments that they pass by on a daily basis and learning how they fit into the greater context of public art.
(Developed for 3D Design II/Visual Art, grades 10-12; recommended for Visual Art, grades 1-12)
15.03.10 - Pittsburgh: Contending with its Steel Past
by Tracy Watkins
This unit focuses on the development of the industrial United States (1870-1900) and students will analyze how
continuity and change has influenced history. Throughout this unit, the rise of the steel industry in Pittsburgh is
studied, as well as the make-up of the workforce and the role the workers played in this history. The unit also
focuses on the labor movement by examining unions in the steel mills and the Homestead Steel Strike of 1892.
Following is an analysis of the demise of the steel industry and the impact of deindustrialization.
Though Pittsburgh was once considered the steel capital of the world, it is certainly no longer a major steel
producer. However, the city still has a strong hold on its steel past. Within this unit, the approach of using
public history projects to learn about public memory and urban and labor history is used. The projects presented
consist of a book, tours, school programs, and the public use of a historical site.
The unit will conclude with students creating a project to display to the public. The activities throughout the
unit will help students develop historical thinking skills through synthesizing and evaluating historical sources
and interpretations of events. Furthermore, students will cite specific textual evidence to support their analysis,
determine central ideas from sources, evaluate various explanations for actions and events, and integrate
information from diverse sources. Lastly, students will write arguments focused on discipline-specific content as
well as informative and explanatory texts while drawing evidence from informational texts to support their claim.
(Developed for U. S. History, grade 11; recommended for U. S. History, grade 11)
Introduction by
Brigitte M. Peucker, Professor of Germanic Languages and Literature and of Film Studies
We were all in agreement that, more than ever before, it is essential to teach our students how to analyze
images. The title of our seminar suggests the double focus of its concern. It began with a number of sessions in
which we discussed formal aspects of the film medium—color and the composition of the frame, sound and
music, lighting, and editing, among others—using carefully chosen films viewed outside the seminar and
analyzed with the help of clips. Film tells stories by means of images, camera work, and editing procedures;
color, sound, and music are also central to narration. The formal procedures of the film medium convey
information, but they also produce emotion in the spectator. A film sequence may be long or short, for example,
thus creating suspense, anxiety—or boredom. It may be shot with a mobile camera or a stationary one, from
above or below, prompting us to ask whose eye is looking. Is it a character that looks; is it a narrator? A
garish color scheme may set the tone for violence, or it may simply be theatrical or suggest gaiety. Music can
be part of the story—as, for example, when a character sings or plays the piano—or it can be
superimposed on the images, as in the scary music that accompanies a horror film. All of these devices shape the
way we read films. In the seminar, we analyzed films from these formal points of view in order to answer the
following questions: How is a story told? How does it color our emotions? What is its aim in doing so?
Our goal was also to analyze a wide range of films. To this end, we included a Disney film and a well-known
documentary, The Thin Blue Line, among other canonical works. The strategy of “close
looking” was central to our study of these films; our guiding principle was to watch our chosen films as
many times as possible. Three of the films we discussed were adaptations of literary texts: The Great
Gatsby, To Kill a Mockingbird, and Zefirelli’s Romeo and Juliet. In the case of
these films, too, we examined film form closely. With respect to film adaptations, we began by asking whether
they tell the same story as the literary text. If the film tells a different story, we asked how and why it
might doso. Again the strategy of “close looking” and close analysis was central to our discussions.
The range of film genres we included made it possible for teachers of elementary school students to engage as
naturally with the materials as the teachers of older students did. The range of topics addressed in the
thought-provoking curriculum units that follow makes this evident.
Meg Deweese’s curriculum unit centers on the subject of suspense in a Poe
short story, its film adaptation, as well as in Hitchcock’s Strangers On a Train—a perfect
topic for the integrated American Studies course that she teaches to eighth graders. Her course focuses on
character point of view and mood with respect to the Poe tale, and editing, lighting, and the camera with
respect to Hitchcock, all with the goal of asking how our emotions are engaged by these texts. Each student
creates Poe “foldables” to expand their knowledge of Poe and his time and place, a film storyboard
to help them understand how film narratives work, and participates in the making of a class film.
Shannon Foster-Williams, who teaches art to third graders, has developed a unit designed to
increase her students ability to “see” and understand images. The Disney film Mulan is used
to fulfill both the art requirement and the mandate that students learn about ancient cultures, specifically
Chinese culture. Her imaginative teaching techniques include looking at examples of Chinese art, acting out the
narrative of the Mulan legend, and designing a storyboard of three panels to illustrate the film.
Miles Greene’s curriculum unit is designed for 12th grade English
students who are visual learners. It uses The Great Gatsby—both novel and its film
adaptation—to teach reading and analytical skills in both media, as well as to teach the history and
culture of the Jazz Age. Literary and film character will be analyzed using the “psychoanalytical critical
lens” approach, thus introducing another area of concern into this rich offering. Molly
Myers’ curriculum unit, likewise for the upper grades, examines To Kill a Mockingbird
in both its novelistic and filmic form in order to lay bare the gender relations in these texts and to
discuss their cultural formation, using the concept of intersectionality as a method of approach. Here, too,
text and image relations are a concern and lead to fascinating observations about how ideology is produced in
both novel and film. Eric Maroney’s course, also for high school
students, uses three films about surveillance to discuss changes in the technology of surveillance and the
equally changing ideological and political implications this practice produces. This timely subject is used as a
springboard for speaking and writing practice, as well as for the analysis of images. Barbara
Prillaman’s curriculum unit makes use of fiction films about depression and schizophrenia
to give psychology students a means of speaking about these disorders that is more immediate than the clinical
essays they will read to accompany the films. The tools for analysis that the clinical essays provide are used
in discussing the films, which will also be analyzed as visual texts. Kathleen
Radebaugh’s middle school students will have the privilege of discussing
immigration and citizenship through the lens of Hester Street and West Side Story, rather
different films that will also provoke a discussion of film genre. Her curriculum unit describes a course that
will also rely upon present-day campaign speeches to supplement film analysis and connect the subject of
immigration to contemporary debates.
Sobeyda Rivera has devised a course for second-grade students of Spanish that uses the Disney
film Mulan as a vehicle for comparing family structures in several cultures—in the
students’ own, in Spanish culture, and in the Chinese culture that the film evokes. The aim is to teach
Spanish while also teaching the concept of diversity to students with little knowledge of the world outside
their neighborhood. Jolene Smith’s curriculum unit also has cultural aims: to use two
children’s books and their film adaptations to discuss misrepresentations of Native American Indian
culture. She will also instruct them about how film techniques color our understanding of the story a film
tells. Finally, Arcadia Teel’s unit, designed for high school students
learning German through the Teaching Proficiency through Reading and Storytelling (TPRS) method, uses the film
Goodbye Lenin! as a means of teaching the history and culture of the former East Germany. Her
innovative method involves watching the film first without sound in order to generate class discussion. This
approach also allows for the close analysis of the film’s formal components, which underscore its
ideological message. In all of these units, the study of film form is used to underscore film’s cultural
concerns.
Brigitte Peucker
Synopsis of the Curriculum Units
15.04.01 - Look Behind You! Mastering the Art of Suspense with Poe and Hitchcock
by Margaret Mary Deweese
“Look Behind You! Mastering the Art of suspense with Poe and Hitchcock” is a curriculum unit designed
for teachers of students in grade eight and above who are searching for a variety of engaging instructional
strategies through which their students will learn about the formal elements of literature and film. This unit will
allow students to explore the works of two masters of suspense, early American author Edgar Allan Poe and twentieth
century British filmmaker Alfred Hitchcock, in order to identify and apply the elements of literature such as
suspense, mood, tone, imagery, point of view and symbol. They will also be introduced to the formal elements of
film, such as cinematography, sound, editing, and several other elements and become adept at understanding how
suspense is created in literature and in film. Through the use of high interest suspense narratives, a short story
and a full length film, students will have many opportunities for deep and relevant analysis, including several
writing components, storyboarding, and the use of technology to create their own works of art. Ultimately, students
will come away with a deeper understanding of suspense narratives, the elements and techniques used to create them,
as well as enough mastery to be able to apply their learning throughout other units of study now and in the future.
(Developed for English Language Arts, grade 8; recommended for English Language Arts, grade 7-12)
15.04.02 - The Visual Art of Writing
by Shannon Foster-Williams
Exposing students to ancient Chinese culture through film, students will use creative processes for analyzing film
and writing. This unit is intended for elementary students who are emerging writers and engaging in creative
writing. It is intended to guide students through the mental process of summarizing and comprehending content. This
unit bridges text and film to enhance understanding of narrative content, using animated film to engage students in
stories that are appealing and appropriate for young learners. Students will compare the written legend of
Ballad of Mulan to the animated Disney film Mulan, which highlights Ancient China. Activities
included in this unit aid students in building pictures that assist with writing. These visual cues will drive a
process that leads to detailed and descriptive writing, through a cycle of interpreting stories,
class critiques, visual summaries, art compositions, and written narratives. The focus is not only on the artistry,
but on a creative way to analyze film and text for the purposes of communicating a story that is
clear, concise, and accurate. Challenging students to create a written narrative that mirrors what is seen in their
illustrated art work, this unit connects literature, film, history, and art.
(Developed for Visual Art/Art History and Culture, grades 3-4; recommended for Social Studies/Ancient China, grade
3, Language Arts/Writing, grades 4-5)
15.04.03 - Film, Freud and Fitzgerald: A Psychoanalytical Critique of The Great Gatsby and Jazz Age Values
by William Miles Greene
High School students often struggle with comprehension and critical analysis of the classic literature suggested by
the Common Core appendixes. Supplementing literature with its respective film adaptation will help to address this
deficiency by giving students a visual representation of a story through which critical thinking and rich dialogue
between students can occur. For this unit, students will analyze Baz Luhrmann’s film adaptation of The Great
Gatsby using the psychoanalytical critical lens theory to formulate conclusions around the stories’ characters
and author, F. Scott Fitzgerald.
