Classroom Activities
My unit emphasizes that writing a defensible, persuasive argument essay is a key academic skill for high school students, laying the foundation for effective communication, critical thinking, and civic engagement. This unit emphasizes the benefits of incorporating debates and structured discussions into high school settings. Teachers who opt to use my curriculum unit will find that the resources I have provided will complement their existing pedagogical practice. One aspect of improving student outcomes is the promotion of student engagement. “The benefits of using in-class debates as an instructional strategy also include mastery of the content and the development of critical thinking skills, empathy, and oral communication skills. 50
Debates and structured discussions require students to rigorously analyze different sides of an issue, construct logical arguments, and anticipate counterarguments. According to Zare and Othman (2013), participation in classroom debates enhances analytical thinking by requiring students to break down complex issues and evaluate evidence critically.51 “This analytical process directly translates to persuasive writing, where students must present claims, support them with evidence, and address opposing viewpoints to craft defensible arguments 52
In a peer-reviewed study examining the impact of debates on learning outcomes, Akerman and Neale (2011) found that “debate encourages students to think more deeply about content, organize their ideas logically, and develop evaluative judgment.”53 My pedagogical practice includes helping my students develop cognitive skills to enhance their understanding and implementation of the fundamentals that are integral to writing strong, persuasive essays, where defensibility depends on the writer’s ability to analyze information and present structured, well-reasoned arguments.
Socratic Seminars
Furthermore, structured discussions often incorporate protocols such as Socratic Seminars or Philosophical Chairs, which require participants to cite evidence for their contributions.54 The emphasis on evidence-based reasoning helps student to be consistent in supporting their arguments with data, expert opinions, and textual references—an indispensable skill for writing defensible essays.
Traditional essay writing can sometimes feel abstract or disconnected from students’ experiences. In contrast, debates and structured discussions make argumentation immediate, dynamic, and personally meaningful. As Brooks and Brooks (2001) assert, “active engagement in debate increases student motivation, investment in learning, and willingness to grapple with challenging concepts.”55 I have my students speak in defense of an idea before their peers, the stakes feel real, and the principles of persuasion become more tangible.
This engagement translates to writing, as students who have debated an issue or participated in structured discussions tend to be more invested in the arguments they present on paper. Research by Goodwin et al. (2023) demonstrates that students who participate in classroom debates report higher confidence and greater willingness to revise and defend their written arguments.56
Debates and Structured Discussion Skill Development
Effective persuasive essays require clarity, coherence, and an awareness of the audience. Debates and structured discussions cultivate these communication skills by encouraging students to articulate their ideas clearly, listen actively to others, and respond thoughtfully. According to Kennedy (2007), “students learn to adapt their language, tone, and rhetorical strategies in response to their audience, a transferable skill that strengthens their writing.”57 This emphasis on transferable skills underscores the broader impact of these methods on students' communication abilities.
Additionally, structured discussions often involve collaborative exploration of ideas, teaching students how to build on others’ contributions and negotiate meaning. This cooperative aspect supports the development of nuanced, well-rounded arguments in essays by exposing students to diverse perspectives and approaches to reasoning. The social learning aspect of these methods is a key factor in their effectiveness.
Debates and structured discussions model respectful discourse and teach students how to disagree constructively—crucial competencies for persuasive writing. When students engage with opposing viewpoints in a discussion, they learn to anticipate counterarguments and respond civilly, strengthening the defensibility of their positions 58
Socratic Seminars, for example, are designed to promote deep listening and thoughtful questioning, enabling students to refine their ideas through dialogue rather than confrontation . 59 These practices foster intellectual humility and the ability to view issues from multiple angles—traits that make for more compelling and defensible essays.
There is significant coaction between oral argumentation in debates/discussions and written argumentation in essays. Bellon (2000) notes that “the skills students develop through oral debate—constructing logical arguments, supporting claims with evidence, and rebutting counterarguments—are directly applicable to persuasive essay writing.”60
Through the iterative process of debate, students test and refine their reasoning in real time, which helps them identify the strongest arguments and anticipate weaknesses before committing ideas to paper. This bridge between speaking and writing enhances students’ ability to produce coherent, defensible arguments in their essays.
Several studies have empirically demonstrated the positive impact of debates and structured discussions on persuasive writing performance. Zare and Othman (2013) found a statistically significant improvement in students' compelling writing scores after participating in classroom debates, attributing the gains to heightened analytical skills and better organization.58 Similarly, Goodwin (2003) observed that students who engaged in debate-based instruction produced “more focused, thoroughly supported, and logically structured essays” than those taught through traditional methods.”61
The process of argument writing extends beyond simply stating opinions; it requires the logical organization of ideas, the use of credible evidence, and the anticipation and rebuttal of counterarguments. To foster proficiency and confidence in these skills, teachers can implement a range of research-backed classroom activities that actively engage students and promote positive learning outcomes.
Debates and Structured Discussions Activity
Activity: Organize debates where students argue for or against a given topic. Assign roles—pro, con, moderator, or audience. After the discussion, students write an argumentative essay based on their stance.
Purpose: Engages students in oral argumentation, requires them to consider multiple perspectives, and builds confidence in presenting and defending their views.
Research Support: According to Kuhn and Crowell (2011), classroom debates foster argumentation skills and help students understand how to construct and critique arguments, resulting in improved essay writing.60
Counterclaim Carousel Activity
Activity: Have students write a claim on a sticky note and pass it around the class. Each student adds a possible counterclaim or rebuttal, rotating until several peers have addressed all claims.
Purpose: Reinforces the importance of addressing counterarguments and strengthens students' ability to anticipate opposing viewpoints.
Research Support: Graham and Perin (2007) report that activities emphasizing the development of counterclaims and rebuttals significantly improve students' argumentative essays. 62
Peer Review Workshops Activity
After drafting their essays, I instruct my students to exchange papers with classmates and provide them with a guided rubric to offer constructive feedback on thesis statements, evidence, organization, and style. This practice promotes collaborative learning, helps them to improve their revision skills, and encourages the practice of self-reflection. The point here is that the practice of peer review promotes high-quality revisions and enhances the content and outcomes of persuasive argument essay writing.
Comments: