Preface
In April 2007 the Yale National Initiative to strengthen teaching in public schools accepted sixty-three public
school teachers from ten cities to participate in seven national seminars held at Yale. The Initiative is a
long-term endeavor to establish exemplary Teachers Institutes in underserved school districts in states throughout
the country. Following the approach developed in New Haven and demonstrated in Houston, Pittsburgh, and other
cities, it builds upon the success of a four-year National Demonstration Project. Teachers Institutes are
educational partnerships between universities and school districts designed to strengthen teaching and learning in a
community's public schools. Evaluations have shown that the Institute approach promotes precisely those dimensions
of teacher quality that improve student achievement.
Half of the teachers, designated Yale National Fellows, were from six cities that are planning or exploring the
establishment of a new Teachers Institute: Atlanta, GA; Charlotte, NC; Chicago, IL; New Castle County, DE; Richmond,
VA; and Santa Fe, NM. Other National Fellows were from Teachers Institutes that are members of the National
Initiative League located in Houston, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, and New Haven. The Fellows attended an
Organizational Session of the seminars held in New Haven on May 4-5. The seminars reconvened during a ten-day
Intensive Session from July 2-13.
The seminars, which concluded in mid-August when the Fellows submitted their completed curriculum units, included
"Adapting Literature," led by Dudley Andrew, R. Selden Rose Professor of Film Studies and Comparative Literature;
"Renewable Energy," led by Gary W. Brudvig, Professor of Chemistry, Molecular Biophysics and Biochemistry; "Across
the Curriculum with Detective Fiction for Young People and Adults," led by Paul H. Fry, William Lampson Professor of
English; "Keeping the Meaning in Mathematics: The Craft of Word Problems," led by Roger E. Howe, William R. Kenan
Jr. Professor of Mathematics; "Maps and Mapmaking," led by Mary E. Miller, Vincent J. Scully Professor of the
History of Art; "Latino Cultures and Communities," led by Stephen J. Pitti, Professor of History and of American
Studies; and "The Science and Technology of Space," led by Sabatino Sofia, Professor of Astronomy.
The twin purposes of the national seminars were to provide public school teachers a first-hand acquaintance with
the Institute approach to high-quality professional development, and to cultivate their leadership either in a
League Teachers Institute or in the development of a new Teachers Institute. Each participating teacher wrote a
curriculum unit to teach students what he or she had learned and to share with other teachers locally and, over the
Internet, internationally. The units contain four elements: objectives, teaching strategies, sample lessons and
classroom activities, and lists of resources for teachers and students. The curriculum units National Fellows wrote
are their own; they are presented in seven volumes, one for each seminar.
The Yale-New Haven Teachers Institute is a permanently endowed unit of Yale University, which undertook the
National Initiative in 2004. The material presented here does not necessarily reflect the views of the funding
agencies.
James R. Vivian
New Haven
September 2007
Introduction by
Dudley Andrew, Professor of Film and Comparative Literature
Adaptation is a terrific topic for teachers of language and literature to learn about and exploit. Students at all
levels have a reservoir of tales with which they are at least vaguely familiar, from Cinderella and Beauty
and the Beast to A Christmas Carol and Lord of the Rings. All children will have seen one or
another well-known story in comic book form, as a puppet play, or dramatized on stage, not to mention via TV
cartoons. They understand that a given story can be read, staged, visualized, and even sung. For decades teachers
have used the protean quality of stories to liven up their classrooms with adaptations so as to generate enthusiasm
about important works of literature and the themes and issues contained in them. And some teachers of theater or
fiction have used adaptations as a way to isolate the specific properties of literature, by showing the kinds of
effects impossible to achieve on film or by providing visual examples of theatrical properties (such as staging) or
novelistic devices (such as point-of-view). When it comes to masterworks of theater and fiction, adaptations entice
reluctant readers to experience a work in a familiar, less intimidating format. At the same time one can see how a
story's greatness is a function of its powerful expression in its original medium.
Adaptation has always been a standard practice in the arts whereby a successful work is given extended and
invigorated life in the body of another medium. Shakespeare, Cervantes, and Jane Austen are alive today in the many
films through which recent generations have encountered them. To study adaptation might at first seem like a
technical exercise whereby the powers and characteristics of the medium in which the work originally appeared (play
or novel) are compared to those of its subsequent emanation. One can examine the successes and failures of any given
text being adapted (The Divine Comedy has never met with critical or popular approval when transposed) or the
quality of a particular version (did Baz Lurhman find the right formula in his 1995 Romeo and Juliet,
compared to the celebrated Zefferelli attempt?). The abiding values of the original can be recognized in the
limitations of what we experience as a kind of echo down the ages. And the powers of the medium for which it was
created can be compared to the different powers of the media into which it is made to fit later on. Much can be
learned from the careful side by side comparison of a prominent original and the versions it has engendered.
Our seminar proceeded through case studies that sampled a number of categories of adaptation. Some examples such as
Beauty and the Beast gave us a chance to look at several different historical moments and cultures when this
fairy tale became relevant in one way or another: in France in the late 18th century; then again in France just at
the end of WWII, and in the USA in 1991 in a version that still appeals to children around the world. The fact that
both films were popular and critical successes allowed us to look more deeply into the expressive properties and
limitations of animation and live action spiced up with trick photography. This story's origin is not terribly
important, and so later artists in many media feel justified in "borrowing" it for their own purposes and in their
own style. Myths operate as part of the cultural pool, such as the story of "Orpheus" which has been passed down but
without a definitive treatment. In 1959 a French filmmaker took it upon himself to set the tale in Brazil during
carnival time, producing the award winning Black Orpheus. On the other hand, most classic tales come very
much tied to the authors who made them famous: Romeo and Juliet, Don Quixote, and Oliver Twist,
for instance. When such masterworks are adapted, you can be sure that the relation of the new version to the
original is a matter of concern, and the question of "fidelity" is on the table. This issue has come under
tremendous scrutiny and it spilled into our seminar as well. It provides the reason to look intently at certain
adaptations that aim to "transform" the experience of the original into a modern medium. Our clearest example of
transformation was The Innocents made from Henry James' The Turn of the Screw which helped us assess
the powers of the both prose and cinema. Interestingly, this tale also became both a play and an opera, though we
did not look into these versions. Effort spent examining "transformations" can greatly improve our (and our
students') understanding of the original work and of the properties and powers of film and of verbal language to
deliver a fiction. Effort spent examining "borrowings," on the other hand, leads directly to discussion of broad
themes and of different cultural or historical attitudes toward those themes. Just showing a version of the
"Orpheus" myth raises questions about the power of art and imagination, about death and eternity, and about
jealousy. Such universal themes can be discussed on their own, but they take on a particular tone when "borrowed" by
Jean Cocteau in Paris shortly after the German Occupation. Adaptation lets one study the universal and the
particular, so that students can see connections between stories made with them in mind and much older or foreign
versions. This is always the case with recent adaptations of Shakespeare, when Leonardo DiCaprio plays Romeo or
Ethan Hawke plays Hamlet.
With the Shakespeare industry in mind, our seminar looked at processes of cultural dissemination whereby a great
many books, movies, plays, and even musicals have interacted in a larger sphere governed by an economy that has its
own momentum. We considered the franchising of art through Barnes and Nobles and other media conglomerates, as
novels or plays become films and some films get turned into musicals. Does a work's identity get lost as it gains
broad acceptance through its dispersal in different media? Does adaptation permit old forms to survive or does it
distort them so much that they lose their original value?
The stakes of the question are broader than literature. "Adaptation" is the name for Darwinian processes by which
species survive the changing circumstances of their environment. The word can be found in the cultural as well as
the biological sphere too. Individuals, families, and large social groups adapt during the normal course of their
life cycles, as when middle school children must adjust to changing classrooms, leaving the womb of their home
classroom and the security of a single teacher. More dramatically, individuals and groups can be forced to
adapt—or else to atrophy—when history brings them into sudden contact with an unexpected situation. Many
immigrant kids probably have a hard time adapting to the brusque social mores that operate in urban schools in the
U.S.
How do we feel about adaptation? The moral force of this question imposes itself whenever issues of personal or
ethnic identity are at stake, as when an overly sensitive child sheds his "poetic" nature to become "one of the
gang," or when the youngest members of a group that has immigrated abandons the rituals and language they were born
into so as to become fully assimilated (adapted) Americans. You can sense the ambivalence of this term clearly in
the culture industry when famous works are re-shaped to meet modern audiences under new conditions. And so this
seminar was concerned with that values as much as the techniques of adaptation.
Being such a common practice, adaptation is an umbrella term under which all sorts of curricular units could be
devised. Participants developed their individual units using the vocabulary and concepts that were tossed around the
seminar table. One unit focused on contemporary avatars of the Greek hero Ulysses, first so that students might
recognize that all people, including themselves, should cultivate virtues to meet the trials that will inevitably
come their way. Homer's particular way of linking these trials episodically will give these students a sense of this
foundational text and how it underlies so many of our stories. Naturally topics associated with Shakespeare (and we
had three of these) involve questions of fidelity. Since his plays are sacrosanct, every deviation from them
suggests an important "updating" either to make the original relevant in a different context or to bring out some
aspect of the original that a filmmaker wants to highlight or exploit for reasons of personal expression. Several
other units involved famous novels that became even much better known thanks to adaptations that ensued. This has
been true of H.G. Wells' War of the Worlds (1898) put on famously as a radio hoax in 1938 and then made into
two popular films (in 1953 and 2005). With The Color Purple, we have a Pulitzer Prize winning novel that
became a Steven Spielberg film three years later, leading to a much discussed Broadway Musical. There is something
powerful about the main themes of both the Wells and the Walker novels and about the ways they were successively
adapted, drawing huge audiences on each occasion. With Blade Runner we have the case of a film bringing
attention to an important but much overlooked 1968 novel. The differences between these two equal artworks initiate
a dialogue students can follow out about crucial themes (artificial intelligence, animal rights, free will) and
about the power of books and films. Some units combine a great deal of contextual material alongside works of
literature and film. One aims to expose students in Spanish classes to masterpieces of literature that open onto
cultural questions about Spain and Latin America. Another takes its point of departure from the 1961 film A
Raisin in the Sun to explore the landmark play written by Lorraine Hansberry, and through it, the history of
social change and social outrage involving African Americans in northern cities. One unit looks at the general
situation of entertainment culture in America, particularly animated films, to help students understand where their
values come from. Like all the units, but more directly, it aims to give students tools with which to watch films
critically.
And this was surely a chief value of studying adaptation. We all come away better able to understand how films make
meaning and, because of this, we can see just what kind of significance a story holds for the person or culture
adapting it. This leads to a far greater understanding and appreciation for the work's original composition and
situation. Teachers may be enthusiastic or appalled by the promiscuity of adaptation, by the way it so often tries
to entice the public through a seductively youthful look, the product of media cosmetics. Yet in parading famous
literature, adaptations provide an extraordinary opportunity to observe the entire mechanism of culture at work,
including the significance of these works and the cultural operations of the media in which they appear.
Dudley Andrew
Synopsis of the Curriculum Units
07.01.01 - The Odyssey: Seeing My Journey through Film
by Susan Hillary Buckson Greene
Finding purpose—discovering meaning in life—the journey…each describes our quest to become
better individuals. Some find meaning within the context of socially stereotyped structures, others in religious (or
dare I say mysterious) traditions; yet, of the two, religion has been most instrumental. Our understanding of such
relationship or lack thereof, ultimately forms our concept of self.
Homer's The Odyssey juxtaposes the struggle of one man, Odysseus, finding his place in this relationship as
he journeys home. He is not unique in his quest. In literature and in films, such characters—be they heroes or
the girl next door—are prevalent (even Dorothy was hailed as a savior after killing the Wicked Witch of the
West). Many works themselves parallel epic characteristics with their vast setting, covering many nations/worlds,
consistent deeds of valor and supernatural interventions.
This 2-week unit designed for ninth grade students at Booker T. Washington High School enrolled in the School of
Fine, Visual and Performing Arts examines the elements of the written epic as well as contextual parallels through
the use of modern films, O Brother Where Art Thou? and The Wiz.
(Developed for Literature, grade 9, and AP English Literature, grade 12)
07.01.02 - Hamlet and Hollywood: Using Film Adaptation to Analyze Ophelia and Gertrude
by Kristen Kurzawski
Hamlet and Hollywood: Using Film Adaptation to Analyze Ophelia and Gertrude, by Kristen S. Kurzawski
After teaching English literature to high school students for ten years I have realized that film adaptations of
literature can make an incredible difference to a student's basic comprehension of literature and aid in his/her
analysis. However, I also realize that adaptations create a specific interpretation of a text. The students come to
see this adaptation as the definitive interpretation of a piece of writing. I have had trouble helping students see
that a director is doing the same thing as a reader of a text. The director is interpreting the text and
transforming that text into a visual form. Students do this naturally. They have been programmed by modern society
to think in pictures and sound bites. They are bombarded by sensory stimuli. I have noticed that students discuss
literature in visual terms, and they respond well to visual writers. Therefore, I see the need for a unit that
engages students while teaching them that film is a powerful interpretive tool, one that offers an interpretation,
but not necessarily a definitive one.
With these things in mind I decided to create a unit which uses various interpretations of William Shakepeare's
Hamlet to initiate the students into film analysis as well as aid their analysis of a staged text.
