Colours of Humanity: Artistic representations of the "Other"
Raymond Marshall
Published September 2023
Tools for this Unit:
Course Material
American Nations, by Colin Woodard16
This work recasts American History not as a story of a unified country, as we so often tell it, but
rather as a story of various nations of people who have, due to historical circumstance and sometimes
necessity, found themselves presenting as a single country, the United States. It then uses this
framework to examine, amongst other questions, how the different “American Nations” treated
the indigenous people so differently, from the intermarriage and benign treatment of the French to the
exploitative and hostile attitudes of the early English Puritans, and how these attitudes informed the
actions of the United States all the way through westward expansion. This book, particularly the first
set of chapters about the founding of the nations through Greater Appalachia, will be very valuable not
only as a different way of looking at history, but will provide further depth to the Alien Invasion
narrative device. Ask the students, what if different factions of aliens treated your people
differently than the others, some better, some worse. How would you react?
America Pox, the Missing Plague17
It would be irresponsible to talk about the history of colonization without addressing the part that
disease played in paving the way for the colonial powers in the New World. This video discusses some of
the horrors of the plague of new disease that swept through Native American populations after the
beginnings of European exploration, but is primarily focused on a question which is not often asked: Why
didn’t a corresponding wave of disease hit Europe in return? The reasons for this lack of
“America Pox” in the history of medicine cast new light on how the people of the New World
lived, and encourages students to break from a purely Occidental focused worldview to better appreciate
the ways in which Pre-Columbian American society was, in some ways, superior to that of their European
counterparts. This can be used to not only allow for a better understanding of plagues of the New
World, but also to reframe students’ understanding of the entire colonial process, as well as
helping to answer common questions such as “why couldn’t the Indians fight back
effectively?”
Yale Art gallery
Due to its generous access policy regarding usage of its artwork for these course units (and indeed in
general) the Yale Art Gallery holds a large amount of artistic works suitable for discussion on this
topic. As a result, I have made an effort to pull as many of these works as possible from their
collection, both for the simplification of copyright issues in this unit, as well as to allow for easy
access and presentation to any teachers who want to use it in the future. I encourage any teacher
reading this to take some time to browse through the University’s expansive archive for any
striking pieces of art not mentioned in this course unit summary, and replace any mentioned pieces of
art with ones that they find more striking or relevant to their class’s interests.
Comments: