Race, Class, and Punishment

CONTENTS OF CURRICULUM UNIT 18.01.08

  1. Unit Guide
  1. Rationale
  2. School Demographics
  3. Unit
  4. Background Information
  5. Strategies
  6. Lesson Plans
  7. Appendix
  8. Bibliography
  9. Endnotes

Understanding the System: A History of Prison and the Virginia Juvenile Justice System

Rodney Alexander Robinson

Published September 2018

Tools for this Unit:

Lesson Plans

Day 1 – Introduction

  • Students will analyze “Letter to the Free” by Common
  • Introduction – Students will document their experiences with the criminal justice system in their journals
  • Students will do a gallery walk of political cartoons and pictures related to the criminal justice system.

Day 2  

Students will read and answer questions from Race to Incarcerate: A Graphic Retelling

Ch. 1 – US Prisons from Inception to Export 

  • What is the purpose of prison?
  • Give at least 3 characteristics of early prisons in the United States.
  • What are the proactive ways to influence human behavior according to the book?
  • Give at least 3 similarities between early prisons and the Richmond Juvenile Detention Center.

Students will answer one discussion question in a one-page journal entry

  • What are some ways to influence human behavior positively and negatively?
  • Would your current case be different if you had a high-powered lawyer? Explain

Class Activities

  • Students will examine the DJJ Historical Timeline and correlate it with national crime debates.
  • Students will watch video clips from Slavery by Another Name
  • Students will analyze “Letter to the Free” by Common

Day 3

Students will read and answer questions from Race to Incarcerate: A Graphic Retelling

2 – The Rise of the “Tough on Crime” Movement

  • Explain indeterminate sentencing.
  • How did the George Jackson case illustrate the problems with indeterminate sentencing?
  • Explain the racial overtones eying Nixon’s “law and order” campaign.
  • Differentiate between conservative (right) and Liberal (left) approaches to rehabilitation.

Students will answer one discussion question in a one-page journal entry

  • Do you agree with this practice of indeterminate sentencing? Explain
  • Do you believe the story of what happened in George Jackson’s attempted escape? Explain
  • Which philosophical approach to rehabilitation fits your beliefs? Explain

Class Activities

  • Students will examine the DJJ Historical Timeline and correlate it with national crime debates.
  • Students will analyze Supreme Court case Terry vs Ohio in relation to the constitutionality of modern police policies.

Day 4

Students will read and answer questions from Race to Incarcerate: A Graphic Retelling

3 - The Triumph of the “Tough on Crime” Movement 

  • Give 3 reasons why crime rose in the 1960’s.
  • What 2 groups were to blame for a breakdown in law and order?
  • Explain “moral malaise”.

Students will answer one discussion question in a one-page journal entry

  • Do population increases play a role in crime?
  • What role did race play in Nixon’s “law and order” campaign?

Class Activities

  • Students will examine the DJJ Historical Timeline and correlate it with national crime debates.

Day 5

Students will read and answer questions from Race to Incarcerate: A Graphic Retelling

4 – The Rock Gets Rolling/ 

  • What were the Rockefeller drug laws?
  • What was the purpose of state sentencing commissions?
  • Does gun control have an effect on crime?

Students will answer one discussion question in a one-page journal entry

  • Are sentencing commissions a good idea? Explain

Class Activities

  • Students will examine the DJJ Historical Timeline and correlate it with national crime debates.
  • Students will research politicians committed to reducing the cocaine/crack disparity laws.

Day 6

Students will read and answer questions from Race to Incarcerate: A Graphic Retelling

5 - Crime as Politics: The Reagan Bush Years 

  • Explain Ronald Reagan’s philosophy concerning government and social problems.
  • What laws were passed as a result of the Len Bias tragedy?
  • What were the results of the 1983 study by the Reagan Justice Department?
  • How much did spending on prisons increase during the Bush/Reagan years?

Students will answer one discussion question in a one-page journal entry

  • Do you believe in rugged individualism?
  • Does the media have a responsibility to tell the truth or to make viewers/readers buy their product?

Class Activities

  • Students will examine the DJJ Historical Timeline and correlate it with national crime debates.
  • Students will analyze the song “Reagan” by Killer Mike

Day 7

Students will read and answer questions from Race to Incarcerate: A Graphic Retelling

6 – Kemba Smith  

  • How long did Kemba Smith receive in prison?
  • What crimes were she guilty of committing?
  • What was the hypocrisy in Bill Clinton commuting her sentence?

Students will answer one discussion question in a one-page journal entry

  • Do you think Kemba Smith was implicit in her own demise? Explain
  • Do you agree with her sentence? Explain

Class Activities

  • Students will examine the DJJ Historical Timeline and correlate it with national crime debates.

Day 8

Students will read and answer questions from Race to Incarcerate: A Graphic Retelling

7 – Crime as Politics: Clinton Years 

  • What were the components of President Clinton’s mixed approach to fighting crime?
  • Explain the role the media played in passage of the 1994 crime bill?
  • What objections did Janet Reno have to the 1994 crime bill?
  • What was included in the 1994 crime bill?
  • How did state governments benefit from the 1994 crime bill?

Students will answer one discussion question in a one-page journal entry

Should America abolish the death penalty? Explain

  • Does the media have a responsibility to tell the truth or to make viewers/readers buy their product?
  • Should politicians be judged for their rhetoric or their actions?

Class Activities

  • Students will examine the DJJ Historical Timeline and correlate it with national crime debates.
  • Students will watch and analyze clips from the movie “13th”

Day 9

Students will read and answer questions from Race to Incarcerate: A Graphic Retelling

8 – Crime as Politics: George W Bush Years

  • Explain “compassionate conservatism”.
  • What did Bush propose to Congress?
  • Explain the sentencing disparity between crack and cocaine.
  • How much did federal prisons grow during the Bush years?

Students will answer one discussion question in a one-page journal entry

  • Do you agree with the philosophy of compassionate conservatism?
  • Does the Attorney General have too much or too little power in the war on drugs? Explain

Class Activities

  • Students will examine the DJJ Historical Timeline and correlate it with national crime debates.

Day 10

Students will read and answer questions from Race to Incarcerate: A Graphic Retelling

9 – The Prison/Crime Connection 

  • How did the rise in prison populations correlate with crime statistics?
  • What does the author suggest as factors to a decline in crime?
  • List 3 crime reduction stats in New York City in the 1990’s.
  • Explain 3 reasons for the reduction in crime in New York City in the 1990’s.

Students will answer one discussion question in a one-page journal entry 

  • Why don’t more prisons equal less crime?
  • What factors do you believe results in less crime?

Class Activities

  • Students will analyze statistics from Virginia Department of Juvenile Justice Reports on Crime and ethnicity in Virginia

Day 11

Students will read and answer questions from Race to Incarcerate: A Graphic Retelling

10 – Color Coded Justice 

  • What percentage of black boys born after 2000 will spend time in prison?
  • List 3 immigrant groups and the criminal stereotypes associated with each group.
  • Explain convict leasing.
  • What is a super predator?
  • Explain 3 factors of the criminal justice system that led to more black people being in jail.

Students will answer one discussion question in a one-page journal entry

  • What racial stereotypes do you believe? Explain
  • Do you think America would give more attention to prison issues if the majority of prisoners were white? Explain

Class Activities

  • Students will analyze statistics from Virginia Department of Juvenile Justice Reports on Crime and ethnicity in Virginia. They will compare and contrast the types of crimes committed in 4 different DJJ jurisdictions (Richmond, Norfolk, Fairfax, and Shenandoah).

Day 12

Students will read and answer questions from Race to Incarcerate: A Graphic Retelling

11 – The War on Drugs and African Americans 

  • Explain the correlation between African American population statistics and drug arrest statistics.
  • What happens during a drug sweep?
  • Explain how mandatory sentences have increased the prison disparity for African Americans.
  • How did court jurisdiction increase the prison disparity for African Americans?
  • List 3 other life factors are affected by the war of drugs.
  • List 4 ways to reduce the prison population due to the War on Drugs.

Students will answer one discussion question in a one-page journal entry 

  • Are drug sweeps a violation of the 4th amendment?
  • Are drug sweeps a violation of the 14th amendment?
  • Explain a positive and a negative interaction with a police officer.

Class Activities

  • Students will read excerpts from Ch. 5 of Locking Up Our Own “The Worst Think to Hit Us Since Slavery: Crack and the Advent of Warrior Policing”
  • Students will read excerpts from Ch 7 of Chokehold, “If You Catch a Case, Act Like You Know”

Day 13

Students will read and answer questions from Race to Incarcerate: A Graphic Retelling

12 – A New Direction 

  • List 3 alternatives to incarceration.
  • Explain community policing.
  • Explain how the criminal justice system has disenfranchised African Americans.
  • What is restorative justice?

Students will answer one discussion question in a one-page journal entry

  • What do you think would be an alternative to prisoning? Explain
  • What can police do to improve their relationships with the community?
  • What can the community do to improve their relationships with police?

Class Activities

  • Students will research hip hop songs about police tactics and prison system and create an oral report on the meaning of the song
  • Students will create a letter to their younger self on how to avoid the pitfalls of juvenile prison.

Day 14

Class Activities

  • Students will edit their letters to their younger self on how to avoid the pitfalls of juvenile prison

Day 15

Class Activities

  • Students will research pictures for a visual timeline to be displayed in Detention Center hallway or in a computer-generated slideshow. The pictures must represent key points in American history that produced an increase in the prison population. 

Comments:

Add a Comment

Characters Left: 500

Unit Survey

Feedback