Specifically this unit asks students to examine clips from Grigori Kozintsev's Hamlet (1964), Franco
Zeffirelli's Hamlet (1990), and Michael Almereyda's Hamlet (2000). These directors have adapted
Shakespeare's work in three distinctly different ways that allow for a myriad of discussion opportunities, but my
unit will focus our analysis on the opening scenes of the films and the portrayal of Ophelia and Gertrude within the
films. I believe discussion of the adaptations will lead to interesting interpretations of the text as well as a new
found way to examine film and Shakespeare.
(Developed for AP English IV, grade 12; recommended for English, grade 12)
07.01.03 - Macbeth and Issues of Gender
by Deborah Samuel
William Shakespeare's Macbeth is both the author's shortest and bloodiest play. It is therefore a natural
choice for high school students. Plays are meant to be performed and not merely read, as is usually the case in the
high school classroom. Therefore, it is a happy occurrence that instructors may now use video recordings, audio
recordings, and DVDs to bring the performance element into the classroom. But performance on film was not
Shakespeare's medium. On stage, the audience gets to look where it wants. The actors get to say their lines without
fear of winding up on the cutting floor. When we switch from a play to a film, the director is king, and we now have
possibly quite a different experience.
The artistry of cinema and the difficult task of taking a stage play and reinterpreting it for a different medium
offer students and teachers a plethora of interesting, and sometimes controversial choices to examine. The intention
of this curriculum unit is to examine four screen adaptations of Macbeth and to use them to enrich the
classroom discussion of Macbeth. These adaptations include Orson Welles' Macbeth (1948), Akira
Kurasawa's Throne of Blood (1957), Roman Polanski's Macbeth (1971), and Men of Respect(1990). Each
director has his own approach, visible in camera angles, lighting, sound, casting, omission and inclusion of
Shakespeare's lines, and the addition of scenes never written by Shakespeare. We will examine Macbeth through
the questions it raises about the nature of men and women. How are the witches and Lady Macbeth depicted? Who do
they cast? How are they dressed? How do they sound and move? Students will view selected scenes of the women in
Macbeth to enrich their discussions of Shakespeare's apparent attitudes. What is Shakespeare's original
intent, and do the directors aim to be faithful to this, or do they alter the meaning of the play as written to suit
a contemporary audience or personal point of view? Extensive background information as well as lesson plans meant to
address these issues in the classroom are included.
(Developed for AP English Literature and Composition, grade 12; recommended for English, grade 12)
07.01.04 - Modernizing Shakespeare: Finding Contemporary Themes from Othello
by Thomas J. Vari
This unit's ultimate purpose is to teach research skills, and is intended for tenth graders. The selections used to
meet this purpose are Shakespeare's Othello and adaptations of this play. In fact, a portion of this unit's
focus is adaptation itself. Students will realize that Shakespeare's play is actually an adaptation of an
Italian writer's short story. The play, Othello, is used as a backdrop for the lessons herein and the unit
uses the themes from this play to hook students prior to reading Shakespearean language. The unit uses film to
engage students as well as to provide a basis for the questioning strategies. These concepts and theories can be
used to teach film, adaptation, Shakespeare plays, and research skills. In this unit, my students look at modern
film to see that Shakespeare's themes can be applied to their own lives and situations. They also see that
Shakespeare adapted his work from another writer's. And, finally, they use this background knowledge about the power
of adaptation and the influence of Shakespeare to research other adaptations of Othello and write a
documented research report about an adaptation they've found on their own.
(Developed for English, grade 10; recommended for English, grades 9-12)
07.01.05 - War of the Worlds-Multimedia Adaptations
by Claudia L. Miller
Film as an instructional genre fits well into my full-inclusion, differentiated-instruction classroom sessions at
Alameda Middle School in Santa Fe, New Mexico. The promise that many of my special needs students hold truly
blossoms when they are afforded a new learning tool and a creative means for assessing what they've learned. My
current unit will look at H. G. Wells' famous 1898 text, The War of the Worlds, and the societal times during
which it was written. We will listen to the 1938 Halloween Eve radio broadcast of Orson Welles' Mercury Theatre
adaptation of the text which managed to petrify the nation. Students will be the judges of how the political times
in America set the scene for their gullibility. Two very different cinematic versions of The War of the
Worlds were released in 1953 and 2005. We'll view them in their entirety. A fourth medium, periodicals, will
allow students to read journalistic reports of the fallout from the radio broadcast and reviews of the book, the
broadcast, and the two movies.
All necessary background research will be included in this unit for my teaching colleagues. An annotated book
bibliography will aid in your selecting which texts you may want to peruse. I afford a selection of teaching
strategies and lesson plans which you can accommodate to a vast heterogeneous population of students. They correlate
with the content standards for all states. Lastly, assessment techniques will be included for teacher perusal as a
measurable means of student success.
(Developed for Language Arts, grade 8; recommended for Language Arts and Social Studies, Interdisciplinary Unit
with Language Arts)
07.01.06 - The Color Purple's Three-Fold Adaptation: Examining Protagonists and Media through a Self-Reflective, Critical Lens
by Ane Nyoka Ebie-Mouton
This curriculum unit serves a two-fold purpose. It will first examine the intertwining lives of season-three
American Idol winner, Fantasia Barrino, and the female protagonist Celie in Alice Walker's Pulitzer Prize
winning novel, The Color Purple, including its film adaptation. The three categories for examination of these
two characters will be Self-Esteem, Generational Curses, and Illumination of the Gift. The second section will
involve a critical examination of the book and its adaptation into a film and musical, in tandem with the passion
all three mediums have evoked. This passion has come in the form of controversy and love, which made these mediums
the subject of much criticism. The predominantly African-American fifth grade demographic I impact will benefit from
the first part of this study through creating real-world implications of these intertwining lives with their own.
The second part of this unit will develop the skills of in-depth analysis that will eqiup them to begin examining
various mediums of storytelling through a critical lens.
07.01.07 - Blade Runner Redux: Teaching a Sci-Fi Meta-Art Classic
by Clary W. Carleton
This curriculum unit provides a guide to teaching Philip K. Dick's Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? and
the film adaptation, Ridley Scott's Blade Runner. Both texts explore ethical and philosophical ideas related
to artificial intelligence. Because the unit is intended for a mixed-level, mixed-grade English class, it could be
adapted to a variety of teaching settings. For English teachers unfamiliar with these works, the unit articulates a
rationale for teaching by enhancing students' critical thinking, close reading, oral language, and writing skills.
Unlike other adaptation histories, it is the achievement of the film that has inspired a reassessment of the novel.
The unit will approach the film as an artistic accomplishment in its own right, rather than as a mere supplement to
the novel. Students will explore issues surrounding the idea of adaptation itself, empowering them to consider how
and why stories change, and the impact of the medium through which they are conveyed.
Through a variety of activities, students will focus on characterization, theme, and allusions in both the novel
and the film. They will also explore film noir and the elements of cinema, helping them elaborate upon ideas
in the novel. Overall, this unit aims to show students how these two texts work together as one "meta-art" classic.
(Developed for English, grades 9-12; recommended for English, grades 9-12)
07.01.08 - Spanish Cultures through Film and Literature
by Maria Cardalliaguet
"Spanish Cultures Through Film and Literature" is designed to expose Spanish I and II students to a
multi-disciplinary unit that uses exceptional literary pieces and their filmic adaptations as vehicles to explore
culture in context, since cultural understanding is crucial when learning a foreign language. Through this unit
students will acquire a deep understanding of the history, literature, art and music of two Spanish speaking
countries: Spain and Colombia. By doing so, students will also start thinking about global consciousness and the
importance of embracing global understanding.
Students will learn to analyze films in order to understand them as works of art with a complex structure and many
different layers of meaning and film techniques. My intention is that at the end of this curriculum unit students
will be able to discern the difference between a shot and a scene, a flashback and a flashforward, voice-over and
voice-off, mise-en-scéne and editing, etc.
Finally, This unit will also help me to implement the five-goal areas the National Standards of Foreign Language
Learning called the Five C's of Foreign Language Education: communication, cultures, connections (among
disciplines), comparisons (between cultures) and communities. My students will understand and interpret spoken and
written language; they will demonstrate an understanding of the traditions, products (texts and films) and
perspectives of the Spanish cultures; they will reinforce and expand their knowledge of other areas of study
(literature and film studies) through Spanish, and they will be able to compare the textual sources and their
adaptations to film.
The unit is recommended for Spanish students with a lower-intermediate level, but it could be used on upper level
courses with proper modifications.
(Developed for Spanish I and II, grades 9-12; recommended for Spanish I, II, and III, grades 9-12)
07.01.09 - Using Film and Literature to examine The Great black Migration: An Analysis of "A Raisin in the Sun" through poetic voices
by Sharon Monique Ponder Ballard
"And we have decided to move into our house because my father, my father, he earned it for us, brick by brick."
Walter Lee
When Walter Lee presents the question to mama, "Why did you move here to Chicago forty years ago from the south?"
mama explains, "I guess I came here to make a better life for me and my family." This will serve as the springboard
for introducing the Great Black Migration and the artistic expressions it occasioned in poetry and drama. Since my
eighth grade students live in Chicago, we will examine jobs, housing and educational opportunities, organizational
support systems and poetic protest.
Lorraine Hansberry's A Raisin in the Sun sets the stage for examining conflicts and themes that arise from
these historical and social events. Almost fifty years ago a young African American woman wrote the play Raisin in
the Sun describing some of the conflicts faced by a family struggling to achieve the American Dream. Have the Dreams
of African American's dried up like a Raisin in the Sun? The poet Langston Hughes asks this very compelling
question: "what happens to a dream deferred?" As a writer Lorraine Hansberry uses the plot of her play to explore
the overarching theme of fulfilling one's dreams which reverberates in each of her characters.
"Does a play or film reflect society's cultural, social or political views or visa-versa?" In this unit students
will examine, identify, interpret, and constructively critique recurring themes in the play and film. As a
Nationally Board Certified Teacher in the field of Middle Childhood Generalist, I have the richness of integrating
curriculum across content areas. Excerpts from the play and poetry will be used to emphasize various themes that
students can also identify through film analysis, making real life connections in the process.
(Developed for Language, Visual and Performance Arts, and Social Studies, grades 7-10; recommended for Language,
Visual and Performance Arts, and Social Studies, grades 7-10)
07.01.10 - Political Socialization: Finding Ourselves in Film
by Jeffrey C. Joyce
This unit deals with films, among other major media types, and the sway they might have on one's political ideals.
More pointedly, the unit asks that my Advanced Placement American Government students remember and research their
own histories to determine the political pressures that have been exerted on them over the course of many years.
Indeed, I want them to think about how they have had to adapt to their political climate given the media barrage
that has been a near constant in their lives and then how the media has had an effect on their political thoughts
and feelings.
The process is referred to as political socialization, or the ways that people become their political selves. Most
often political scientists give primary weight in this matter to family. But as times have changed and children
expose themselves to, and are often manipulated by, multiple forms of media, it is worth asking whether or not their
political opinions are in many ways a byproduct of the materials they consume. Therefore, this unit emphasizes the
role that film has played in my students' political development.
This unit includes the study of political ideologies first and then uses film analysis to find political rhetoric
in popular media. The unit then poses the question to students: have the films you have digested changed you,
politically? The overarching goal is to have students learn not only to appropriately define general political
ideologies in context, but to apply their understanding to their own lives and then, through some self-discovery,
pinpoint the origins of their own political belief system.
(Developed for AP Government and Politics, grade 12; recommended for AP Government and Politics, grade 12)
Introduction by
Paul H. Fry, William Lampson Professor Emeritus of English
In introducing "Across the Curriculum with Detective Fiction for Young People and Adults," I have no temptation to
change the title of the seminar. All the authors in this volume took very seriously the selling point of the
seminar, which was that detective fiction is not only fun to read—which makes it great for reluctant
readers—but sets more parts of the brain to work than nearly any other kind of fiction that gets assigned. The
curriculum units written for this seminar could certainly be arranged in more than one way. Three units each, for
example, focus on Walter Mosley and Arthur Conan Doyle, respectively, and there are other patterns too among the
authors chosen, but it just didn't seem as close to what really was on all the fellows' minds to arrange them this
way. Their main concern, as was likewise the case in my children's literature seminar last summer, was just getting
their students to the point where they're willing to read by drawing on various parts of the school curriculum, not
just the standard "English" rubric. I've ordered the table of contents, therefore, around different angles of
approach to this objective: 1) Reluctant readers (two units); 2) logical reasoning (two units); 3) creative writing
(one units); ethnicity, identity, and community ethics (four units).
Jessica Colbert has the daunting task of teaching slow readers and bright students who are maladjusted, all
in the same middle school classroom. For the purpose she has chosen one novel, Walter Mosley's Devil in a Blue
Dress. While this novel is meant for adults, it is technically—according to word-scanning
techniques—written at the fourth or fifth grade level, and Colbert means to exploit this range of appeals
while preparing reading and even audio exercises that suit her students' range of abilities. Cathy Kinzler is
a school librarian who spends time in the library encouraging groups of reluctant readers. She has chosen a short
novel for adolescents about a teenage fratricide that a friend of both brothers is reluctant to bear witness to for
a variety of reasons. (Reluctance to "snitch" was on several teachers' minds, and this a theme Kinzler shares with
Shaub.'s unit described below.)
Two teachers took a special interest in the potential of detective fiction for enhancing skills in logical and
inferential reasoning. Ella Boyd is a seventh grade science teacher whose first task is to teach students who
have had no exposure to science something about the scientific method, especially the difference between inductive
and deductive reasoning. Her main commitment is to science, of course, but she intends to introduce both some
three-minute mystery problems for younger readers by Donald Sobol and some Sherlock Holmes stories to illustrate her
lessons, and to do some across-the-curriculum teaching while she's at it. Mary Lou Narowski will also use
Sherlock Holmes as her main vehicle, but her focus apart from reading, and to enliven reading, is the encouragement
of students to invent their own games of detection, at three different levels of sophistication according to their
respective talents. The guidelines for these exercises, and their payoff, constitute the unit's unique contribution.
As a teacher of creative writing, Deborah Dabbs had worked reluctantly with the curricular directive from on
high to get her students writing narratives on the "epic" model—whatever "epic" in this context might be
supposed to mean. Not surprisingly, she leapt at the chance to use detective fiction for this same purpose, and she
has written a unit using a variety of short detective stories together with Christie's Murder of Roger
Ackroyd as models both for free composition and for exercises such as rewriting outcomes and writing plausible
first sentences.
Bonnee Breese hopes to teach primarily African-American high school students lessons across the curriculum
in identity, community ethics, and understanding historical context by using a sequence of novels by Walter Mosley,
Barbara Neely, and Chester Himes. Historical specificity can be taught through Mosley's sequence of Easy Rawlins
novels from postwar into the Watts years and through Himes's late Harlem Renaissance ethos, while Neely focuses not
only racism but infra-racial tensions, especially in Blanche Among the Talented Tenth. Laura Zoladz
uses Mosely, Neely, Tony Hillerman, and Sharyn McCrumb to reinforce a high school curriculum in American literature
that is meant to examine such topics as the American Dream. She sees these authors as offering excellent ways to
imbue such topics with nuanced skepticism—especially nuanced in the case of Hillerman. William Lewis
too is interested in a writer about Native American matters, the Wyoming-based Craig Johnson, but the novel he
chooses for his unit entails the visit of Johnson's detectives to Philadelphia, where Lewis teaches. Hence his unit
is simultaneously an introduction to the form of detective fiction and an examination of Philadelphia as
neighborhood and familiar backdrop. Finally, Christine Shaub teaches vocational-technical students a course
that prepares them for paralegal work. She is concerned that their views of snitching can scarcely allow them to be
objective in their chosen field, so she has decided to stage a series of pointed conversations about the social
circumstances of witnesses and the withholding of evidence, using a sequence of young adult novels that focus this
issue as starting points for discussion.
How to "hook" students on reading? These units offer nine very promising possibilities.
Paul H. Fry
Synopsis of the Curriculum Units
07.02.01 - Using Walter Mosley Detective Novels (Devil in a Blue Dress) to Motivate Reluctant High School Readers
by Jessica Colbert
This curriculum unit will focus on the writings of Walter Mosley. It will center on the whole class reading of
Devil in a Blue Dress, with the possibility of exploring other Easy Rawlins stories and/or other detective
fiction written by African American authors.
This unit will be implemented in a mixed grade level (9-12) special education resource English class in a
low-income high school. Included in the class are students with learning and/or emotional disabilities as determined
by a psychological report and Individualized Education Plan (IEP). It is my opinion that this unit can be modified
and adapted for a regular education classroom as well. Included in this unit is a section for an activity used as an
extension for my population of students with learning disabilities. This activity includes examining the notion of
double-consciousness in Devil in a Blue Dress and subsequent Easy Rawlins novels. This portion of the unit
would be very appropriate for any regular or honors education class.
(Developed for English-Learning Support, grades 9-12; recommended for English, grades 9-12)
07.02.02 - Using a Mystery Novel to Encourage Pleasure Reading and Imaginative Thinking
by Cathy C. Kinzler
This unit is designed to promote reading for pleasure and the use of higher order thinking skills in middle school
reluctant readers, particularly seventh and eighth graders. I use one mystery novel, Blood Trail by Nancy
Springer, but the activities could be adapted for other literature. The mystery genre is a great choice for engaging
students who do not enjoy reading because it capitalizes on the current popularity of television programs dealing
with crime solving. Mysteries provide a perfect opportunity to grab students' attention. Trying to solve the
"whodunit?" can pull them into the print world of the characters' emotions and quandaries, making them experience
questions like "Shall I 'snitch' on a friend?" This novel is excellent for my purposes because it is short and
written at about a fifth-sixth grade level, allowing students to become personally involved in a story involving the
murder of a high school boy by his twin brother and the ethical situations surrounding it. Activities include using
oral language skills and graphic organizers, writing expository and persuasive narratives, working with elements of
a story, summarizing, predicting, and higher order thinking skills such as inferential and imaginative thinking. An
extensive list of mystery novels is included.
(Developed for English, grade 7; recommended for Reading and English Language Arts, grades 7-8)
07.02.03 - Using Detective Fiction to Reinforce Problem Solving Strategies and the Scientific Method
by Ella M. Boyd
This unit, "Using Detective Fiction to Reinforce Problem Solving Strategies and the Scientific Method," is meant to
be used in a middle school science classroom. It is a unit designed for integration of the science and language arts
curricula. The focus for this particular unit is a short story by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, but greater participation
from the language arts teacher would allow the use of a full novel. The unit will focus primarily on observation and
inference skills, the basic kinds of skills needed for critical thinking in science. Science should be taught as a
process, not memorization of facts, and the use of detective fiction will help to accomplish that goal. The
classroom activities include a series of activities to practice observation skills, to practice making inferences,
and then to apply those skills to solve a short mystery story. The difference between inductive and deductive
reasoning is discussed, especially the way Sherlock Holmes uses those skills for solving crimes.
(Developed for General Science, grade 7; recommended for General Science, grades 6-8)
07.02.04 - D. I. E.
by Mary Lou L. Narowski
This unit combines the use of mystery board games to grip my students in ways that will really stimulate
them and hold their interest, with negotiation of a labyrinth of intrigue found in detective fiction. I have chosen
eleven mystery stories, one of which is in film version, by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, as I feel that these
stories are accessible to my students in terms of appropriateness and reading ability. Added to this is the
complement of their personal voices expressed in an expository writing (crime) journal. These mystery stories will
engage students while producing and reinforcing emergent literacy abilities, all while following the detective in
the whodunit, what happened world of secrecy and suspense. These stories will help in the development of logic,
reasoning, and higher order critical thinking as they struggle to find the explanation of the crime. The basic
literary elements inherent in any story will also be reinforced. Finally, the invention of group mystery
games will provide ample room for innovation and creativity as the students proceed from playing the marketed
game of Clue, Master Detective, with their own cast of characters, creating their own reading level version
of a crime game.
(Developed for Language Arts, grades 7-8; recommended for English Language Arts, grades 7-9)
07.02.05 - Uncloaking the Clues: Details, Daggers, and Detection
by Deborah Denise Dabbs
As it has become increasingly obvious over the years, educators do not operate in a vacuum. We are, to a degree,
dependent upon the efforts and cooperation of our colleagues. Therefore, this curriculum unit seeks to use the study
of the detective genre to develop and hone students' problem solving skills. By using the conventions and tenets
associated with detective fiction, the students will write stories in this genre. Because this course of study calls
for the students to encode as they write, their use of the tenets of detective fiction will aid them in learning to
decode in other areas, specifically academic areas which require the use of problem solving skills. This will occur
because the study of this genre highlights the fact that the key to acquiring all of the necessary ingredients to
solve a detective mystery is an attention to detail. Therefore, through their writing of stories which require that
their detectives use this skill as they endeavor to solve crimes, the students will hone their own abilities to
detect details and uncover clues which allow them to glean the understanding necessary to solve problems presented.
Their mastery of the skills necessary to write detective fiction will enable them to develop and use critical
thinking skills, thus fostering higher order learning.
(Developed for English IV, grade 12, and Creative Writing, grades 9-12; recommended for English I-IV and Creative
Writing, grades 9-12)
07.02.06 - Crime Fiction Investigation: "Socially Correct or Not, Let Me Tell You Who Did It"
by Bonnee L. Breese Bentum
This curriculum unit investigates the detective novel series of three African-American writers, Walter Mosley's
Easy Rawlins series, Barbara Neely's Blanche series, and finally Chester Himes' Coffin Ed and Grave Digger series.
The focus of the unit takes students through a curriculum study in giving them familiarity with African-American
writers who have contributed exceptional mystery writing to the literary canon. This unit, more specifically, is
intended to have students explore issues of race, economic status, community, social structure, good versus evil,
and gender in the creation of a story that uses the principles of the crime fiction genre. Furthermore, this unit
will be evidence for students to understand how close the connections are between literature and history. The unit
allows students to read and write about their own societal issues in a way that is accessible and entertaining. This
curriculum unit is intended for use in the high school English Language Arts classroom.
(Developed for English Language Arts, grades 9 and 12; recommended for English Language Arts, African American
History, and African American Literature, grades 9-12)
07.02.07 - Beyond Criminal Justice: Investigating Social Issues through Detective Fiction
by Laura Viviana Sturgeon
Detective fiction, a genre often considered solely for entertainment, abounds with good writing and trenchant
social criticism; it is also a treasure trove of high interest literature, accessible for students of all
backgrounds and levels. In this particular unit, I target 11th grade American Literature students who attend a
Vocational-Technical High School in New Castle County, Delaware. The unit revolves around four novels: Walter
Mosley's Devil in a Blue Dress, Barbara Neely's Blanche among the Talented Tenth, Sharyn McCrumb's
If I'd Killed Him When I Met Him, and Tony Hillerman's A Thief of Time. It also includes stories by
Dorothy Sayers and Raymond Chandler in order to familiarize students with the genre's traditional conventions so
that they will better understand how the novelists subvert or alter these conventions for purposes which include
social criticism and the creation of an aesthetic that is true to each author's social and cultural identity. The
novels deal with themes of identity, social class, race, ethnicity, gender, assimilation, and discrimination, while
containing complex protagonists and intricate plots; hence they can be used to study characters and to analyze the
structure and conventions of plot and narrative. Meanwhile, students will enjoy the challenge of beating the
protagonists to the solution of the mystery.
(Developed for American Literature, grade 11; recommended for English, grade 11)
07.02.08 - More Than Just Whodunit - Using a Mystery Story to Motivate Tenth-Grade Students to Read
by William Sandy Lewis
This curriculum unit would be useful to high school teachers of English or social studies in the tenth, eleventh, and
twelfth grades. There are possibilities of examining the Cheyenne Indian culture, the Lenape Indians, many aspects of
Philadelphia, including its neighborhoods, its historical institutions, its cultural and governmental institutions, as
well as its wealth of public art in the form of its parks, fountains and sculptures all in the context of an enjoyable
mystery story.
(Developed for English, grade 10; recommended for English and Social Studies, grades 10-12)
07.02.09 - Police Investigative Challenges: To Snitch or Not to Snitch, That is the Unanswered Question
by Christine Shaub
Police investigations are challenged without a cooperative witness. To snitch or not to snitch is a question the
witness to a criminal offense must answer. This unit was devised so students could learn more about the challenges
of solving crimes when there is an uncooperative witness. Those persons who do come forth may be "tagged" as a
snitch. This is an ethical dilemma for students if ever faced with such a situation.
Through crime fiction, students will look at the meticulous work of crime detectives. When a witness withholds
information, the detective must utilize clues from the crime scene, and beyond, to put together pieces of the
puzzle. Using crime fiction to teach about witness intimidation will give the students an opportunity to walk in the
shoes of the detective and better understand investigative challenges.
Students will create a mystery skit, a mock trial, a new courtroom design, and an informative witness brochure.
Students will have a better understanding of police procedures in relation to solving crime, witness intimidation,
witness protection, police corruption, as well as the social and cultural implications of the snitching phenomenon.
(Developed for Introduction to Criminal Justice and Legal Administrative Assistant Career Program, grades 9-12;
recommended for grades 8-12)
Introduction by
Mary E. Miller, Sterling Professor of History of Art and Dean of Yale College
What is a map? How is it that we visualize our world in a two-dimensional form? How is it that we understand the
social meanings of maps so clearly that we can call for a "road map for peace" or talk about a mental "map"?
Humankind has invented maps time and again, from ancient China to Babylonia to ancient Mexico. Conquerors created
maps as their tools, from the European "scramble" for Africa to the westward charting of Americans during the 19th
century. Maps that are unique works of beauty have been painted to adorn the walls of kings and popes; maps have
been printed by the million to stuff into the glove compartments of our cars. The past ten years have seen an
explosion of new kinds of mapping, from Mapquest to Googlearth to the GPS devices that guide cars and nuclear
warheads. Where will maps go next?
The seemingly visual map may nevertheless provoke the written word, from the maps of Tolkien's trilogy to the map
of Treasure Island. The drive to complete the idea of the complete map has led humans to explore the ends of the
earth, from the North and South Poles to remote islands to the sources of the Nile and Amazon, and, most recently,
to send satellites far into space. Yet no map can ever be complete—and in one respect or another, no map can
ever be completely accurate.