Students will be considering questions around the characters’ morality and how their behavior and
psychological profiles are indicative of Fitzgerald’s attitude as an author who was a witness to and
participant in the Jazz Age. Students will draw connections to their own lives from themes surrounding class,
materialism and gender. Lastly, they will learn how film is a unique medium for storytelling, in that techniques
unique to film play an important role in developing characters, creating tension and portraying symbolism. This unit
should be considered for teachers seeking to integrate a film dimension into a unit already in existence on The
Great Gatsby or Fitzgerald as a means to increase the novel’s accessibility for struggling or reluctant
readers.
(Developed for English, grade 11; recommended for Film, grade 11)
15.04.04 - Film Analysis and Contemporary Issues: The Surveillance State
by Eric W. Maroney
This curriculum unit makes use film to build and enhance students’ analytical reading and writing skills.
Throughout the unit, students will identify and analyze the cinematic tools and choices a director employs to create
meaning. This analysis will mirror the same close reading skills described in the Common Core State Standards
(CCSS), which are the same practices students engage in when deconstructing traditional literature or written text.
. Film replaces written text providing an alterative medium for students to engage with. This substitution is
intended to remove the barrier of decoding; thus, allowing students access to complex texts and ideas. Thematically,
the unit explores the ethics of surveillance. Students will examine The Conversation (1974), Eagle Eye
(2008) and Citizenfour (2014) to consider the ideologies these texts produce regarding surveillance
and the evolution of surveillance technology. Students will explore the ways viewers are encouraged or discouraged
to identify with particular characters and consider the way this spectator identification constructs the messaged
agenda of the film. At the culmination of the unit, students will write a comparative analysis on two of the texts
studied throughout the unit.
(Developed for English IV, grade 12; recommended for English and Civics, grades 9-12)
15.04.05 - You Should Be in a Dress and Camisole
by Molly A. Myers
At one point in the novel To Kill a Mockingbird, the character Ms. Dubose yells from her porch to a
young Scout Finch, “you should be in a dress and camisole!” There are many such gendered moments in both
the novel and film adaptation. These moments create many opportunities and points of access for students to read and
analyze “texts” in terms of how the author or filmmaker make specific choices to establish setting,
create character, and present important events. This unit will serve as the baseline for a women’s studies
course taught as an elective to 11th and 12th grade students. The purpose of the unit is to introduce and pre-assess
the skills of close reading and analyzing various texts (fiction, non-fiction, and film) in order to examine the
concepts of “reading gender” and to introduce the necessary intersectional awareness in text and film to
prepare students for the kind of analytical thinking we will be developing throughout the year.
(Developed for Women's Studies, grades 11-12; recommended for English and Reading, grades 9-12, and Sociology and
Film Studies, grades 11-12)
15.04.06 - Deepening One's Understanding of Psychological Disorders through Film: From One Extreme to Another - Depression and Schizophrenia
by Barbara Ann Prillaman
In this unit film interpretation will be used to better understand the psychological disorders of depression and
schizophrenia. Following the Common Core Standards, students will read for meaning and interpret multiple sources
(written text and film) regarding depression and schizophrenia. High school students will focus on the guiding
questions: How is psychologically abnormal behavior defined? What are the symptoms and causes of depression?
Describe the symptoms and causes of schizophrenia? What are the challenges associated with these diagnoses? What
cinematic elements help with the portrayal of psychopathology in movies? How do the cinematic elements of the film
accentuate or contribute to your understanding? Students will participate in Socratic Seminars to critically read,
view, and prepare to actively participate in conversations to help them make meaning of this complex content.
Additionally, they will write individual patient reports to represent their understanding. Then, they will create
collaborative public service announcements about the disorders.
(Developed for College Preparatory [CP] Psychology and Advanced Placement [AP] Psychology, grades 11-12;
recommended for Psychology courses, grades 10-12)
15.04.07 - Immigration and the Narrative Voice: Analysis of Image and Sound in Film and Its Connection to the Immigrants' Stories
by Kathleen Radebaugh
We are a nation of immigrants who bring different beliefs and values to the United States of America. In this
curriculum unit for a middle school ELA or a history classroom, students will interpret and analyze how two
different ethnic groups of the 1850s and the 1960s were portrayed in two different films. Hester Street is
a film about how a Jewish family from Russia adjusts to their new community in Manhattan’s Lower East Side in
1850. West Side Story is a filmed theatrical performance about two star-crossed lovers from different
neighborhoods in Brooklyn. Each film has a very different style of portraying the stories of Jewish and Puerto Rican
immigrants, yet students will see the parallels in themes and characters. The culminating assessment for the
students is to analyze and evaluate the immigration process currently in the United States and to ask why
immigration is a reform topic in the mayoral and presidential elections of 2016.
(Developed for English, grade 7; recommended for Social Studies, grade 7)
15.04.08 - Lights, Camera, Action! Reading Children’s Literature through Film in the Spanish Classroom
by Sobeyda Rivera
This curriculum unit describes an elementary Spanish course in which students will use film and literature. It is
designed to let them compare Hispanic and Chinese cultures to their own. The course is targeted for second grade
level students. Our world is a very diverse one and rich with cultural heritage. It is important to enable our
students to understand more than one cultural heritage and to teach them to appreciate and respect other cultures.
In this unit they will also discover the similarities of family dynamics in and how the Chinese family compares to
their own. They will increase their geographical awareness and use map skills to identify the United States, China
and some Latin American countries.
Using the Disney film Mulan and the Mulan legend, available as a literary text, students will be
able to find clues to the bigger picture, to past and present. They will be analyzing and interpreting the film and
then discussing their thinking with each other. By means of the film they will be able to see the family traditions,
cultural pressures on Mulan and the bravery of her acts to protect her family. They will look closely at costumes,
colors and sound and how they create meaning. This study will enable them to develop their own classroom film.
(Developed for Spanish, History, and Social Sciences, grade 2; recommended for Foreign Language, History, and
Social Sciences, grades 2-5)
15.04.09 - The Authenticity of Native American Indian Character and Culture in Book and Film
by Jolene Rose Smith
Numerous works of literature and many films do not provide us with authentic information about the tribes of Native
American Indians they address. This unit hopes to correct this problem. The texts selected are the The Education
of Little Tree and The Indian in the Cupboard as well as the films made about them. Both
books and films have numerous examples of fictitious events and inaccuracies concerning the Native American Indian
characters’ portrayal. This is where I as a Native American Indian educator step in to teach the authentic
culture and traditions. Our own Diné culture and tradition will be studied along with that of the Cherokee
and Iroquois. Often students do not know the truth about the many tribes, bands, and clans’ culture and
traditions. Instead, what they know is what they read and watch. A second focus of this unit is to introduce
students to the idea of thinking about film as something that can be analyzed. We will discuss the formal aspects of
film and compare them with the written texts on which they are based. The unit is designed for fifth grade students,
but it can also be taught to sixth graders.
(Developed for ELA- Vocabulary, Reading, and Writing, grade 5; recommended for elementary grades 4-5)
15.04.10 - Life in the DDR through Film: German II
by Arcadia Alice Teel
This unit uses the film, Goodbye Lenin! to increase vocabulary acquisition and introduce cultural aspects
of the DDR to German II students. The film is broken down by chapters so that certain vocabulary can be emphasized
using Teaching Proficiency through Reading and Storytelling (TPRS) methods. The selected vocabulary for a particular
chapter is practiced by asking a story in which the students supply the details. The students then watch that
chapter of the movie without sound and once more with sound. A critical analysis of that chapter takes place before
the vocabulary is reinforced by having the students translate passages and rewrite parts of the story. Historical
and cultural aspects of East Germany are emphasized during the analysis of the film’s various chapters. This
unit can be altered to be relevant for German II, German III, and German IV. Its analytical approach to film and
history make the unit adaptable for film classes as well as European history classes. Methods used are suitable to
meet MYP and IB standards.
(Developed for German II, grade 10; recommended for German III and History, grades 11-12)
Introduction by
Roger E. Howe, William R. Kenan, Jr. Professor Emeritus of Mathematics
The work in the seminar “Problem Solving and the Common Core” was centered on the taxonomies of
one-step addition and subtraction problems and of one-step multiplication and division problems, given in Tables
I and II of the Mathematics Glossary of the Common Core State Standards for Mathematics (CCSSM)
(www.corestandards.org/Ma). We started by familiarizing ourselves with the addition and subtraction problem
types. We constructed examples of problems of the fourteen types distinguished by the taxonomy. We shared and
analyzed some of the examples, and we discussed how wording varied from type to type. From this we progressed to
constructing, sharing, solving and analyzing two-step addition and subtraction problems, then three step. We
went through a similar process with multiplication and division problems.
Studying word problem through the taxonomies provided some valuable insights. One is, it makes visible the
complexity of the territory of word problems, in particular, the large number of different kinds of problems.
(The number of types of two-step problems is in the hundreds, and the number of three-step problems is in the
thousands.). The implication of this is that simple-minded approaches to word problems, such as using key words,
are doomed to failure. For students to succeed at word problems, they must learn to read problems carefully and
analyze the relationships between the various quantities given. Mastering word problems is genuine higher order
thinking. A second insight is that the taxonomies can give teachers insight into the complexity, and increase
their skill in navigating the territory of word problems, and in helping their students learn to do the same.
We ended by considering problems that combined types using any of the four operations. We observed that these
multi-operation problems were more or less typical algebra problems. We discussed different approaches to
solving such problems. We explored the standard approach through algebra: defining variables, converting the
information in the problem to equations, and solving the equations. We also saw that many of the problems could
be solved by what might be called arithmetic techniques, in which problem analysis allowed one to successively
isolate the unknown quantity and find its value. In particular, we discussed examples of the classical {\it
method of false position}, which was widely used before symbolic algebra was invented (mainly by Francois Viete
in the late 16th century). We also discussed how the Singapore bar model method could be used to approach these
problems.
The units are ordered by grade level, with the early grades coming first. Most of the units from the seminar make
use of the addition/subtraction taxonomy. The first four units, which are for first and second grade, focus
almost entirely on one-step addition and subtraction problems, with carefully articulated mixes of the various
types of such problems as described by the taxonomy. The units of Joshua Lerner and Melissa Anderson use the
one-step taxonomy to build competence with multi-step problems. Problem solving ideas are combined with an
introduction to fractions in Melissa Grise’s unit, with proportional reasoning in Aaron Bingea’s
unit, and with algebra in the units of Lawrence Yee and Hilary Waldo. The final unit, by Klint Kanopka, deals
with estimation problems, in contexts where much of the information needed for solving is not given in the
problem, but must be reconstructed by the student. All the units emphasize the need to for students to devote
careful attention to understanding the problem, and to the relationship between the quantities involved, in
order to arrive at a successful solution strategy.
Roger E. Howe
Synopsis of the Curriculum Units
15.05.01 - Taking the Problems out of Story Problems
by Corrina Christmas
This unit explores ways to give first grade students a good foundation of solving one step addition and subtraction
story problems so that they will become better problem solvers in not only first grade but it will follow them into
high school and even college.
It begins with decomposing numbers so that students understand how to break numbers into smaller numbers, adding
and subtracting within ten, breaking double digit numbers into tens and ones, adding within twenty, and story
problems.
The emphasis on this unit is the fourteen types of story problems (six change, six comparing, and two types of
part, part, whole. Not only what they are but how to solve them. It focuses on using inverse operations to help
students make connections about numbers and story problems.
This unit included the four step strategy in solving problems. Step one: How to understand the problem. Step two:
Devise a plan of how to solve the problem. Step three: Carry out your plan and check your answer. Step four:
Reflecting on the problem. Was the solution correct? If not what went wrong? Is there an easier way to solve the
problem?
(Developed for Math/Story Problems, grade 1; recommended for Problem Solving, grade K, and Story Problems, grades
1-2)
15.05.02 - Math is All Around Us: Representing and Solving One-Step Addition and Subtraction Word Problems within 20
by Danyelle Frye-Brulia
This unit concentrates on representing and solving one-step addition and subtraction word problems within 20. It is
important that students develop an understanding of the operations of addition and subtraction within the wide range
of situations where addition and subtraction can be applied. Students solve problems of 3 types including change
problems, part-part-whole problems and comparison problems. These types of problems are further divided according to
position of the unknown quantity, resulting in 14 problem types. Instruction emphasizes the use of manipulatives
based instruction following the concrete-pictorial-abstract approach. These strategies have been found effective
with students with disabilities as well as students experiencing difficulty mastering mathematical concepts at a
pace on par with their peers. The intended audience is first-grade. The unit could also be used with kindergarten
students that need enrichment or with older students who have not mastered problem solving of addition and
subtraction word problems within 20.
(Developed for Elementary Mathematics, grades K-2; recommended for Elementary Mathematics, grades K-2)
15.05.03 - Real World Problem Solving in Second Grade Mathematics
by Carol P. Boynton
For most second graders, the beginning of the year is a time for refreshing knowledge and skills from first grade.
The summer away from direct instruction and opportunities for practice and guidance sometimes means a loss of solid
understanding of learned concepts in mathematics. This three- to four-week unit is designed to review and build new
understanding of one-step word problem solving using addition and subtraction as students develop skills and
strategies they will use all year. The students, through a series of mathematical scenarios, will use the problem
types identified in Table 1 of the Common Core Mathematics Glossary which covers addition and subtraction.
For the duration of the unit, the focus remains steadily on solving and later constructing a collection of word
problems that provide robust and balanced practice. This integration of Language Arts and Mathematics throughout the
unit guides students as they connect math to the real world using the scenarios of activities they engage in at
school. A culminating activity includes the creation of a workbook filled with word problems, answer key included,
authored by the second grade students themselves!
(Developed for Mathematics, grade 2; recommended for Mathematics, grade 2)
15.05.04 - Planting a Seed for Problem Solving
by Christy Marie Schmidt-Applegate
(Developed for Mathematics and Science, grade 2; recommended for Mathematics and Science, all grades)
15.05.05 - Math at School: Modeling Addition and Subtraction in Everyday Classroom Scenarios
by Joshua Lerner
The Common Core State Standards present a helpful taxonomy for understanding the various types of addition and
subtraction word problems. Considering these many contexts, and the fact that any number in a situation may be
unknown in any given situation, there are so many possible variations in these word problems! To help students be
able to eventually approach and solve any addition or subtraction situation, it is important to help
students develop the habits of mind and approaches necessary to make sense of word problems in general. This
curriculum unit, written at Yale University in Summer 2015, uses a modeling method to help students make sense of
word problems, and presents a logical sequence of presenting students with one-step and two-step problems. The unit
also describes how to use a structured problem-solving lesson format to drive student higher-order thinking.
This curriculum unit will be taught to 3rd grade students but can be modified for 2nd grade
and 4th grade classrooms. The research presented on word problem types, modeling, and structured problem
solving is useful professional development for math teachers at all grade levels.
(Developed for Mathematics, grade 3; recommended for Mathematics, grades 2-4)
15.05.06 - Creating a Culture of Critical Thinkers in the Mathematics Classroom: Reducing Dependency on Key Words
by Melissa Rose Anderson
Creating a Culture of Critical Thinkers is a unit concerned with building confidence in the elementary
student’s ability to approach written math problems. This unit is intended for use in a fourth grade
classroom, but can be applied to a wide range of settings. It is the intention of this unit to prepare
students to parse and discuss many types of one and two-step, addition and subtraction word problems in an analytic
and reasoned manner. Problems will be analyzed through whole group discussions and cooperative learning. In addition
to giving examples on how to facilitate whole class discussions, a standard method for problem solving and a set of
word problems will be included. It is my hope that students will begin to view themselves as expert problem solvers
by the end of this unit.
