Democracy in Theory and Practice

CONTENTS OF CURRICULUM UNIT 08.03.12

  1. Unit Guide
  1. Background
  2. Objectives
  3. Strategies
  4. Classroom Activities
  5. Resources
  6. Appendix
  7. Endnotes

Who decides who benefits? A comparative view of wealth distribution using examples from New Mexico's Legislature, Santa Fe City and the Pueblo of Pojoaque

Meredith Charlton Tilp

Published September 2008

Tools for this Unit:

Appendix

Grid A Graphic explaining analogous relationship between government and economics

Elements of Economic power Elements of Political Power
Consumers Voters
Goods and services Policies
Profits Votes
Firms Parties

Vocabulary lists:

*In the Magruder's textbook, an excellent translation into Spanish exists for these terms.

Democracy

Majority, minority

Will of the People

Articles of Confederation

Federalist anti-Federalist

Bill of Rights

Amendment

Sovereignty

Checks and Balances

Property

Capital

Investment

Per Capita Income

GDP/GNP

4 Factors of Production: land labor, capital and entrepreneurship

Wealth

Separation of Powers

Federalism

States Rights

Population

Ethnicity

Racial Group

Ancestral lands

Rural and Urban

Taxes: Progressive, Proportional and Regressive

Population Growth Rate

GRID B Comparative govt United States New Mexico Pojoaque
Symbol? Bald Eagle Zia Symbol Butterfly
Constitution? US dates 1789 based on principals of Social Contract Theory, Natural Rights, English Law and Iroquois League, 13 colonies NM based on US constitution 1911 No written agreement, verbal agreement based on Indian tribal philosophies and religion of respect and honor
Bill of Rights? Yes, Amendments 1-10; demanded after revolution because of States fear of Federal Government Included in NM Constitution as Article II: Sections 1-24 A form of Bill of Rights, not written, ex. Everyone is equal; and has equal voice? Women?
Population Served? 280 millions US Census 2000 1.3 million 277 tribal members
Universal Suffrage? All 18 years and older, registered and US Citizens All 18 years and older, registered and US Citizens 18 years and older tribal members
1. 3 Branches of Goverment?
2.Checks and Balances?
3.Limited Government
4.Popular Sovereignty
Yes, but Executive has veto and evolving power in times of terrorism and war.
2. Legislative Branch has power of the financial approvals
3. Over 50% of Americans don't participate
4. Washington DC is perceived as a out of touch with average Americans" Lobbying The War in Iraq $3 billion??
-Executive has power of line item veto.
-Citizen's Legislature all voluntary
-Participation??
Budget Surplus $1 Billion??
Formation of NM Film Industry
The Governor is key figure in proposing economic development.
??? Checks and Balances
??? Disagreements
Hilton Hotel Chain, Casinos $240 Million?
Name of Exec & Staff? Current George W. Bush, President
Richard Cheney, Vice President
Governor Bill Richardson
Lt. Gov. Diane Denish
George Rivera, Governor
Name of Legislature and composition? Congress House (432) and Senate (100)
Mainly white men changing
Nancy Pelosi, Speaker of House
Citizen Legislature
NM House 100
; NM Senate 33 Ben Lujan, Speaker of the House
Tribal Council 77 members; 3 meetings must be attended
Name of Judiciary? Supreme Court and Federal Courts (DC) NM Courts (Santa Fe) Tribal Courts but
Tribal Tradition of Elders
Executive Election Popular Vote but Electoral College Popular Vote Tribal members 18 years and older
How Laws are Made? Governor and Legislators work together Governor and Legislators work together Governor and Tribal Council

Evaluation Aspects

  • Pre-test analysis of concerns on democracy: distribution of wealth
  • Monday-Current events topics on the economy and distribution of wealth?-graded participation
  • Tuesday-Lecture or PowerPoint with individual homework-graded
  • Wednesday-Group project-group gets a grade
  • Thursday-individual classwork
  • Friday-Weekly test
  • Pre-and Post Career Planning-after students make the class trip, they write a question on what their career plans are. I keep a record of this, resume writing, interviewing skills, steps to pursue career goals (examples would be application to an internship, interview at Mervyn's etc.) and what the final outcome is at the time of graduation.

Seniors at Capital High School Notes

I teach US history and geography, government and economics to 125 Capital High School juniors and seniors living on the south side of Santa Fe, New Mexico. Recent immigrants from Mexico comprise approximately 40% of my students, another 40% of the students are "Hispanics," identifying with their Spanish ancestors as distinct from Mexican nationals, and the remaining 20% are white, black and Asian. So the majority is really divided in two parts.

There are sensitivities in teaching to this largely Hispanic group and differences of opinions that are personal. Some Mexican kids feel that they are sojourners in the land of opportunity and that not all of the United States' benefits are available to them. Some New Mexican students, on the other hand, feel there is not enough of the pie to go around, especially including those who are not legally in the United States. The teacher weighs each of these attitudes and intervenes where necessary and appropriate.

Because my classes are only 55 minutes long, week-long projects cover broad categories. Involving the students in planning and implementing the field trip is important and an opportunity for democratic decision making. Permissions are signed agreeing to behavior, grades and respect.

NM Benchmarks for 12 th Grade Government & Civics and Economics

Since the course I teach focuses on US government and economics, it will be relatively easy to integrate 'democracy' and 'distribution of wealth' into my curriculum. The New Mexico Benchmarks in Government state that 11 & 12 th graders should be able to analyze the structure, function, and powers of the federal government (e.g., legislative, executive, and judicial branches and should be able to the philosophical foundations of the American political system in terms of the inalienable rights of people and the purpose of government. In addition, Benchmarks in Economics state that these same students should be able to fully participate and understand how economic decisions are made.

Comments:

Add a Comment

Characters Left: 500

Unit Survey

Feedback