In this seminar, we looked at some of the earliest efforts to create a two-dimensional rendering of the earth,
along with the development of the instruments that would make such renderings possible. At the same time, the social
meanings of maps and mapping always stayed in the foreground of our considerations. We spent two sessions outdoors
learning the most basic principles of map survey, first by measuring strides while holding a compass; the second by
using tape, compass, and level. Seminar participants worked in teams, learning to stride, measure, and orient. This
practical knowledge—and a little geometry—gave all members of the seminar some basic understandings and
hands-on experience of maps as they have been made before the age of satellites and GPS.
Fellows of the seminar developed units that emphasized geography and history, both in westward expansion of the
United States and in units that addressed focused, historical phenomena, from the Underground Railroad and the
migration northward of African-Americans in the 20th century. Fellows took advantage of US Census data to explore
the mapping of poverty, both in general and with attention to specific urban and rural locations. Others took the
map and made it central to literature and writing, making map study both a part of understanding a particular work
and using the map as the point of departure for expository writing. Art teachers explored the graphic possibilities
of the map; they also used the map as the point of departure for the teaching of perspective drawing and rendering;
the map also was taken as the underpinning for art history survey.
In the end, all units found ways to address the map metaphorically as well. In this, the seminar shared a "mental
map" in recognizing relationships between tangible, visual images and notions of order and coherence that pervade
our constructions of the world.
Mary E. Miller
Synopsis of the Curriculum Units
07.03.01 - The Underground Railroad and the Geography of Freedom: Using Slave Narratives and Negro Spirituals as Maps
by Sheila Lorraine Carter-Jones
This unit gives a theoretical and historical basis for the inclusion of the African American voice in the reporting
of the history of slavery in America. Students will participate in creative dramatics activities as ways of
understanding real events in the lives of enslaved Africans in America and the function of the Underground Railroad.
They will also refine and broaden their understanding of important human qualities: courage, perseverance, respect
for the dignity of human life and the concept of freedom-as justice. Intellectually, they will have the opportunity
to engage concrete stimuli with an imaginative response, increase their ability to be intellectual risk-takers, and
generate optional ways to think, feel, and do and to solve problems.
Through writing and map making/reading/interpreting skills students will have the opportunity to identify and come
to terms with some of their own feelings, perspectives and understandings of slavery and the physical and psychic
geography of plantation life. Using literary devices to engage real people in history as literary characters, all
students will learn historical truths and understand how they each are a part of and not apart from American
history. Let me add here that the following lessons provide learning activities for the eighth grade but can be
adapted in small ways to be suitable learning activities for any grade level.
(Developed for Communications, History, and Community, grades 6-12; recommended for Communications and History,
grades 4-12)
07.03.02 - Mapping Change: How Colonialism Changed a Man, His Community, and His Culture
by Anne Marie Esposito
To appreciate and value a culture an individual needs to experience it and that is what Chinua Achebe allows a
reader to do in his novel, Things Fall Apart. This unit helps students see how a Eurocentric view of the
world and its peoples allowed European nations to systematically expand their influence and control in Africa even
though it was populated by many tribes who had an established and civilized way of life. Through their study of
various European maps, students will learn that maps have a purpose and point of view. Often the maps we have been
shown support a belief that Africa was in need of European governance and that the European powers were on a
humanitarian mission to save the people of Africa. After examining these maps students will know that maps can alter
the way someone or someplace is perceived since maps can reveal as well as hide information. As they read Things
Fall Apart, students will learn, as Achehe intended, that the people of Africa had a rich and sophisticated
tribal society worthy of recognition and respect. Through Okonkwo, students will uncover the traditions and values
of Igbo society and its rich oral traditions.
(Developed for English, grade 12; recommended for English, grade 12)
07.03.03 - Maps and Mapmaking for the Artist
by Elizabeth R. Lasure
As I read the outline for this seminar I was immediately struck by the similarities of the challenges of the early
explorers/mapmakers and that of art making. The world for them must have appeared both exhilarating and
intimidating. The risk these early explorers took combined a spirit of adventure, a knowledge (limited as it was) or
sense of place and a great deal of courage and conviction. I believe the nature of art making to be similar.
No doubt, art making is hard. To be inspired, to create innovative marks on a page, and to confront personal
censure are difficult challenges for artists and teachers alike.
Through a series of 'personal geographies' - or works of art that map their past and future lives- students will
explore the history of maps and mapmaking. What ways do we use maps? How do they define their subject? How do they
define what is not know or cannot be seen? How do they lie? These questions will help students consider the content
of the maps they study, as well as the potential expressive qualities of the map as a medium in art making. Maps
have their own inherent visual qualities of tone, value, and density. Maps also make use of such dominant elements
as line and color. Maps make use of both the literal and conceptual make-up of a work of art.
(Developed for Studio Art, grades 10-12; recommended for Studio Art, grades 10-12)
07.03.04 - The Beautiful Art of Map Making
by Mayra Muller-Schmidt
The mind's eye that humans have is a very special ability that rarely is mentioned. Humans are able to see and take
measurement of land, and convert it in their minds as line and contours. The idea of a map and then drawing it
according to scale is part of a very special ability. It is called spatial reasoning. How does one develop
this? Obviously, abstract thinking is involved. Understanding a map has its spatial or visual requirements. It is a
cognitive and abstract thought. You see flat yet think in round terms. Illustrated maps can summon visions of
ancient places, treasure maps and top secret places. Maps are everywhere. Indeed, maps are an integral part of
common daily life.
The middle school child is at the point of expanding his visual sense of spatial reasoning. To think of angles,
transparency, parallels, and the like makes an introduction to abstract thought, geometry, algebra, and other
concepts easier to grasp. That also leads to being able to display an understanding of patterns and relationships.
So what does that have to do with making and learning about maps? Map-making is one of the oldest and least talked
about skills. Additionally, the beauty of mapmaking is rarely presented as an art skill. The knowledge of using the
compass, charting, measuring and all other tools of the trade must be understood by the map-maker. My unit will
provide discussion, research, writing, science, geography, history and art to surround the students with ways in
which to enrich their spatial reasoning skills.
(Developed for Fine Arts, grade 6, and History, grades 6-8; recommended for Geography, Fine Arts, History, and
Mathematics, grades 6-10)
07.03.05 - Mapping + Episodic Short Short Stories = Classroom Writing Success
by Janelle A. Price
The creation of their own personal life story map is the guide for students in developing a writing portfolio of
three to five episodic short short stories, a sub-genre of short stories using only 500 to 1,000 words. The students
begin the unit through the exploration of cartography, centering on the decorative mappae mundi and portolan charts
of the Medieval period. The short short story sub-genre is simultaneously introduced through classic and modern
examples. The unit shifts to a writing focus with exercises that illustrate the specific characteristics of the
sub-genre, but can be used for any story writing. These exercises include: the development of a motif, use of
tension, dialogue, story prompts, and revision cues. Included in the unit are assignment sheets, rubrics, a brief
early history of cartography with a vocabulary list, and suggested maps and short short stories to use in the
classroom.
(Developed for English IV, grade 12; recommended for English, grades 10-12)
07.03.06 - The Rhetoric of Maps and the Westward Expansion of the United States
by Ralph E. Russo
The acquisition of new territories by the United States between 1783 and 1850 expanded the nation's borders to the
Mississippi, then to the Rocky Mountains, and finally to the Southwest and West Coast. A pageant of now famous
historical figures, as well as, lesser known, and unknown persons, pushed the frontier further westward through
politics, diplomacy, squatting, courage, good fortune, warfare and, at times, apparent thievery. However, of all the
tools at the disposal of politicians, patriots, explorers, adventurers, businessmen, and speculators, the map, above
all things, legitimized westward expansion and symbolically made these gains manifest. With all of its rhetorical
powers, lies, and limitations, the map became the concrete embodiment of the notion of Manifest Destiny.
This unit is created to incorporate the rhetoric of maps, 18th and 19th surveying and mapmaking techniques, and the
historical events that lead to the westward expansion of the United States into the United States history curriculum
at Wilbur Cross High School, a comprehensive urban high school in New Haven, Connecticut. While it is specifically
designed to target student needs in my 10th grade United States History I class, it should be easily adapted to work
with students in grades 7-12. The unit includes background information on events such as the Mason Dixon Line, the
Land Ordinance of 1785, and the Lewis and Clark Expedition. It also contains reference to numerous map collections
and authoritative works. Most importantly I believe my unit features an instructional, yet fun, map practicum where
students will use period mapmaking tools and techniques (compass, striding, and Gunter's chain) to measure, scale
and draw space around our school.
(Developed for U.S. History I, grade 10; recommended for History and Social Studies, grades 7-12)
07.03.07 - Santa Fe and the World: Maps and Mapmaking of People, Places and Poverty
by Meredith Charlton Tilp
In a world of constant overstimulation, how do we get a student's attention and hold it? How does the teacher
compete in the multi-dimensional world of iPhones, Ipods, and text messaging? How do we utilize multi-media teaching
in assisting students to grasp complicated concepts? Like the early explorer who made maps as he/she entered unknown
territories, the modern teacher can use maps to explicate concepts and make them visually available to students.
Maps, in so far as they use color and symbols, size and shape, are student attention grabbers. Historical maps,
political maps and tourist maps all have a point-of-view. Data maps pretend to be representative yet they are
distinctly biased. Maps of poverty average incomes to provide a synopsis of events, lives and 'a snapshots of
facts.' They require critical thinking, analysis and imagination—powerful teaching tools.
Even more powerful is the hands-on process of mapmaking - because it engages students in research that allows them
to experience information viscerally instead of in the abstract. Students will learn to make their own maps in which
their local world is the center.
(Developed for U.S. History, grade 11, and U.S. Government and Economics, grade 12; recommended for U.S. History,
Geography, U.S. Government and Economics, and Civics, grades 11-12)
07.03.08 - Portraits of Places: Maps and Art from the European City View to the Aboriginal Dreamtime Paintings
by Kimberly Kellog Towne
This curriculum unit is designed for middle school students but could easily be adapted to upper elementary and
high school students. The students will explore the viewer's relationship to place by exploring perspective in some
depth. In short, we will look at perspective, both technically and metaphorically. The students will be introduced
to basic linear perspective techniques and how artists use the various techniques to depict a 3D effect on a 2D
surface. They will be expected to be able to describe and use a variety of techniques, including position, size,
overlapping, detail, and atmospheric perspective. We will then focus on perspective from four main points of view:
worm's eye view, human's eye view, bird's eye view and satellite view. The students will explore a variety of maps
and landscapes from different times and different places. City maps from the Renaissance period will be a major
focus, as will the landscape paintings of the Australian Aboriginals. The realistic, bird's eye view of the
Renaissance city maps will be contrasted with the symbolic, satellite views in Aboriginal art. Students will
ultimately have a much deeper understanding of perspective, both visually and cognitively.
(Developed for Art, grade 6; recommended for Art, grades 5-9)
07.03.09 - Mapping the Great Migration 1916-1930: African American Movement from the South to the North
by Stephanie R. Felder
Why study the Great Migration of 1916-1930? Philadelphia is a city that is more than fifty-percent African
American. Many of the people that live in the city today have origins in other parts of the country and the world.
Historically, as a city located in a border state during slavery, Philadelphia has a long history of being a home
for free African Americans. Throughout history, people have migrated to and emigrated from places. Migration is
nothing new but the time period of 1916-1930 brought about a movement of African Americans from the South that has
not been duplicated since. As a mandated part of the Philadelphia High School curriculum, African American history
is a vital part of the education that my students receive. Students today do not seem to inquire about the social,
economic and political aspects of society. This curriculum unit will give them an historical perspective about one
group of people in American society. I hope that students learn to be inquisitive about their own past and well as
that of others. In doing so, I want my students to gain the analysis and inquiry skills needed to be successful in
today's educational climate and society as a whole. In this curriculum unit I will utilize the geographic themes of
location, place, human- environment interactions, movement and regions. I will also turn to the social studies
themes of culture; time, continuity and change; people, places and environments; individual development and
identity; individuals, groups and institutions; power, governance and authority; production, distribution and
consumption; science, technology and society; and global interactions. I will use these themes to examine and
explore migration. My purpose in using the themes of geography is to help students understand the absolute and
relative position of a place on Earth's surface, how physical and human characteristics define and distinguish a
place, how humans modify and adapt to natural settings, how people, ideas and material move between and among
locations, and how an area displays unity in terms of physical and human characteristics. These social studies
themes will provide the framework for the standards that will be addressed in this unit. Having studied maps and map
making from an artistic, historical and practical perspective, I endeavor to have students gain not only a
historical perspective of "The Great Migration" and also a practical understanding of maps and map making. I plan to
do this through giving students the opportunity to study about geography, which is sorely lacking in the high school
curriculum, but also to drive the study of geography by analyzing and examining a historical event that is relevant
to our coursework, our local community and many of their cultures.
The unit will span the course of a semester as students study various topics in an African American History course
designed for high school students. The grade level is primarily eleventh. The unit will consist of six lessons of
history and geography.
(Developed for African American History, grade 11; recommended for American History, African American History, and
American Literature, grades 9-12)
Introduction by
Stephen Joseph Pitti, Professor of History and of American Studies
This 2007 national seminar gathered talented and energetic teachers to discuss the history and culture of Latinos
in the United States. Aware that communities from Maine to Hawaii are now home to tens of thousands of residents who
trace their family histories to Mexico, Puerto Rico, and other parts of Latin America, we attempted together to
historicize recent trends—the "Latinization" of the United States—and to find ways to integrate Latinos
more fully in school curricula.
Fellows first read, and seemed to enjoy, Juan González's Harvest of Empire, a book of popular history
that describes how Latin Americans have been incorporated, by migration and other processes, into the United States.
That reading prompted many good seminar discussions about the 19th and 20th century past, about the influence of the
U.S. in the Western hemisphere, and about the possible connections between histories of migrant Puerto Ricans and
Mexicans. From that point forward, we took on questions about citizenship, about race and racism, and about
community politics, beginning a set of conversations that defined our seminar meetings face-to-face, and that guided
a number of Fellows' units in subsequent weeks.
Along the way we also had a number of stimulating discussions of broad interest to seminar participants. We
considered the past and present struggles of Latino kids in U.S. schools, as well as teachers and administrators, in
the writing of Ernesto Galarza, historian Virginia Sánchez-Korrol, and social scientists such as Stephanie
Bohon. We talked about the differences between the Latino neighborhoods, workplaces, and leisure practices in
established communities such as Philadelphia and Santa Fe, and those which newly-arrived populations have created in
Richmond and Charlotte. We studied educational trends in Latino communities nationwide, exploring rates of literacy,
high school graduation, and college matriculation. We considered works of fiction and memoirs by Latino authors,
including Sandra Cisneros's House on Mango Street—which a number of the participants had already used
in their own teaching, although in many different ways—and Junot Díaz's Drown, an account of
life in both the Dominican Republic and the New York City area. We tackled short stories, paying particular
attention to the ways in which authors narrate their arrivals in the United States, and how they explain cultural
change and continuity among Spanish-speakers. We watched several films and music videos, listened to corridos and
salsa tracks, read a history of Latin music in the United States, and analyzed a late-19th century cookbook written
by a Mexican American woman in California. Fellows analyzed the art of the Chicano movement, and they talked about
the ways in which recent Guatemalan migrants to the South connect Central American indigenous histories to the
contemporary United States. In our final session we considered the contemporary immigration debate, and how
proposals aimed at border enforcement, new guest worker systems, or an easier path to naturalization might soon
reshape the 21st-century United States.
These interesting and wide-ranging discussions helped guide Fellows as they wrote fascinating units intended for a
wide range of students. Samuel Reed put together an exciting approach to introducing his mostly African American
middle school students to Philadelphia's Latino communities, and to salsa and other Caribbean musical traditions,
through various writing and performance projects, and a pen pal program with a school that boasts a large Latino
population. Sara Thomas created a unit that guides high school art students in New Haven to consider how Latino
artists, and others, have adapted the historical figure of La Malinche, and the Vírgen de Guadalupe, and that
then encourages them to make their own adaptation of a familiar image or icon. Nicole Schubert responded to the
growing number of Latin American immigrants in her North Carolina community to design a middle school unit about
Mexican immigration that focuses on immigrants' personal narratives. Raymond Theilacker developed a unit meant to
guide his eleventh and twelfth grade Delaware students through several genres of Latino literature, to teach
something about Puerto Rican and Mexican American history, and to prompt discussions about literary analysis and
identity formation. Yvette Carter of Richmond designed an approach to the popular children's song "Bate, Bate,
Chocolate" which she hopes will inspire her primary school music classes to sing, learn about rhythm, and write
short essays. Paulina Salvador developed a unit for her bilingual education classroom that will guide her Latino
fifth grade students in Santa Fe towards new types of readings, and that will help them better understand their own
families and communities. Finally, Kathy Zimbaldi of Houston assembled a unit about Cuba, Puerto Rico, and the
Dominican Republic for English-language learners in her Houston primary school, a unit that relies upon
recently-published picture books to encourage a love of reading, to improve general literacy, and to provide
Mexican-origin children some basic information about the Caribbean.
Taken together, these units offer a number of exciting ways to bring Latino content into classrooms throughout the
United States.
Stephen J. Pitti
Synopsis of the Curriculum Units
07.04.01 - Boricua, Morena: Latin-Caribbean American and African American Cultural Connections En ciudad de Filadelfia
by Samuel A. Reed
This unit draws upon social studies, performing arts and literature to show the interconnections between Latino and
African-American cultures. It is intended for middle grade students (grades 6th-8th) at a predominately African
American school. The unit involves an inquiry process where students learn about Latino culture while also learning
about their selves. The films Mad Hot Ballroom and West Side Story will serve as anchors for exploring
how Latin-Caribbean culture interrelates with African American culture. Students will conduct their own inquiry,
using the essential question "what cultural connections do Puerto Ricans and Dominicans share with African
Americans?" Concurrently, students will explore and analyze popular Latin Caribbean dance movements, music,
bilingual poetry, historical and current events to uncover the connections Puerto Ricans, Dominicans and African
Americans share. To enhance the inquiry process, students will participate in a pen-pal exchange with sixth and
seventh grade students at the Hon. Luís Muñoz Marín School, a predominately Latino school
located in the Central East Region of the School District of Philadelphia. To culminate this unit, students will
present multi-media renditions of what they learned about the connections between Latin-Caribbean and African
American cultures.
(Recommended for Social Studies and Literacy, grades 6-8.)
07.04.02 - Examining Mexican Immigration Thru First Person Point-of-view
by Nicole Marie Schubert
This unit examines the struggles Mexican immigrants have faced in the U.S., comparing the conflicts faced by
migrant laborers in the early 20th century to those plaguing present-day Mexican immigrants. I am an 8th grade
language arts teacher and will be using non-fiction texts as well other first-person perspective texts to teach this
concept. Since Charlotte, North Carolina has seen an enormous increase in the number or Latino, specifically
Mexican, immigrants during the past fifteen years it is important for my students to learn about the new face of
Charlotte. Instead of teaching the strategies for reading non-fiction by using many unrelated topics, I decided to
use news articles, editorials, political cartoons, first-person narratives, corridos, a film, short stories
and a novel that address the issues surrounding Mexican immigration to the U.S. In order to teach the components of
a news article, editorial and feature story I have selected six texts the students will read in order to identify
the features of each as well as compare and contrast the information about important issues like border control, the
700 mile fence, family conflicts involved with immigrating, legal versus illegal immigration, and many other issues
surrounding this controversial and significant topic.
(Developed for Language Arts, grade 8; recommended for Language Arts, grades 7-8, and English, grades 9-10)
07.04.03 - Context Clues: The Appropriation of Malinche and the Virgin of Guadalupe
by Sara E. McGrimley
As an urban teacher I have had to find ways incorporate reading and writing across the disciplines within my art
curriculum. I have decided to do this through art analysis, followed later by art creation. Students will be looking
at icons, analyzing them, placing them in context, determining how context changes the analysis, and then creating
their own icon within a specific context. First I will show students a set of images of the Virgin of Guadalupe
focusing on analysis, supporting their interpretation with information from the artwork. The second set of images we
view will be of Malinche and we will focus on the importance of understanding context. I will use these two
different Mexican icons whom artists have represented in a variety of different ways, to teach students these
skills. As a culminating activity I would like students to choose an icon that is interesting to them, and then
choose a context in which they would like to appropriate that icon. They will need to determine how they would like
the viewer to see that icon differently, and what symbols they are going to use to express that idea, using the
examples we have viewed as an inspiration for process.
(Developed for AP Art, grades 11-12, and Introduction to Art, grades 9-10; recommended for AP Art, grades 11-12,
and Introduction to Art, grades 9-10)
07.04.04 - I Know You Are, but What Am I? A Latino Literature Unit
by Raymond F. Theilacker
This curriculum unit immerses students in several genres of Latino literature with the dual purposes of exposing
eleventh or twelfth grade students to a selection of Latino literature, and of raising multicultural awareness and
appreciation. The goal is to feature Latino issues in the literature so that Latino students enjoy familiar models,
while non-Latino students gain cultural knowledge and appreciation. Students work in groups with self-described
immigrant characteristics which they have detailed in an identity profile; then they respond to the reading and film
assignments according to these profiles. There is accompanying study of literary devices, while students learn to
create identity profiles based on their invented immigration status, in a sustained role-playing activity.
Implementation of the unit spans a 5 to 7 day period in a block schedule, but is fully adaptable to a school year
structured in two semesters, spanning a 2 to 3 week period, on a standard forty-minute class schedule. The lessons
are designed for collaborative teamwork, and for direct instruction toward literary analysis and personal expressive
writing. By the conclusion of the unit, students have information from the reading, and from periodic journaling
activities that enable them to respond to a personal essay prompt. The personal essay serves as the summative
assessment in this unit.
(Developed for English, grade 12; recommended for English, grades 11-12)
07.04.05 - Latino Children's Folk Music: A Series of Thematic Writing Exercises
by Yvette Moorehead Carter
As a music educator for pre-Kindergarten through fifth grade, I value the study of music and the opportunities it
provides for subject integration. I teach music in a way that embodies the beginning studies of the elements of
music and includes interdisciplinary experiences with mathematics, history, science, reading, visual arts, and
writing. Consciously or unconsciously, music is usually taught in a way that includes reading song lyrics, using
mathematical skills in assigning and counting note values, and exploring the science of vocal and instrumental
sounds through the study of vibrations. As a result, students are able to experience music in a variety of ways. My
goal is to teach a unit that will use "chocolate" as a motivational theme for writing, a task that is not often
favorably approached by elementary students. My theme is inspired by the Latino folk song, "Bate, Bate Chocolate."
This song serves as the core of my unit.
Music is a language with universal appeal. It can be written down or passed from one person to another. As songs
and chants move orally from one generation to another, they often carry with them cultural traditions and customs.
"Bate, Bate Chocolate" embodies a rich cultural history that includes both the historical significance of the Aztec
Empire and the history of chocolate. These nuances allow for the integration of both history and writing with music.
I have attempted to address not only the needs of music teachers, but also the needs of second through fifth grade
classroom teachers by designing this unit in a way that can be adapted to explore exciting, age-appropriate themes
for writing within any subject area. Teachers can select themes from sources within their areas of expertise and
create the desire for writing that students seek.
(Developed for General Music and Music, grade 5; recommended for General Music, Music, English, and Writing, grade
5)
07.04.06 - La voz y la vida: Literacy and Identity in Young Latino Immigrant Students
by Paulina Alexandra Salvador
Recent immigration from Mexico and Central America has profoundly changed the cultural landscape of the United
States. My fifth grade bilingual classroom is a microcosm of the Latino immigrant community residing in Santa Fe,
New Mexico. My students represent the social, political, economic and educational needs of this burgeoning Latino
immigrant community which is largely concentrated in one area of the city. This nine-week curricular unit explores
best practices for literacy development, incorporating progressive teaching strategies for English language
learners. It also aims to create a learning environment that is challenging and culturally inclusive. Throughout the
teaching-learning process students will have several opportunities to interact with literature and reflect on their
ethnic and bicultural identities. Memoirs, narratives, poetry, and oral histories of immigrant Latinos are
incorporated to reveal the parallels that the students may find with their own experiences. Students will also
consider the history of immigration, in general, and of Latinos in the United States. As culminating writing
activities, students will write an oral history of a recent immigrant whom they know well. Using the oral history as
a primary source, they will create an illustrated third person memoir picture book.
(Developed for Elementary Bilingual Education, grade 5; recommended for Elementary and Middle School grades 5-8)
07.04.07 - Cuรฉntame Una Historia, Por Favor! (Tell Me A Story, Please!)
by Kathy Howell Zimbaldi
This unit is written with the transitional ESL student in mind. While the target group is at 4th grade level, it is
flexible enough to be used with various ages of ELL's who are transitioning to total English instruction .Its goal
is broad and inclusive; each activity is designed to promote English language skills in the four language arts
strands of reading, writing, listening and speaking. In this unit, I chose to introduce my students to the 3
Caribbean islands of Cuba, The Dominican Republic, and Puerto Rico through the reading of the folktales common to
each island. While my primary goal was language acquisition, my secondary goal was cultural. My students, all of
Mexican extraction, lack information about Hispanic people with whom they share a mother tongue. Because these
islands together account for the largest number after Mexico) of migrants in the U.S., I hope to broaden their
perspectives about the Hispanic /American immigrant experience and increase their understanding of the Latino
presence in the U.S.
(Developed for ESL Transitional, grade 4; recommended for ESL Transitional, grades 4-6)
Introduction by
Gary W. Brudvig, Professor of Chemistry and of Molecular Biophysics and Biochemistry
With concerns about the impact on the environment of our current use of fossil fuels and our national energy
security, renewable energy is in the news on a daily basis. Many students have seen Al Gore's movie "An Inconvenient
Truth" and are familiar with some of the issues relating to energy use, but they may not know much about the science
related to renewable energy. The aim for this seminar was to discuss the science related to current sources of
energy and potential future sources of energy, with a focus on renewable energy. We can learn much about sustainable
energy use by studying natural processes. Nature has solved the renewable energy problem through the process of
photosynthesis that is carried out by green plants. Plants are amazing chemical factories and provide a working
example of renewable solar energy conversion, but this is often not appreciated. By understanding how plants carry
out the processes of solar energy utilization, we can obtain some answers to the question of how we can harvest
solar energy by using processes of artificial photosynthesis.
My own interest in science stems from my hands-on experiences as a child. Therefore, many demonstrations were
included in this seminar — at least one demonstration, and frequently 2-3, in each seminar meeting. These
demonstrations were chosen so that they could actively involve the students and at the same time illustrate the
scientific principles related to renewable energy.
The book by David Walker entitled "Energy, Plants and Man" was used as the primary text for the seminar. A special
issue of Scientific American on "Energy's Future Beyond Carbon" (September 2006) served as a supplementary
"text". The first week of the seminar focused on photosynthesis. The seminar began with a discussion of how plants
use light to convert carbon dioxide and water into sugar and oxygen gas. This was followed by discussions on the
nature of light and the fundamental steps by which light is absorbed by plants and converted into chemical energy.
Demonstrations of the colors in light using diffractions glasses and a spectrophotometer aided these discussions.
Plant pigments were discussed next, together with demonstrations on light absorption/emission by pigments extracted
from plants and algae, and on pigment separation by using paper chromatography. The process of carbon fixation was
discussed and was "photographically" illustrated by making starch pictures on geranium leaves (although this
demonstration was not as successful as I had hoped). In the second week of the seminar, we delved into various forms
of energy, including wind, geothermal, solar, and nuclear. A highlight of the week was the production of biodiesel
fuel from cooking oil that culminated in the combustion of biodiesel fuel in an oil furnace burner. The seminar
ended with a discussion of energy use in the future that included progress in development of systems for artificial
photosynthesis and fuel cells.
The curriculum units developed from this seminar are suitable for elementary to middle school to high school
students. In all of the units, the science content is integrated with language arts, mathematics and social studies
to provide a balanced program that meets the literacy requirements of the school system. The Fellows have prepared
extensive lists of materials that can be used in the classroom or as resources. These materials include books that
the children can read, textbooks that the teachers can use, demonstration sourcebooks, suppliers of equipment,
useful computer software, and addresses of sites on the world wide web. Several of the Fellows developed units
around a theme or activity related to photosynthesis, including a remarkable 3D model-based unit on the fundamental
processes of photosynthesis. Other units are related to sources of renewable energy for the future, such as wind and
solar energy, as well as the impact of our energy use on the planet Earth. The units include a number of excellent
activities that will engage the students' interest and teach them about renewable energy.
I would encourage all teachers of elementary through high school students to review these curriculum units. These
materials provide a valuable resource for incorporating topics of science and society related to "Renewable Energy"
into the classroom.
Gary Brudvig
Synopsis of the Curriculum Units
07.05.01 - Petroleum: Our Best Transportation Option?
by Justin T. Benz
This is a unit designed for a high school environmental technology program. This unit explores the carbon cycle
almost in a "cradle to grave" sense, starting with plants fixing carbon using solar radiation during the process of
photosynthesis, tracking inputs from anthropogenic sources (most notably transportation), exploring the global
fluxes of carbon and cycling into the carbon sinks and quantifying how carbon is sequestered by our oceans and our
terrestrial systems. Students research alternatives to current transportation fuels to determine the best options
for transportation in order to lower the carbon output of our transportation sector. Students gain field experience
when they run biometry measurements on local woodland and then calculate the amount of carbon the woodland can
sequester. Students use molecular models to understand hydrocarbons and the chemistry of the products made out of
them as well as the process of combustion. Using the new knowledge gained from the unit, the students gain an
appreciation for conserving our petroleum resource as feed stock for products instead of burning it all as a fuel.
(Developed for Environmental Landscape Technology, grade 10; recommended for Environmental Science, Agriscience,
and Natural Resources, grades 9-12)
07.05.02 - Solar energy: Using Carbon Dioxide from the Atmosphere to Produce a Viable Fuel Source
by Emily Betts
In the time of dire predictions about climate change, there are questions we must ask about renewable technologies.
Which technology can shift our carbon-based economy to one that reduces carbon dioxide in the environment? How will
we meet energy demands, and do we actually have the technology to do so? Teaching students about renewable energy is
crucial to help them understand the potential and reality of these energies in their lives.
Solar energy may hold the greatest potential for replacing fossil fuels as our primary energy source, since enough
energy from the sun strikes the Earth in one hour to supply all the energy consumed by humans in one year. My
curriculum unit focuses on the biological sources of solar energy including biomass, which incorporates solar energy
through photosynthesis and is then burned or converted into fuel. While biomass is a renewable technology, use of
biomass is not always a benefit to the environment. Combustion of biomass does release carbon dioxide, and the
growing and transport of biomass is also a emissions concern.
Students need to have knowledge and experience with the new renewable technologies so that they will be more likely
to incorporate viable technologies into their lives.
(Developed for Biology, grades 9-10, and Environmental Science, grades 9-12; recommended for Life Science and
Environmental Science, grades 6-8, and Earth Science and Biology, grades 9-12)
07.05.03 - Environmentalists and Chemists Unite: A Chemistry Class for our Changing World
by Cherisse Campbell
When taken out of context, the standard high school chemistry curriculum can be seen as an obscure chain of
unrelated factoids. This curriculum unit will address several standards-based curriculum components by situating
them within the context of a topic that has been receiving significant attention in the popular media, the need for
alternative energy sources. The unit has four parts, each offering a method of addressing traditional chemistry
content through engaging connections and activities. Although the theme of the unit is centered on alternative
energy sources, it is intended to address content required in the chemistry curriculum, including atomic inventory,
classification of matter, balancing equations, naming covalent compounds, moles, stoichiometry and heat capacity.
This will be accomplished through the use of literature and lab experiments such as the synthesis of biodiesel. The
lessons presented in this unit are not intended to serve as the sole reinforcement for the chemistry content
covered, but to serve as a unifying theme throughout a course that is commonly characterized by content that appears
unrelated and irrelevant to students.
(Developed for Chemistry, grade 11; recommended for Chemistry, High School grades)
07.05.04 - Catch the Wind
by Jeffrey C. Davis
This curriculum unit teaches students about their responsibility and potential as stewards of the Earth via a study
of renewable energy with an emphasis on wind power.
The unit is written for a fifth/sixth grade class and can be modified to use in younger or older students. Though
addressing local issues in New Mexico, environmental concerns in any region can be addressed though the methods in
this unit.
The unit is conceived as a longitudinal project with most of it being completed in one quarter and some parts
extending throughout the year. There are three major sections that overlap during the unit. Students will learn
about energy, global warming, and renewable energy (emphasis on wind power), culminating in the construction of a
wind turbine model. Student learning about energy issues and debate will underpin the second major
part—presenting a case to waive county height restrictions for the construction wind turbine on the school
campus. The third part of the unit concerns the weather and will continue throughout the year. Students will learn
the fundamentals of weather and weather forecasting (e.g., patterns, fronts). Students will track and report the
weather to the school each morning.
(Developed for Science and Social Studies, grade 5; recommended for Science, grades 5-7)
07.05.05 - Stylin' Your Ride: A Student's Guide to Designing Green Vehicles
by Jennifer B. Esty
This unit is designed to introduce students to various sources of energy for vehicles. It will explore the
technology currently available for vehicular transportation and the technologies that are being developed for future
use in vehicles.
The unit is written for a ninth grade integrated science (sometimes called Phy/Chem) class. In our school system,
that means that we cover primarily physical sciences in this class. This unit is intended to address three of the
science standards we are supposed to cover: the use of fossil fuels and other technologies in the generation of
electricity, the chemistry of hydrocarbon combustion, and the environmental impact of human transportation choices.
This unit is broken into three major sections. In the first section, past and current, commonly available
transportation technology options are discussed. The second section looks to the future where transportation
technologies that are being developed and perfected today are discussed. The final section of this unit is the
project that the students will produce based on the information presented in the first two sections of this unit.
(Developed for General Science, grade 9; recommended for General Science, grade 9, and Environmental Science, High
School grades)
07.05.06 - The Power of the Sun
by K. Gothie
The curriculum unit, "The Power of the Sun" is designed to be taught to sixth grade students during their science
period. The focus of the unit is on solar energy and covers elements of Earth and Space Science, Life science, and
Physical science. This unit is designed to provide students will a broad understanding of global warming and the
need for alternative and renewable energy production. A majority of the activities in this unit are investigative
and hands-on. The primary focus of the investigations will be for the students to understand processes of scientific
investigations and use inquiry and scientific methods to develop questions, design and conduct experiments using
appropriate technologies. The culminating activity will be the design and construction of a model solar car.
(Developed for Science, grade 6; recommended for Science, grades 5-7)
07.05.07 - Solar Energy -- Architectural Alternatives for Home Building
by Georgia Redonet
"The will to act—that's a renewable resource—let's do it."
Al Gore, February 25, 2007
Former vice president, Al Gore, made the above statement when accepting an Academy Award for his documentary An
Inconvenient Truth. It is a point well taken. Humans posses the energy and ability to affect change and that
energy is a limitless renewable resource. Whether our ideas are big or small, they can all add up to a change in how
we live that can improve the world in which we live. The issue of global warming bypasses any questions as to how
much petroleum energy is left for the world to use. CO2 emissions must be reduced and every individual can play a
role in that reduction. This curriculum unit will focus on architectural alternatives in home construction using
solar energy. Our studies will culminate with a look at Earthships. These homes present what appears to be the most
all-inclusive use of alternative applications using solar energy. The main purpose of this unit is to use
architecture to introduce my students to the topic of renewable and alternative energy, which is quickly becoming a
part of our mainstream dialogue.
(Developed for Texas History, grade 7; recommended for Science and History, grades K-12, and Architecture,
Construction, and Engineering, High School Grades)
07.05.08 - Modeling Photosynthesis
by Connie Scercy Wood
The main goal of this unit is to create a way to teach a rather complex process—photosynthesis—using a
three-dimensional approach that provides students with a concrete way of understanding this very difficult topic.
This unit was designed with upper level Biology classes, like Advanced Placement and International Baccalaureate, in
mind. Even these students have difficulty understanding things that happen at the molecular level. Included in this
unit is a summary of the most current information we have about photosynthesis. Using this information, I have put
together instructions for building and using a model of a chloroplast, to teach, and to help students make
connections between the molecular process and what they are observing in the lab. There are also activities that
help students enter into the molecular realm of photosynthesis through role-playing. Once they can visualize the
invisible, students will have a better basis for the formation of hypotheses and conclusions in inquiry labs. Based
on the model and role-playing, students could then develop their own simple models for demonstrating the variations
in photosynthesis by C4 and CAM plants.
(Developed for IB Biology, grade 11; recommended for AP Biology and IB Biology, grades 11-12)
Introduction by
Roger E. Howe, William R. Kenan, Jr. Professor Emeritus of Mathematics
Symbolic notation is an important source of power for mathematics. This specialized writing system compresses large
amounts of information into compact, easily manipulated form. For the knowledgeable user, this notation is a
versatile problem solving tool. However, from the educational point of view, this power does not come for free:
teachers must work hard to help students keep the symbolism invested with meaning. If a student cannot interpret and
work with the symbols in meaningful ways, his only option is to try to manipulate them according to formal rules.
Frequently the rules become too complex to cope with, and the student completely loses touch with mathematics.
Word problems can help students stay in touch. Dealing with a word problem requires translating its verbal
statements into symbolic ones, manipulating the symbols to solve equations, then translating back to answer the
question posed in the problem. This process requires students to assign meaning to symbols, thereby keeping students
tied to mathematics. Thus, word problems should not be thought of as a separate topic in the curriculum. They have a
central role to play in mathematics education.
From this point of view, the avoidance of word problems so common in our math instruction is a prime symptom of the
deficits of mathematics education in the U.S.
The seminar on The Art and Craft of Word Problems was devoted to remedying this deficit, at least in the
classrooms of the seminar Fellows. Each fellow has written a curriculum unit centered around word problems. Word
problems are not simply a prominent feature in these units, they are dealt with in a systematic way intended to give
students an overall understanding of how to approach word problems in the relevant subject area. More broadly, the
goal is to instill a habit of careful reading and interpretation.
George Polya, in his often cited writings on problem solving, listed four key steps for dealing with any problem:
- Understand the problem.
- Make a plan.
- Carry out the plan.
- Look back.
Of these steps, the first is by far the most important. Students who learn to read mathematics words problems and
interpret them carefully develop skills that will help them in all mathematics courses, and far beyond mathematics.
The most frequently proffered advice for understanding word problems is to learn the vocabulary. Each mathematical
operation has a variety of words or phrases which invoke it; addition is suggested by "in all", "all together',
"sum", "more than", "added to'" and so forth. The sound advice to know the words involved in problem statements is
unfortunately frequently taken to extremes, resulting in the "key word" approach: decide what operation to perform
by identifying a word associated to one of the operations. However, this approach has serious shortcomings. It is
easy to write word problems with a phrase such as "more than," or "the sum of", but which require subtraction for
their solution. There is no substitute for careful reading and understanding. Particularly with multistep problems,
ability to read and understand and translate into mathematics is essential, since the proliferation of possible
problem types easily outstrips efforts at classification. Unfortunately, the national aversion to word problems
severely curtails the extent and variety of multistep problems our students see, thereby limiting their experience
and ability in applying mathematics.