(Developed for Mathematics, grade 4; recommended for Mathematics, grades 3 and 5)
15.05.07 - Fractions: Building a Foundation through Conceptual Understanding and Problem Solving
by Melissa Grise
Do your students struggle with fractions? In the unit Fractions: Building Conceptual Understanding and Problem
Solving students are given the opportunities to build their understanding of fractions and apply this
knowledge to problem solving. This unit is geared toward 4th grade students who may be lacking the skills
to access the classroom curriculum. The Common Core State Standards place a huge focus on building the understanding
of fractions through the unit fraction. Therefore, students will begin this unit by developing their understanding
of a unit and a unit fraction. Through the use of area models and linear models students will be able to represent
various unit fractions. As the students explore these models they will see the connections between improper
fractions and mixed numbers. Students will then study the taxonomy of addition and subtraction problems. The
practice will focus on the change increase and decrease problems with the use of fractions. Students will be given
opportunities to solve, identify, and ultimately write their own word problems. Through these activities your
students will have a much deeper understanding of what fractions represent and how to apply this when problem
solving.
(Developed for Mathematics - Fractions, grade 4; recommended for Mathematics - Fractions, grade 4)
15.05.08 - Developing Proportional Reasoning
by Aaron Robert Bingea
Proportional reasoning is the cornerstone of algebra and upper level mathematics. In the 6th grade
students are tasked with developing this new form of thinking to solve problems involving ratios, rates, and
proportional relationships. In years past, I have seen my students work through a unit on ratios and proportions and
develop nothing more than a set of rules and procedures for identifying and naming ratios and solving for missing
values in proportions rather than a more complete understanding of proportional relationships and their significance
to problem solving. In this unit I lay out a sequence of essential understandings that are necessary to develop
robust and flexible proportional reasoning. To reach these understandings, this unit discusses key strategies
students will employ to work through a purposefully sequenced, cohesive set of problems that provide a foundation
for students to develop sound proportional reasoning.
(Developed for Mathematics, grade 6; recommended for Mathematics, grades 6-8)
15.05.09 - Equations in the Common Core: Algebraic Reasoning and Problem Solving
by Hilary Waldo
Algebraic reasoning is a capstone of middle school math and serves as a gatekeeper of sorts for higher-level
mathematics and future careers. Middle school students frequently lack the deep understanding of algebraic reasoning
required to successfully manipulate and solve equations. This weaker foundation leads students to common algebraic
mistakes like not completely distributing a term when multiplied to an expression or attempting to simplify an
equation through inverse properties but only doing so on one side of the equation. These mistakes and their
underlying misconceptions hinder student success, as the 8th grade curriculum requires an increasing
level of sophistication in algebraic reasoning. A solid foundation in the underlying concepts of algebraic reasoning
paired with a classroom approach rich with the use of manipulatives and physical models can increase students’
capacity to solve multi-step equations. Manipulatives represent a concrete representation of abstract algebraic
reasoning that can serve to make the symbolic processes of algebra more accessible to all students.
(Developed for Common Core, grade 8; recommended for Algebra, grades 8-9, and Pre-Algebra, grade 7)
15.05.10 - Personalizing Problem Solving
by Lawrence Elliott Yee
This curriculum unit was designed to help students develop the mathematical problem solving skills and strategies
necessary to access the mathematics embedded within word problems and scenario based problems. The ability to access
the mathematics embedded within word problems and story-based scenarios is a major obstacle for students. Often word
problems found in textbooks are written with unfamiliar contexts to many students. Personalizing problems to
students’ interests to make mathematical content and word problems more familiar and relatable to students is
a recurring strategy that is emphasized throughout the unit. This unit presents an example personalized scenario
with example word problems while discussing how a scenario can be extended to include a variety of mathematical
content. Mathematical content discussed include the nine common types of one-step multiplication and division
problems, extensions to two-step problems, and extensions of the scenario to influence the development of algebraic
reasoning and problem solving. Reading strategies and differentiation of word problems to support student problem
solving within a personalized context are also discussed.
(Developed for CCSS Mathematics 1 [Common Core State Standards Integrated 1], grades 9-12; recommended for
Integrated Mathematics I, grades 8-9, Middle School Mathematics, grades 6-8, and Algebra I, grades 7-9)
15.05.11 - Solving Big Problems: Using Estimation to Develop Scientific Number Sense
by Klint Kanopka
This unit seeks to improve students’ number sense, problem deconstruction and communication skills through
the use of estimation questions known as Fermi Problems. Problem solving strategies, order of magnitude sense,
estimation skills, an understanding of precision and experience justifying mathematical computations with writing
will be developed. Students always ask, "when will I need this" and this unit attempts to give them something they
can use. The true value of a physics education comes in the ability to ask questions, make observations and solve
problems. Not just textbook or classroom problems, but real life problems. Number sense, especially when orders of
magnitude are concerned, is a tough skill to develop and internalize. Being able to decompose complex questions into
approachable parts puts understanding within reach.
This unit is designed for an 11th grade Physics class concurrently enrolled in Algebra 2 or Precalculus. It doesn't
depend on any particular physics content knowledge, so it is immediately applicable in a chemistry class. It would
also fit well into an Algebra 1, Algebra 2 or Precalculus class offered at the high school level. The complexity of
questions and techniques can be scaled depending on the age of the students.
(Developed for AP Physics I and Advanced Physics, grade 11; recommended for Physics, Chemistry, Environmental
Science, and Mathematics, grades 9-12)
Introduction by
W. Mark Saltzman, Professor of Chemical and Biomedical Engineering
Synopsis of the Curriculum Units
15.06.01 - Diabetes and Navajo Nation
by Priscilla Black
An observation of Native American Indians shopping at our local grocery store is frightening. Most young parents
fill up their shopping carts with sugary foods or foods that are high in carbohydrates. The new age of process food
has our native people in a battle against diabetes. A generation of many Navajos understanding Type 2 diabetes is
here. Student will see that human pancreas is an amazing gland that has a two part system that regulates the sugar
in the blood stream. The unit will give teachers some ideas of how to catch a young person’s mind with an
introduction of how Navajos and Alaskan Indians are two times more likely to be victims of Type II diabetes.
Let’s not stop at that, as you research Type II diabetes, you will be surprise that the United States and
other countries are seeing increased incidence of this hormonal disease with great concerns. What is there to do?
This unit will break down the reasons why Type II diabetes has becomes a problem. Students will learn the anatomy
and physiology of the pancreas. It will help students understand how the body break downs sugar, store it and uses
sugar. And of course, how the cells accept or rejects the glucose in our blood stream.
(Developed for English Language Arts, grade 4; recommended for Science, grade 4)
15.06.02 - Towards an Understanding of Disease Burdens in Developing and Developed Nations
by Cristobal Rene Carambo
The effect of carcinogens and pathogens on human health is a central theme in all environmental science classes.
Our health depends on an array of chemical, physical and biological processes that maintain homeostasis. These
internal mechanisms are directed by codes stored in our DNA: our genotype. Health is however determined by the
complex interaction of our genotype with the external environment as pathogens and toxins can invade our bodies and
occasion disease and / or death.
Recent health crises have proven that health must be viewed from a global perspective.
This unit will explore the physiological determinants of global health in two distinct phases. Students will first
study the cellular and genetic systems that maintain and safeguard their health. The second phase will require them
to evaluate data sets from the 2015 WHO global health summary and explain how demography influences health outcomes.
The common core standards suggest that teachers provide students the opportunity to evaluate and critique the
assumptions and theories that inform science phenomena in their everyday lives. Engaging students in the analysis of
complex sociocultural issues that affect global health will help improve these vital analytical skills.
(Developed for Environmental Science, grade 11; recommended for Biology, grades 10-11)
15.06.03 - Effects of Carcinogens on Cells
by Dawn Bernadette Curtis
Cancer is the name given to a collection of related diseases caused by the uncontrollable growth and reproduction
of mutated cells. No country in the world is safe from cancer creating a global impact on health and economics.
Cancer is the second highest cause of death in the United States. Genetics, tobacco use, sun exposure, radiation
exposure, diet and physical activity, alcohol consumption and other carcinogens such as pesticides contribute to the
increased risk of cancer all over the world. Through an awareness of some common carcinogens and cancer risks
students will discover ways to possibly decrease their personal risk. This unit discusses what carcinogens and
cancer are and how a healthy cell becomes a cancerous cell on a level for sixth grade science students. It
introduces the reproduction of cells and mitosis. This unit also provides an introduction on DNA and genes in
respect to the creation of a cancer cell.
(Developed for Science, grade 6; recommended for Science, grades 6-8)
15.06.04 - Genetics and Mechanisms of Disease
by Corryn Nikodemski
What keeps us alive? While it only takes four words to ask the question, an entire textbook is needed to answer it.
Posing this question to sixth graders allows me to gain valuable insight about a group’s background knowledge:
Some sixth graders are quite knowledgeable, but, more often than not, they a basic understanding of the human body.
This unit is designed for students to preview basic vocabulary and concepts associated with genetics and disease.
Understanding these concepts will foster connections between basic anatomy and physiology and molecular biology.
Students will be briefly exposed to cells and their nuclei, will discover how DNA is important to life functions,
and will read informational text on inherited diseases like Hereditary Sensory Autonomic Neuropathy (HSAN) and
Cystic Fibrosis. To support language arts teachers in the transition to the Common Core, students will be expected
to read informational text using close reading strategies. This unit utilizes hands-on activities to build interest,
direct instruction on content using structured note-taking, and mini-lessons on reading strategies to assist with
the comprehension of content students are responsible for reading alone.
(Developed for General Science, grade 6; recommended for Middle Level Science, grades 6-8)
15.06.05 - Recombinant DNA Technology and Global Health
by Tarie Pace
The unit, Recombinant DNA Technology and Global Health, is designed to teach students the benefits of genetically
modified organisms. It focuses on the basic needs of living organisms, and how environment plays an integral role in
acquiring them. Students will learn how DNA functions as a blueprint for living organisms. Students will explore how
scientists use DNA to understand the traits and characteristics of plants and animals. They will also use computer
applications to determine how characteristics are passed from parent to offspring. The unit provides several
experiments to demonstrate the extraction of DNA from human and plant tissue. There is also content information
available to provide instructors with background knowledge about biofortified crops, and why they are needed in
different regions. Literary resources are included to give students relevant information about genetically modified
organisms. The listed activities can be used in a primary classroom, but simple modifications are listed for use in
upper grades. A research component is included to provide students with independent research on the effect of
biofortified crops. This unit can be used to highlight regional disparities of nutritional intake, and how students
can use problem-solving skills to address them.
(Developed for Science and Social Studies, grade 3; recommended for Science and Social Studies, grades 4-6)
15.06.06 - Statistical Methods and Health in Chicago
by Sarah Schneider
The neighborhoods of Chicago lend themselves to a rich study of epidemiology. In this unit, students learn to apply
core statistical methods to health data sets. Students will work to understand the purpose and the power of
summarizing these data sets as they represent and model complex health situations in their surrounding community.
Through team exploration and guided research, they will complete and present an in depth statistical study into a
relevant health topic of their choice. Teams will then work to communicate their findings to their school community
as they learn to advocate for themselves and their health. Students in this 11th Grade IB Diploma Program
Mathematics course will also be expected to make interdisciplinary connections in their IB Diploma Program Biology
course throughout the school year as they investigate the biological underpinnings of health and disease.
Note: The scope and sequence of this 11th Grade Diploma Program Mathematics course is similar to that of
an Honors Precalculus course. Prerequisites for this course are High School Algebra, Geometry, and Advanced Algebra
with Trigonometry.
(Developed for Diploma Program Mathematics Standard Level, grade 11; recommended for Statistics, Algebra I-II, and
Biology and related Life Science, grades 9-12)
15.06.07 - The Changing Threat of Malaria and the Impact on Global Health
by Joe Van Sambeek
The curricular unit: The Changing Threat of Malaria and the Impact on Global Health is designed
to be taught to students in a high school biology course. Malaria is one of the largest killers today. Even with
billions of dollars being spent every year, over 200 million people are afflicted with the disease each year,
killing more than 500,000 of them. Through an examination of the disease malaria, students are exposed the nature of
the disease itself, the potential impacts climate change might have on the disease, the effects on humans, and
propose solutions to reduce human suffering. Hands on activities include examination of various types of cells and
microscopic organisms, raising of mosquitos to observe their lifecycle and investigating potential mitigation
efforts to minimize human suffering.
(Developed for Biology, grades 10-11; recommended for Biology and Environmental Science, grades 10-12)
15.06.08 - Every Breath You Take - Air Pollution’s Effects on Respiratory Health
by Vanessa Vitug
Have you ever tried to breath in air that is polluted? How much small particulate matter like dust, soot, smoke,
and fumes can be inhaled before your lungs are permanently damaged? Global air pollution is an ongoing health
problem faced by billions of people each year. Understanding and controlling air pollution can potentially prevent
human respiratory disease.
The objective of this unit is for students to understand how the respiratory system is affected by chronic
obstructive respiratory disorders like asthma, restrictive lung diseases like silicosis, and second hand smoke
exposure. Students will understand the relation between pressure, flow, resistance, and volume in the mechanism of
breathing and gas exchange. This background of respiratory anatomy and physiology will allow for students to connect
the global problem of air pollution to the respiratory health of individuals.
Varied Common Core based classroom activities will connect real world historical and current issues to help anatomy
and physiology students apply the content beyond the classroom. Through these connections, and the freedom for
students to explore and innovate solutions to today’s world problems, we will help students and teachers
become advocates for clean air and meet the demands of the Next Generation Science Standards.
(Developed for Physiology, grades 11-12; recommended for Biology, grades 9-10)
15.06.09 - The Role of Hormones in Homeostasis
by Andrea Lynn Zullo
The endocrine system relies on an intricate network of chemical messengers called hormones to control growth,
development, and metabolism from cradle to the grave. One of the key components of the endocrine system is its
ability to maintain homeostasis. When the body deviates from a set-optimal point, this system brings it back to
normal. There are devastating consequences when they body cannot restore balance. This unit provides a survey of the
endocrine system, and how positive and negative feedback controls our body. This topic involves the analysis of
positive and negative feedback loops and what happens when their delicate balance is disrupted. Examples of diseases
like acromegaly, diabetes insipidus, Hashimoto’s disease, and low testosterone are discussed in conjunction
with feedback loops. This unit ends with a look at medical interventions and the use of anabolic steroid abuse in
athletics. Students explore the above concepts using modeling, jigsaw reading, and other techniques compliant with
Common Core State Standards for literacy. The content and activities in this unit are meant for high school students
in biology or anatomy and physiology, but can be scaled to suit most grade levels.
(Developed for Human Body Systems, grades 10-11; recommended for Anatomy and Physiology Elective; Biology, grade
10; Health Courses, grades 9-12; and middle school Biology; grades 6-8)