Asian American History and the Making of the U.S. Immigration System

CONTENTS OF CURRICULUM UNIT 26.03.09

  1. Unit Guide
  1. Overview
  2. Demographics
  3. Rationale
  4. Content
  5. Teaching Strategies
  6. Classroom Activities
  7. Appendix On Implementing District Standards
  8. Resources
  9. Annotated Bibliography
  10. Notes

Who Belongs? Immigration, Disability, and the Making of Belonging

Aryanne Young

Published September 2026

Tools for this Unit:

Teaching Strategies

Reading Like a Historian: Disciplinary Literacy

This unit uses disciplinary literacy to teach students to approach sources as historians rather than simply memorize facts.[57] Students ask who created a source, why it was created, whose voices are represented, and what evidence it provides. They apply these questions to immigration laws, photographs, memoirs, poetry, maps, medical documents, and oral histories, learning that historical sources offer perspectives rather than complete accounts of the past.

Building Understanding Through Scaffolding

Because many of my students are multilingual learners and students with intellectual and developmental disabilities, each instructional cycle follows a predictable routine. Lessons move from explicit modeling and guided practice toward collaborative inquiry and independent reflection. This structure draws on the Gradual Release of Responsibility model, providing support while gradually increasing student independence.[58]

Developing Academic Language and Thinking

Students repeatedly encounter a small set of high-utility concepts, including belonging, exclusion, citizenship, identity, resistance, and advocacy, rather than memorizing long lists of isolated terms.[59] They also reflect on what they know, how evidence changes their thinking, and which strategies help them understand complex sources, building greater independence as learners.

Designing for Access: UDL

Universal Design for Learning is embedded throughout the unit rather than added after barriers emerge.[60] Students encounter history through photographs, maps, poetry, memoirs, oral histories, and government documents and can demonstrate understanding through writing, discussion, art, multimedia, or oral presentation. These options provide different pathways to the same rigorous historical thinking.

Building Connections Across Time

The Historical Connections Framework helps students connect new knowledge to existing ideas and organize information around larger concepts. Each cycle moves from a historical case study to a contemporary parallel and then to a personal or community connection. Returning to concepts such as belonging, exclusion, identity, and resistance helps students recognize patterns across time rather than viewing historical events in isolation.

Together, these strategies make historical inquiry accessible without reducing its complexity. Students are supported in analyzing evidence, making connections, and developing their own interpretations of the past.

Comments:

Add a Comment

Characters Left: 500