The units prepared for this seminar promote understanding word problems, not only one by one, but through
comparison. Because they will see and compare a variety of word problems, students will get a feel for the kinds of
issues that can arise, and for some possible responses. The phrase used in the seminar for this comparative study
was "exploring the problem territory". As students work on the problems assembled for these units, they should also
gain some familiarity with the problem territory, and, hopefully, will feel somewhat more at home in it.
The grade levels taught by seminar fellows ranged from primary to high school. Accordingly, their seminar units
cover a range of topics. At the primary level, the units by Tanya Shannon, Huwerl Thornton and Nancy Wasser deal
with addition and subtraction. All these units ensure variety in their problems by drawing on the taxonomy developed
by T. Carpenter et al, in the book {\it Children's Mathematics} This book makes the point that, although addition
problems tend to be relatively easy for children to conceptualize, the operation of subtraction has many faces, some
of which are much harder for children to deal with than others. The standard "take away" scenario is the simplest to
deal with. If students are presented only with take away problems, they will not develop a robust concept of how
subtraction gets used. These units will ensure a wider experience with the subtraction operation.
In addition to their common reliance on the Carpenter et al. taxonomy, the units have further individual foci.
Tanya Shannon has varied the complexity of the numbers in her problems, and sometimes expresses them in numerals,
and sometimes with words. Huwerl Thornton has adapted strategies originally devised to teach reading for use with
his word problems. Nancy Wasser has created a bilingual set of problems, and has incorporated problems to help
students grasp the structure of the decimal place value system for writing numbers.
At a slightly higher grade level, Valerie Schwartz has developed a suite of problems designed to take students from
single step problems to multistep problems incorporating both addition/subtraction and multiplication/division. Her
unit also undertakes to teach the use of Singapore bar models. This highly effective method for representing
problems graphically enables elementary students to solve many problems that in the U.S. are considered part of
algebra.
Karlene McGowen takes a language arts perspective in her unit. She seeks to approach mathematics word problems in a
multidisciplinary way, by using story books and a "problem of the week" theme to get students to analyze the
language in word problems in greater depth than standard instruction affords.
Moving beyond elementary school, Jill Smith's unit treats the issue of proportion in several important settings,
including the analysis of unit rates, the geometric topic of scaling, and the use of percents. Moses Jackson focuses
on percents, and investigates a range of problems using the "three piece percent formula". He shows how to apply
this formula in a wide variety of settings. Angel Johnson has created a unit to introduce her students to algebraic
notation. She develops parallel lessons, first treating numerical expressions of several levels of complexity, and
then progressing through the same stages with symbolic expressions. Part of the work of this unit is for students to
translate words into expressions and expressions into words - to be able to read expressions. This makes explicit
the task that is implicit in standard word problems, and provides extra practice with this important skill.
The topic featured in the units of Patricia Marasco, Paula Shaffer-Roche and Tyler Willoughby is linear equations,
in one or two variables. Each of these units deals with several types of problems and works to help students see the
similarities and differences between the types. The problems vary in complexity, from problems that could be dealt
with readily by standard arithmetic methods to problems that require the full apparatus of elimination. Paula
Shaffer-Roche has paid particular attention to this progression of complexity. She discusses a technique, known as
false position, that enables students to approach many varieties of problems, including mixture problems,
interest rate problems and combined sales problems, using arithmetic reasoning. Each writer has an individual
approach to the subject. This gives the reader a three-fold opportunity to enrich his/her own ideas about motivating
this topic and the possibility of further enrichment through comparing the units.
The most advanced topic treated in these units is quadratic equations, the theme of Nancy Rudolph's contribution.
She has assembled a substantial collection of problems based on quadratic equations. They deal with projectile
motion and several aspects of geometry. She includes problems to advance her laudable "personal mission" of having
students understand the important topic of the behavior of area under scaling. Her problems deal both with direct
issues - evaluating, finding roots and finding extrema of various quadratic functions - and with inverse issues -
finding a quadratic function satisfying specified conditions. The variety of the problems she presents should help
her readers explore the problem territory of this key topic in algebra.
Roger Howe
Synopsis of the Curriculum Units
07.06.01 - Teaching Addition and Subtraction Word Problems to Children
by Tanya Shannon
Many students have difficulties when attempting to solve word problems. Many reasons are given for the students'
lack of success in word problems. These reasons include students' lack of exposure to life outside of television and
their neighborhoods, minimal reading skills, and difficulty in comprehension skills. I do not dispute these reasons
for students' failure, but I propose that there is a way to ensure that problem solving permeates the mathematics
classroom while simultaneously maintaining student interest. This unit will help teachers that are looking to
implement strategies that will change the way that students read and understand addition and subtraction word
problems. Additionally, it will help teachers to learn the various methods that they can use in order to develop
meaningful word problems for all of their students. Although it was written for second grade, these strategies and
accompanying appendix of word problems are adaptable for grades one through four.
(Developed for Mathematics, grade 2; recommended for Mathematics, grade 2)
07.06.02 - Crafting Word Problems Even a Child Can Do
by Huwerl Thornton
This unit covers the structure of addition and subtraction math word problems. It analyzes the different ways that
addition and subtraction word problems can be created. The unit looks at how word problems strike fear in the hearts
of many people and how teachers can help their students to develop ways to attack word problems. This in turn will
hopefully help students develop a love for word problems. More importantly, the unit helps teachers realize that the
creation of word problems is something that should be done with great care and should be created with a specific
objective to be taught.
The second part of the unit looks at how to use reading strategies to help students solve word problems. It
explores the use of making connections, asking questions, visualization, determining importance, inferring and
predicting, and synthesizing. The unit focuses on a modified KWL chart called KWC. The KWC and using reading
strategies to help solve word problems comes from Arthur Hyde's book Comprehending Math: Adapting Reading Strategies
to Teach Mathematics, K-6. The lessons in the unit are about teaching the KWC to the class to use as a strategy and
tool to solve word problems.
07.06.03 - A = C - B: Subtraction is the Cousin of Addition
by Nancy Ann Wasser
This unit explores the process of subtraction through the study of word problems. It begins by providing a
presentation of the decimal number system and base-ten operations as a scaffolding to support cognitive
understanding of subtraction as the inverse process of addition. It teaches composing and decomposing
of tens as opposed to the more traditional method of carrying and borrowing. It presents lessons treating various
subtraction situations including: take-away, difference, and comparison and part-whole relations, especially missing
addend problems. Students learn to identify key elements of problems, formulate conjectures and work in groups to
problem solve. Lessons teach students to identify the unknown in a word problem. They also teach subtracting across
zeroes and present mental math techniques.
The unit is written for a fourth grade bilingual English/Spanish class, therefore the word problems are in one or
the other language; however, it could easily be adapted for a monolingual English fourth grade class. Taxonomies are
included which provide useful nomenclature and methodologies for problem solving. An appendix of word problems, in
English and Spanish, is provided as well, along with an annotated bibliography.
(Developed for Mathematics, grades 4-5; recommended for Mathematics, grades 3-5)
07.06.04 - Word Problems in Picture Books: Literature as a Source of Math Word Problems
by Karlene E. McGowen
This curriculum unit will look at math word problems from a language arts point of view. Many times students are
able to do the math computation but get stumped by the wording in the problem. This unit can show them how to read
the problem the same way they might read a novel or a non-fiction passage, they will then have greater success at
solving the word problem correctly.
The unit is divided into two sections; however these two sections are designed to be used together. The first
section involves the use of math picture books. Look at these picture story books as one giant word problem. By
beginning with these books we can show the students that a word problem is simply a story that involves math. The
second section of the unit involves the collaboration of efforts between the Language Arts teachers and the Math
teachers. Call it Word Problem(s) of the Week. The students will receive a word problem on Monday or day one. The
students take the problem to the Reading teacher, English teacher and then Math teacher over the course of a couple
of days. Each teacher helps the students with a different aspect of reading and solving the problem. In merging
these two sections, it would be ideal to use the word problems created specifically for the picture books as
problems of the week. Although the unit utilizes picture books, the word problems are leveled for middle school
students.
(Developed for Reading, grade 8; recommended for Mathematics, Reading, and English, grades 6-8)
07.06.05 - Dr. Word Problem - Solving Word Problems with the Four Operations Using Singapore Bar Models
by Valerie J. Schwarz
Dr. Word Problem is a unit designed to examine the structure of word problems involving the four operations of
arithmetic. This unit focuses on teaching a strategy that is a visual approach to solving word problems. The
students will be exposed to Singapore bar models as a technique to aid in understanding and solving problems.
Students are taught how to represent word problems by drawing a Singapore bar model. The unit explores the bar
models beginning with basic addition facts. The unit progresses to subtraction, multiplication, division, and
multi-step problems. A key aspect of this unit is connecting the four operations. By developing children's
understanding of the relationships that the four operations share, children will also build a stronger foundation
that will invaluable, especially as the multi-step problem domain is investigated. The unit also addresses common
pitfalls and limited strategies to problem solving. Dr. Word Problem aspires to overcome these pitfalls by
developing arithmetical understanding. This unit can also be adapted to work with word problems dealing with
fractions and decimals. The models can also be used to solve algebra problems without using algebra.
(Developed for Mathematics, grade 4; recommended for Mathematics, grades 3-5)
07.06.06 - Percents in Real Life Situations
by Moses B. Jackson
This unit, Percent in Real Life Situations, uses the concepts of percents to teach 9th grade students of the School
District of Philadelphia how to solve word problems. It presents a template that can be used to translate percent
word problems, in all forms, into mathematical sentences.
The unit is intended to be taught in four weeks with a focus on how to help students analyze open ended questions
and Critical Response Problems (CRP) that are usually a component of regular Standardized State Tests. The template
deals with a manipulation of the statement, "percent times whole equals part". Hopefully, math teachers will find
this unit helpful as an added resource for their classrooms and lesson plans.
(Developed for Mathematics, grade 9; recommended for Mathematics and World Problems, grades 9-10)
07.06.07 - Linear Expressions and Evaluations
by Angel Johnson
As we continue to use mathematics as a tool to model physical or real world phenomena, more complex situations will
be represented by word problems. As a global society, educators and students must become extremely comfortable in
incorporating, using, and solving word problems. This three-week unit is designed to introduce Algebra 9th grade
students to the language of mathematics and show them how to model situations symbolically—known as concise
representation. The unit develops algebraic concepts through the use of everyday arithmetic situations. Students
learn that, through the rules of addition, subtraction, multiplication and division, and procedures for finding the
unknown values, they can systematically translate concrete situations into algebraic expressions and manipulate and
evaluate those expressions to arrive at a solution. Specifically, students learn what expressions say, and how to
translate back and forth between verbal formulations and symbolic ones. Students will develop notational
representation (numerical and algebraic), simplify expressions, and apply these skills for reinforcement. Students
will also have an opportunity to review, identify and apply the associative, commutative, distributive, and identity
properties. Some relevant vocabulary words are: additive identity, algebraic expression, associative property,
coefficient, commutative property, distributive property, factors, like terms, multiplicative identity, order of
operations, product, and variables.
(Developed for Algebra I, grade 9; recommended for Algebra I, grade 9)
07.06.08 - The Art of Solving Word Problems by Using Proportions
by Jill Elizabeth Smith
The Art of Solving Word Problems by Using Proportions focuses on the struggles that multi-level students face
preparing to correctly solve a word problem. In the North Carolina curriculum, a major objective in seventh grade
math is solving problems by using proportions. In this unit, my main focus is on word problems that involve unit
rates, percents and similar figures/models. Most students at varying levels struggle with setting up a proportion
when given a word problem. Students tend to have the knowledge to solve proportions by cross multiplying, but their
application is sometimes faulty. This unit assists this issue by breaking down the problems into different
difficulty levels and subject matter. Included in the unit, there are also lessons, activities and sample problems
that involve real life situations to help students further grasp the concept. It also emphasizes repetition of the
basics by completing several problems that contain the same scenario yet have a changing variable. The unit I have
written will give students a better understanding and higher confidence level of a major objective and help them to
be more successful.
(Developed for Mathematics, grade 7; recommended for Mathematics Proportions and Science Proportions, grade 7)
07.06.09 - Word Problems: Looking for the Similarities in Problems to Help Categorize and Solve Them
by Patricia Lee Marasco
This unit is written for freshman, ages 13/14. The purpose of this unit is to supply students with the basic tools
and ideas they will need to begin their study of linear equations. I will help students go from simple to more
complex problems by having them recognize the similarities and differences between problems. I believe that once a
student can recognize and categorize the given problems, they will then feel confident enough to attempt to solve
these and the more complex problems we will study later in the year. This is just another way of saying we are going
to categorize or group problems. It is important for students to recognize what red flags there are in each problem
that categorizes a problem as such, by identifying the subtle differences or similarities. I will also spend some
time going over the language of word problems. I believe that there is a tendency of teachers not to explain key
conventions and assumptions. I have found that going over the language is beneficial for two reasons. The first
reason is that it clarifies the meaning of the terms. The second reason is that it sends a message to the students
that it is OK to ask if they don't understand. How can they answer the question if they don't know what they are
being asked? This unit is designed to help my students recognize various problems and use several different tools to
derive an answer that makes sense. In addition, I hope to add some fun to their math experience.
(Developed for Algebra I, grade 9; recommended for Algebra I, grade 9)
07.06.10 - Assisting the Transition from English to Mathematical Language
by Paula West
This unit maintains a focus on various strategies and approaches to implementing word problems. For example, the
lessons utilize mental math and tables to help aid to the mathematical thinking involved in problem solving.
Furthermore, the lessons emphasize starting with simple mathematical language, then completing more complex
problems. The goal is to build a strong problem solving foundation. The lessons are built around the idea that math
is similar to learning a foreign language. Hence, students have to be prepared to handle mathematics with the idea
in mind that with more exposure the language becomes much easier to translate. The unit seeks to illustrate methods
that help address the difficulties that mathematical language presents to students. Classroom activities will
analyze meaning in word problems in order to arrive at the correct answer. My goal for this unit is to have students
be able to attack word problems without fear and frustration. I hope the strategies explored here inspire educators
to analyze word problems with their students more easily and effectively.
(Developed for Algebra I, grade 9; recommended for Algebra I, grade 9)
07.06.11 - Applying System of Equations to Real-World Scenarios: A Practical Curriculum
by Tyler B. Willoughby
Word problems are a problem. The objective for this curriculum unit is to show students the multiple ways that
system of equations can be used to solve real-world problems. In order for students to be engaged and interested in
learning, they need to see the real-world practicality behind the math concept being learned. Without a lot of
practice, System of Equations can be difficult for students to compute correctly and efficiently. Therefore, in
order to capture the attention and interest of our students, I will first identify a variety of system of equations
and then explain how to solve each using three different methods. Utilizing the substitution method,
addition/subtraction elimination and multiplication/elimination methods, we will review how to solve a system of
equations.
Then I will combine the distance (d = rt) and interest (I = prt) formulas together with a system of equations and
demonstrate how to solve real-world scenarios and exciting problems. I will also provide practical examples to
problems involving wind and water currents, chemistry problems involving mixtures and solutions, more interest
problems involving the time value of money, and other practical examples that involve systems of equations.
(Developed for Algebra, grade 8; recommended for Algebra, grades 8-10, and Algebra II, grades 10-12)
07.06.12 - Quadratic Equations in Word Problems Students Can Relate To
by Nancy Rudolph
This unit is based on a collection of quadratic word problems that are intended to be relevant to teenagers, and
are organized differently from traditional math textbooks. Progressing through the problems, students'
quadratic-solving skills should improve, and they should gain a better understanding of how each small change
affects the solution and/or the choice of solution method. The unit begins with projectile motion problems that
relate to sports since most teenagers can relate to them, and because the parabolic path of objects in flight, as a
function of time, is visually represented by the graph of the quadratic function. They move on to geometry problems
where they will gain much-needed practice in setting up and solving area and volume equations based on information
given in word problems. And finally, they study the effects of dilations (changes in scale factor) on area. While
the dilation problems are written specifically for vocational students, many of them address interests of typical
high school students. The unit assumes students are able to find x-intercepts and coordinates of the vertex of a
quadratic function by factoring, using the Quadratic Formula, or examining a graph or table on a graphing
calculator.
(Developed for Integrated Math III, grades 10-11; recommended for Algebra I and Algebra II, grades 9-12)
Introduction by
Sabatino Sofia, Professor of Astronomy
The title of this seminar was sufficiently broad to encompass topics ranging from Astronomy, to Astrophysics, Solar
System, Physics, Mathematics, History of Space Exploration, to Life in the Universe. The curriculum units developed
reflected such a variety of topics, as well as a variety of grade levels targeted.
The unifying thread of each curriculum unit was that Space played a role in the advances of the topics addressed.
For example, two of the units address the topic of the origin of the chemical elements following vastly different
teaching techniques. Although the primary relevant field is Nuclear Astrophysics, the space program was critical in
separating the role of primordial nucleosynthesis from that of stellar nucleosynthesis in building up the elements
found in the Universe. Similarly, many of the basic properties of the objects in the Solar System, addressed by
several curriculum units, were only established with the help of space probes. Also, the search for life outside
planet Earth, currently apparently dominated by radio astronomy, does in fact rely fundamentally on the space
program, both for the in-situ search for primitive living organisms within the Solar System, as well as for the
search of Earth-like planets around stars within our galactic neighborhood. Finally, many of the basic principles of
Mechanics can be illustrated by events and devices used in the space program, such as micro-gravity, the rocket
effect, etc.
To evaluate the objectives and topics of each curriculum unit and assess its relevance to your own teaching, it is
necessary to examine the synopsis of each unit individually. There you will find sufficient information to address
the level of the targeted students, as well as the key elements of local and/or national standards that the unit
addresses.
It has been a prevalent feeling of most Fellows of this seminar that astronomical and space topics are great
motivators for students who do not typically see the relevance of Physics, Mathematics, Chemistry or other sciences
to their own lives. In these units you see one or more of these sciences at work, demonstrating that they are not
merely abstract manipulations without a point. This compendium of units, as well as those corresponding to similar
seminars, should assist science teachers to convey to their students why the effort required to master these
subjects is a worthwhile undertaking.
Sabatino Sofia
Synopsis of the Curriculum Units
07.07.01 - The Origin of the Elements
by Stuart Surrey
In general, most high school chemistry courses around the country teach students about the elements from an
organizational point of view. That is, the elements are taught in conjunction with the development of the periodic
table. Students learn about the arrangement of the elements based on increasing atomic numbers, similar chemical and
physical properties, as well as trends within the periodic table. Whereas most high school chemistry textbooks
briefly mention the occurrence and/or abundance of specific elements on Earth or in the atmosphere, they rarely give
any insight into the actual origin of the elements. Therefore, the aim of this curriculum unit is to present the
students with a basic understanding of how and where the elements were formed prior to discussing the periodic
table. This will include current information on Big Bang or primordial, stellar, and supernova nucleosynthsis. In
doing so, the students will study the history of the Big Bang theory and stellar evolution as a means of
understanding the origin of the elements as well as stimulating interest in astronomy and cosmology.
(Developed for Chemistry, grade 11; recommended for Chemistry, grade 11)
07.07.02 - Beyond The Atom: Interpreting the Origin of the Elements
by Ram Bhagat
Beyond the Atom: Interpreting the Origin of the Elements is an imaginative approach to teach students about the
birth of matter. In technical terms, this approach combines the principles of Aesthetic Education, Science
Education, Emotional Intelligence and Multicultural Education. Put simply, this method integrates the Performing
Arts—specifically Drumming, Dance, and Drama—into the Chemistry curriculum. Beyond the Atom is an
interdisciplinary unit with an emphasis on Reading Across the Curriculum. Consequently, students will read Charles
A. Cerami's biography on Benjamin Banneker and interpret the impact of African Astronomy on contemporary American
society through dance. In addition, Beyond the Atom addresses the issue of "Science Literacy" in the United States.
My overall goal is to motivate urban minority youth, especially African American male adolescents (AAma), to develop
creative problem-solving skills and enhance their intellectual, social and emotional abilities. The federal
imperative to "Leave No Child Behind" combined with mandatory End-of-Course testing on the state level places AAma
at a tremendous risk for poor academic and social performance. This unit recommends an African-centered pedagogy to
address these disparities. Researchers have found that infusing Arts Education across the curriculum in an urban
setting enhances the learning experience of all students.
(Developed for Chemistry, Atomic Structure and Periodic Table, grades 10-12; recommended for Chemistry, Atomic
Structure and Periodic Table, grades 9-12)
07.07.03 - Are We Alone?
by Eric J. Laurenson
"Are we Alone in the Universe?" This question has been pondered for much of human history, but scientific,
technological advances in Astronomy have added a tremendous amount of data to the discussion. Ever since the famous
Drake equation was proposed in 1965, scientists have attempted to predict the likelihood of intelligent
extraterrestrial life. It is my goal in this unit to explore the current data that exists regarding the requirements
for life, the probability that such life could find a suitable existence elsewhere in the Universe and the physics
required to detect it.
The debate ranges from those that claim that intelligent life is very rare to those scientists who believe that
intelligent life is pervasive throughout the Universe. I will be considering the factors that are postulated to be
prerequisites for life, the history of life on our planet that has resulted in our own existence and the relative
significance of this fact, the scientific data that allows us to predict the probabilities of life elsewhere in the
Universe and the reliability of these claims. I will be considering all of these issues in light of the physics
involved in searching for extraterrestrial life. I intend to teach this unit in physics classes to explore
probabilities in scientific claims. Using all of this information it is my intention to present a scientific
discourse about the relative likelihood that intelligent life exists elsewhere in the Universe.
(Developed for AP Physics, grade 12, and Honors Physics and General Physics, grades 11-12; recommended for AP
Physics, grade 12, and Honors Physics and General Physics, grades 11-12)
07.07.04 - The Integration of Space Technology into the Physics Classroom
by Debra Blake Semmler
I have developed a curriculum unit that includes space science and technology as a unifying theme throughout the
study of introductory physics. The purpose of the unit is two fold. First, so often the study of physics appears to
be a series of mathematical manipulations with little connection to understanding how and why the Universe works,
which is the true study of science. I believe the integration of space science will ignite interest and allow
students to recognize that the study of physics is not just formula manipulations but has implications beyond
solving the daily homework problems. The second purpose is that the students we teach will be part of the
decision-making for the future, and need a basic understanding of physical principles of the Universe to make
informed decisions, not only about space travel, but about energy resources and the environment. I believe that
including the science of space in my curriculum will motivate and inspire students to have a richer understanding of
the concepts of physics. The unit includes problem sets, class discussions, presentations and demonstrations, and an
inquiry design cycle experiment on rocket science.
(Developed for Honors Physics I, grades 10-12; recommended for Physics, grades 10-12)
07.07.05 - Traveling the Solar System through Literature
by Lori Paderewski
Third and fourth grade teachers will love this unit on Space, covering in depth, the Sun, Moon, and Earth system.
Science and space exploration is constantly being improved and updated so we can get a better understanding of the
areas, which are outside of Earth's realm. Just as space is huge, so is the number of concepts that need to be
taught in order for students to gain a basic understanding of the topic. According to the Delaware State Science
Coalition, there are two essential questions, which need to be addressed in order for the students to be able to
build upon the grade four expectations. Those questions are: What predictable, observable patterns occur because of
the interaction between the Earth, Moon and Sun? and How has technology expanded our knowledge of the Earth, Moon
and Sun system? Both of these questions will be answered and expanded upon in this Unit. However, the Unit will also
cover other basics of astronomy that will help us give a better foundation for when the students advance on to the
upper grades. Therefore, the purpose for this Unit will be for students to learn about the relationships between the
Earth, Moon and Sun.
(Developed for Elementary Science, grade 3; recommended for Elementary Science, grade 3)
07.07.06 - Space Illustrated: There and Back
by Barbara C. Natale
This unit "Space Illustrated: There and Back" will provide students in grade four with an exciting opportunity to
explore the Solar System. During the lessons, students will come to the realization that Space and the technology of
Space is an interesting subject, one that they may determine to be a future career. I have planned the lessons to
embrace content material with several hands on activities. One, students will make a rocket ship and launch it into
"Space". Students will shrink down the Planets with objects and make an imaginary Solar System on the school
playground. Two, students will participate in an imaginary space trip, conduct an interview and publish a space
magazine. This magazine, called "Space Illustrated" will include an interview with an astronaut and pictures. This
magazine will be theirs to keep and enjoy. The class will share their magazine at Davis Street Interdistrict Magnet
School's publishing party in May.
Any teacher, regular or special education, can utilize any or all of this unit, modified or used as it is written.
These lessons allow teachers and students the opportunity to work together to better understand the mysteries of
outer space. Fourth graders are at a very impressionable age, and maybe one of the lessons in this unit will inspire
them to become an Astronaut and travel to a galaxy far, far away.
(Developed for Science, grade 4; recommended for Science, grade 4)
07.07.07 - The Science and Technology of the Apollo Space Program
by Francisca Eunice Gomez Rebullida
The science and technology of the Apollo Space Program is a curriculum unit written for second language learners in
the fifth grade. The unit could be adapted for mainstreamed fifth graders too. You can integrate English as a Second
Language Instruction with science/reading using the literature approach. Are you ready to travel historically to the
Moon with the astronauts? I am about to take you to the Moon with the former astronauts of the manned Apollo Space
Program. As we travel you will learn about the six Apollo Missions that took twelve astronauts to explore the Moon
and the other six astronauts who piloted the Command Module and returned safely to Earth. We will learn how the
astronauts explored the Moon and helped the scientists with their experiments of the lunar samples. The unit will
provide you information on the technology that allows humans to work on the Moon's environment. We will also read
about space exploration, how 400,000 people landed Apollo 11 on the Moon, and the first Hispanic woman astronaut.
You will learn how to become an astronaut, how astronauts live in space, and try space food. We will sing spacey
songs, read and write out- of -this world spacey stories. To blast off, tap into students' prior knowledge such as
space, weightlessness- zero g, microgravity, Newton' three laws and address misinformation that they may have
about space. So put on your space suits, and "climb aboard" the spacecraft. Are you ready? Ten. . .nine. . . eight.
. . seven. . . six. . . five. . . four. . . three. . . two. . . one. . . blast off!
(Developed for ESL and Science, grade 5; recommended for Science, grade 5)